‘I did not know that Sister Muirgel was part of the group until weset out. I decided that I could avoid her immediate company on the journey.’
‘Did you know her personally, or only by the fact that she was the daughter of a chieftain whom you disliked?’
‘I knew her from the stories that circulated within our abbey.’
‘What stories?’ Fidelma was curious.
‘Of her promiscuity, of her unchaste relations with other Brothers. Of the way she used people for her own ends, and the fact that she was the opposite to a truly religious person.’
‘That is a harsh judgement of a Sister,’ observed Fidelma.
‘One greater than I will be her judge. “Look eagerly for the coming of the Day of Judgement and work to hasten it on; that day will set the heavens ablaze until they fall apart, and will melt the elements in flames. But we have His promise, and look forward to new heavens and a new earth which is the home of justice”.’
Fidelma was not impressed with his quotation from the Holy Book and ignored it.
‘How is it that such stories came to circulate in your Abbey of Bangor when Muirgel was a religieuse at Moville?’
‘There was plenty of intercourse between our two communities. Our Abbot often had cause to send to his Brother the Abbot of Moville. Once he had to inform him that he had heard such tales and that he must not let his community descend into a sink of iniquity.’
‘How did the Abbot of Moville respond?’
‘He did not.’
‘Perhaps he thought that it was not the place of the Abbot of Bangor to tell him how to lead his community?’ Fidelma smiled without humour. ‘Anyway, you formed a harsh judgement of Sister Muirgel.
Brother Tola nodded and intoned:
‘A prostitute is a deep pit,
A loose woman, a narrow well;
She lies in wait like a robber …’
Fidelma interrupted him sharply.
‘Apart from the fact that I seem to recall that Christ said harlots would enter heaven before some religious leaders, are you now saying that Sister Muirgel was a harlot?’
Tola merely continued his quotation from the Book of Proverbs.
‘I glanced out of the window of my house,
I looked down through the lattice, and I saw among simple
youths,
There amongst the boys I noticed
A lad, a foolish lad,
Passing along the street, at the corner,
Creeping out in the direction of her house
At twilight, as the day faded,
At dusk as the night grew dark;
Suddenly a woman came to meet him,
Dressed like a prostitute, full of wiles,
Flighty and inconstant,
A woman never content to stay at home,
Lying in wait at every corner,
Now in the street, now in the public squares.
She caught hold of him and kissed him;
Brazenly she accosted him and said,
“I have had a sacrifice, an offering to make, and I have paid my
vows today” …’
Fidelma held up a hand to quell his sonorous recital and finally had to cut in sharply.
‘I think I can also recall the words of Proverbs, seven. What are you saying by reciting that passage? You disapproved of Sister Muirgel because she had relationships with men, or that she was selling her body to whoever paid? Let us be precise about it. What is your definition of a harlot?’
‘You are the lawyer, you may interpret as you please. All I say is let the simple fools follow her like oxen on their way to the slaughterhouse.’
She had heard the same narrow views preached before by several religieux who argued for the reform of the Irish Church in favour of the concepts of Rome. She decided to clarify his attitude.
‘Tell me, Brother Tola, are you one of those who believe that the religieux should be celibate? I have often heard the argument at Rome.’
‘Does not Matthew say that our Lord Christ ordained celibacy for His followers?’
It was a favourite argument of those who wished all religieux to take an oath of celibacy. Fidelma had heard it many times and had no problem about the answer.
‘When the disciple asked Christ whether it was better not to marry, He replied that celibacy was not something everyone could accept; itwas only meant for those for whom God had appointed celibacy. His words were that while some are incapable of marriage because they were born so, or were made so by men, there were, indeed, others who had themselves renounced marriage for the sake of the Kingdom of Heaven. He left it as the choice of the individual. Let those accept it who can. So far the churches of Christ have adhered to that free choice …’
Tola’s features expressed irritation. He obviously did not like being out-quoted from the Scriptures.
‘I accept the teachings of Paul on this matter. Celibacy is the ideal of a Christian victory over the evil of the world and must become the main basis of religious life.’
‘There is a lobby in Rome who believe in this celibacy,’ agreed Fidelma, her tone indicating that she did not think much of the argument. ‘But if Rome accepts it as a dogma of the Faith, they say that the Faith stands against that which God created. Had God wanted us to be celibate, he would have made us so. However, instead of theology, I would prefer to return to the matter in hand. You clearly did not like Sister Muirgel.’
‘I make no effort to disguise it.’
‘Very well. Apart from her being, in your eyes, prone to indiscriminate sexual liaisons, I am at a loss to understand the depth of your dislike.’
‘She seduced and perverted young men.’
‘Can you give me an example?’
‘Brother Guss, for example.’
‘So you knew that Brother Guss claims to have been in love with Sister Muirgel?’
‘She ensnared him with her wiles, as I have been trying to tell you.’
‘A harsh thing to say. Had Brother Guss no free will?’
‘I warned the boy,’ went on Brother Tola. He screwed up his eyes as he sought to recite another passage from memory.
‘ … My son, listen to me,
Attend to what I say.
Do not let your heart entice you into her ways,
Do not stray down her paths;
Many has she pierced and laid low,
And her victims are without number.
Her house is the entrance to Sheol,
Which leads down to the halls of death.’
‘You seem attracted by Proverbs, seven,’ remarked Fidelma mockingly. ‘Do you often quote it?’
‘I did my best to warn poor Brother Guss.’ Tola ignored her tone. ‘I praise the Hand of God which swept the harlot overboard.’
Fidelma did not say anything for a moment or two. It had become clear to her that Brother Tola was a man of strong religious conviction, to the point of extreme intolerance. She had known men to kill for religious intolerance before.
‘When did you learn that Sister Muirgel had been swept overboard?’ Fidelma queried.
‘At the same time that everyone else did,’ he replied. ‘This morning.’
‘When did you last see Sister Muirgel?’
‘When we came aboard. I think she was ill almost from the time we rowed out to the ship. No, that is not so. She was all right until after we came aboard. In the absence of Sister Canair, another one who was loose with her sexual favours, Muirgel took charge and allocated the cabins. We all went to these cabins and most of us remained below until after we had set sail. I never saw her afterwards and word came she was suffering from the motion sickness. Perhaps that was a warning of God’s punishment to come.’