He felt her hand on his forehead to signal she’d had enough. David got on his knees and then sat back with a big grin on his face.
“I bet my worthless brother never made you cum like that,” he teased.
Lexi huffed out a laugh as he resumed playing his role.
“You’re so frickin’ competitive. I bet if I admitted to that, you wouldn’t be able to resist lording that over Greg, and I like him way too much to ever do that to him,” she said.
“I’ll let you try to fool yourself, but we both know,” David said confidently as he went to the nightstand to get a condom.
When he got back on the bed, Lexi snatched the condom out of his hand and tossed it to the side.
“You don’t need that,” she said, looking him dead in the eye.
“Welp,” was all he could come up with.
If this was supposed to be Joey...
The sexual beast inside David objected to any rational thought, saying, ’Fuck condoms!’
“I don’t want anything coming between us,” Lexi assured him.
When it was really him and Lexi, they didn’t use them. Thinking about going bareback with Joey just felt wrong, but he sort of liked the evil twist Lexi had put on this little sexual drama. He took her at her word when she spread her thighs, reached up and grabbed his cock, pulled him to where she wanted, and then laid back.
David looked down as the big head of his dick pushed between her folds and began to sink inside her. Lexi sold the whole ‘Mr. Happy is massive’ storyline as she got a pained expression and cried out.
“Shit, I’m hurting you,” David worried.
Her eyes flew open.
“Don’t you dare stop,” she ordered. “It’s just that you’re a big boy. Give me a second to get used to it.”
David’s balls tightened when he felt her inner walls spasm. He quickly began to think of dead kittens. When that didn’t work, he thought about Cassidy threatening to rip his dick off. Funny how that brought him away from the ledge.
“Give me all of it,” Lexi ordered.
David pushed all the way in until his balls rested against her awe-inspiring ass. As he felt her wrapped around his shaft, he realized he loved this fantasy. The reality was indescribable. He’d had sex with a lot of women, but Lexi might feel the best of all of them, and she was right there, under him.
She grunted to let him know she was ready. David made it his goal to conquer her and slowly began to saw in and out of her sex. He was almost mesmerized, watching her inner walls cling to his dick each time he would pull back. Then it was as if her body would suck him back into her depths. His overinflated ego swelled even more when he saw how she responded to him as she played out her role.
Since he’d been able to thwart coming too soon, he fell into the zone. It was the same one he used when playing ball. Everything around David faded away, and it was just him and Lexi. He pulled out all the tricks he’d learned over the years. David made short, rapid, shallow thrusts followed by long, slow movements. He held off the sensation of his impending orgasm until he knew he had it under control.
He smiled because he knew he could go all day now.
David brought Lexi off again and again as she wiggled and squirmed under him. Then her pussy clamped down hard. He blinked in surprise, and that familiar sensation rushed forward, not to be denied this time. It was as if her body sucked the cum straight from his balls. David grabbed her hips and went to pound town to squeeze out every last ounce of pleasure.
Lexi’s thighs clamped tight around his waist as he roared his release.
They both collapsed in a sweaty, gasping mess.
“What the heck was that?” she asked.
“A good start,” David said.
After they recovered, David dressed, went to the living room, and found the real Joey. He had a few questions.
“What’s really going on? Are you and Greg having problems?”
“No, nothing like that. There’s nothing sinister; I just wanted to thank you. Since I assume you have everything you want, I figured that might work,” Joey explained.
“Just so we’re clear, that’ll never happen,” David said.
“Are you mad at me?” she asked.
“Not at all. This is all on me.”
“That sounds an awful lot like the ‘it’s not you, it’s me’ BS you tell someone when you break up,” Joey said.
“I made a promise to my mom when I saw what an affair did to their marriage. If anything, I’m beating myself up because I came close to not keeping my word of never being the other man, so to speak. And it has nothing to do with Greg giving me the go-ahead,” David explained.
“And you just missed out.”
“That’s the downside, I’ll admit, and I’m sure it’s a considerable downside. But I have to think more and not just let my dick make decisions for me. As much as I hate it, I’m a role model to my kids and others. If I ran off with every girl who offered herself to me, I would quickly become the typical jock or Hollywood douche. I have to constantly remember that not everything I do behind closed doors will stay there. That’s why I try not to jump from bed to bed,” David said.
“Is that why you and Lexi hook up?”
“If we did hook up, it would be because that’s what we decided to do. The side benefit would be that I wouldn’t be hooking up with some starlet who only slept with me to keep her spot on a film or wanted publicity. Both of those have happened in the past,” he shared.
“You’re as bad as Greg at not talking about your sex life with others. What happened to Phil?” Joey asked.
“Greg and I need to talk to him. Not just about that, either. Looking back over the last few days, I’ve come to realize we haven’t been there for him like we should. I keep forgetting that he’s new to the family, and some of the shit Greg and I give each other is probably a bit much for him. He was raised as an only child and never had siblings to give him a hard time,” David said.
“I understand he moved to your high school to get to know you. How will he cope with your dad, Greg, and you all living in LA?” she asked.
“That’s probably a good question that I need to talk to my family about.”
“Better yet, you need to talk to Phil,” she said.
“He’ll be off to college after next year, too. I would hate to see him resent us and not keep in touch. I think about all the friends I had back home, and so many of them I don’t even seem to miss,” David said.
“You don’t really lose family. If you do, it’s typically caused by a two-way-street type of situation. If you make a conscious effort to keep in touch, you’ll be fine,” Joey predicted.
David saw that he’d fallen down on that. He’d only known Phil for a couple of years, and unlike Greg, who he’d known all his life, Phil had never actually lived under their roof. David had Greg underfoot for sixteen years before he moved out to go to college. That was a big difference, and David had to find a way to bridge that gap.
“There’s something else I need to tell you,” Joey said.
“What’s that?”
“Greg and I talked to Lexi about doing a foursome.”
David stiffened for a moment. He really wished she hadn’t shared that with him. While he and Lexi weren’t exclusive...
“Not happening,” he said.
“I didn’t think so.”
“And in the future, just tell me ‘Thank you,’” David said with a smile.
“You didn’t appreciate my attempted gift?” she teased.
“If only you had listened to me after I graduated, this might have been a whole different discussion. But we can’t live in a world full of ‘what ifs.’ You and Greg are together, and I think you made the right choice. He is probably the best guy I know,” David said as he felt his emotions start to get the better of him.
It was true that his older brother meant the world to him. Now he had to figure out how to get there with his younger one.
Developmental Editors: XofDallas and Bud Ugly