“Milady and Sir Richard request that you attend them as soon as you are able,” he told the Templar. “I’ve just been trying to help them with a list they’re making of men in the town that might be this damned Mauger Rivelar.” He shrugged regretfully. “I wasn’t much help, I fear.”
When he reached Nicolaa’s chamber, Richard was with her, discussing each of the names on the list they had compiled. As Bascot entered, the castellan looked at him expectantly. “Was the potter able to give you any additional details about Mauger’s appearance?”
“Only that he might have blue eyes,” Bascot replied. “That is all.”
Nicolaa sat back in her chair, disappointed. “We have been trying to recall John Rivelar’s appearance in more detail,” she said, “but our memories contain nothing remarkable.” She tapped the piece of parchment on the table in front of her. “Many of the men on this list could be his son, but lacking some definitive feature to set one apart from the others, it is impossible to tell which of them it could be.”
Bascot picked up the list and scanned it. It was separated into three parts-castle, town and priory. The listing for the castle household had just over half a dozen names with Gosbert’s assistant, Eric, at the top followed by six more, and ending with the name of Gilles de Laubrec, the marshal. Bascot was surprised at the knight’s inclusion.
“I had not expected to see de Laubrec’s name here,” he said.
Richard gave a nod of reluctance. “He took up his post in my father’s retinue just before you came yourself, de Marins, and so his arrival is within the two-year space of time during which Mauger could have returned to Lincoln. De Laubrec told us that he was formerly in the retinue of a lord in Normandy, but…” Richard rubbed a hand over his mouth as though to stop himself from voicing his misgivings, “if Mauger gained some skill at arms during the ten years he was absent, the pretence of being a landless knight in a distant demesne would not be difficult to assume. We can send a messenger to Normandy, of course, and ask the baron if de Laubrec is telling the truth, but it would take many weeks before we knew the answer. We do not have that much time.”
“The same can be said of most of the others on the list,” Nicolaa added. “Eric came to me saying he had been in the employ of a woman with whom I am acquainted but have not seen for many years. He gave me details of her household and the manor house in which she lives. I did not question his veracity.” She pointed to some of the other names. “You will also see that Martin, the castle leech, is here, along with Lambert, John Blund’s clerk. Martin told us he served his apprenticeship for leechcraft in the company of a physician from London while they were both in the retinue of one of the Marcher lords on the Welsh border. Lambert says he comes from Exeter, in Devon, and claims he was taught to scribe at a schola there. Their bona fides, like the marshal’s, can all be checked but, as Richard says, it will take a long while to do so.”
Bascot pointed to the second category on the list, that of the priory, where the names of Brother Andrew and two other monks were written down. “It should not be as difficult with these men. The church is scrupulous in investigating the backgrounds of any men requesting admission to their ranks.”
Richard got up and began to pace. “You would think so, de Marins,” he said, “but I have been to All Saints and spoken in confidence to the prior, and that is not always so. Andrew claims to come from the land of the Scots, and to have been a member of a Benedictine monastery on one of the many small and remote islands off the northern coast of Scotland. He brought with him a letter from the abbot there, saying Andrew wished to extend his knowledge by studying under Brother Jehan, whose renown as an herbalist is well-known.”
He gave Bascot a look of irritation. “Unless we send an enquiry to the Scottish monastery, how are we to know that Mauger did not adopt the guise of Andrew to gain access to the priory? In the ten years he has been away, he could easily have become skilled in scribing and written the letter himself. The prior seems to think he is sincere.”
“Andrew, by his own admission, had easy access to the shelf where the pot was kept in the priory,” Bascot mused, “but so do the many people of the town who come to the infirmary for aid when they are ill.”
“Exactly,” Richard replied.
“I have asked Roget to enquire discreetly about those who live in the town,” Nicolaa said, pointing to the section where ten names were recorded, “but it will not be easy to ask their neighbours for information without revealing the purpose for it.”
“We seem to be at a standstill,” Bascot said.
Their frustration was like a physical presence in the room, as though a fog had descended and engulfed them. Nicolaa stood up, breaking the tension. “We must press onwards, regardless of how hopeless it seems, until we find some way to uncover Mauger’s false identity. There is no other option left open to us.”
That evening, Bascot sat with Ernulf in the small cubicle in the barracks that the serjeant used for a sleeping place, sharing a pot of ale. Even though the room was screened off by a leather curtain from the large open space that housed the soldiers of the garrison, they were talking quietly lest they be overheard. In a corner, Gianni sat listening to their conversation while he used the wax tablet to practice his competence with Latin phrases.
The Templar and the serjeant were discussing the names on the list Nicolaa and Richard had prepared.
“I can’t believe ’twould be any of those in the castle,” Ernulf said. “Especially Sir Gilles. He has never given, by word or sign, that he is other than what he claims to be.”
“Neither has Martin,” said Bascot. “A man becomes a leech, I would have thought, because he wants to heal people, not kill them.”
Ernulf took another swig of ale. “Could be the clerk, Lambert, I suppose,” he said. “He’s allus seemed to me to be a sly fellow. I put it down to him coming from Devon. I knew a lass from those parts once; she was as bright and pretty as a new minted penny, but she slipped my purse with a month’s wages off my belt and was gone before I’d had time to take the kiss she’d promised me. Never trusted anyone from Devon after that.”
He looked at Bascot. “Course, if Lambert is Mauger, he never would of come from Devon, anyway, so maybe his slyness has more to it than I thought.”
The serjeant’s logic was convoluted, but Bascot nodded in agreement as Ernulf added, “Milady said it was possible that the monk that helps Jehan in the infirmary could be Mauger, the one who calls himself Brother Andrew.” The serjeant shook his head in despair. “Don’t like to think that a man of God could be responsible for killing all those people but then, if he’s only posing as a monk, I suppose it might make sense.” He hawked and spat on the ground. “If ’tis that assistant of Gosbert’s, I’ll skewer him on a spit and roast him like a pig over an open fire. He’ll not die quick, I promise you that.”
At that moment, the leather curtain over the cubicle rattled and Roget entered. The expression on his face did nothing to lighten the despondency that Ernulf’s words had invoked. The former mercenary looked disgruntled and tired; the scar down one side of his face seemed deeper and his eyes were dull. He was carrying a stoppered flagon of wine and poured himself a generous measure before offering it to the others. When they shook their heads, he sat down heavily on a stool.
“I have just finished giving my report to Lady Nicolaa,” he told them. “I tried to find out what I could about the people whose names she gave me but discovered little that might help us. It could be none of them, or all. Everyone seems to be what he says he is, but how are we to know who is telling the truth and who is not?” He took a long swallow of his wine and cursed long and hard. “ Mon Dieu, it is like going into battle with a sack over your head. You know the enemy is there, but you cannot see him.”