I had just finished questioning the Filipinos when the street door opened and two men came in. I knew one of them: Bill Garren, a police detective on the Pawnshop Detail. The other was a small blond youth all flossy in pleated pants, short, square-shouldered coat, and patent-leather shoes with fawn spats to match his hat and gloves. His face wore a sullen pout. He didn't seem to like being with Garren.
"What are you up to around here?" the detective hailed me.
"The Toplin doings for the insurance company," I explained.
"Getting anywhere?" he wanted to know.
"About ready to make a pinch," I said, not altogether in earnest and not altogether joking.
"The more the merrier," he grinned. "I've already made mine," nodding at the dressy youth. "Come on upstairs with us."
The three of us got into the elevator and Ambrose carried us to the fifth floor. Before pressing the Toplin bell, Garren gave me what he had.
"This lad tried to soak a ring in a Third Street shop a little while ago—an emerald and diamond ring that looks like one of the Toplin lot. He's doing the clam now; he hasn't said a word—yet. I'm going to show him to these people; then I'm going to take him down to the Hall of Justice and get words out of him—words that fit together in nice sentences and everything!"
The prisoner looked sullenly at the floor and paid no attention to this threat. Garren rang the bell and the maid Hilda opened the door. Her eyes widened when she saw the dressy boy, but she didn't say anything as she led us into the sitting-room, where Mrs. Toplin and her daughter were. They looked up at us.
"Hello, Jack!" Phyllis greeted the prisoner.
"'Lo, Phyl," he mumbled, not looking at her.
"Among friends, huh? Well, what's the answer?" Garren demanded of the girl.
She put her chin in the air and although her face turned red, she looked haughtily at the police detective.
"Would you mind removing your hat?" she asked.
Bill isn't a bad bimbo, but he hasn't any meekness. He answered her by tilting his hat over one eye and turning to her mother.
"Ever see this lad before?"
"Why, certainly!" Mrs. Toplin exclaimed. "That's Mr. Wagener who lives upstairs."
"Well," said Bill, "Mr. Wagener was picked up in a hock shop trying to get rid of this ring." He fished a gaudy green and white ring from his pocket. "Know it?"
"Certainly!" Mrs. Toplin said, looking at the ring. "It belongs to Phyllis, and the robber —" Her mouth dropped open as she began to understand. "How could Mr. Wagener—?"
"Yes, how?" Bill repeated.
The girl stepped between Garren and me, turning her back on him to face me. "I can explain everything," she announced.
That sounded too much like a movie subtitle to be very promising, but—
"Go ahead," I encouraged her.
"I found that ring in the passageway near the front door after the excitement was over. The robber must have dropped it. I didn't say anything to Papa and Mamma about it, because I thought nobody would ever know the difference, and it was insured, so I thought I might as well sell it and be in that much money. I asked Jack last night if he could sell it for me and he said he knew just how to go about it. He didn't have anything to do with it outside of that, but I did think he'd have sense enough not to try to pawn it right away!"
She looked scornfully at her accomplice.
"See what you've done!" she accused him.
He fidgeted and pouted at his feet.
"Ha! Ha! Ha!" Bill Garren said sourly. "That's a nifty! Did you ever hear the one about the two Irishmen that got in the Y.W.C.A. by mistake?"
She didn't say whether she had heard it or not.
"Mrs. Toplin," I asked, "making allowances for the different clothes and the unshaven face, could this lad have been the robber?"
She shook her head with emphasis. "No! He could not!"
"Set your prize down, Bill," I suggested, "and let's go over in a corner and whisper things at each other."
"Right."
He dragged a heavy chair to the centre of the floor, sat Wagener on it, anchored him there with handcuffs—not exactly necessary, but Bill was grouchy at not getting his prisoner identified as the robber—and then he and I stepped out into the passageway. We could keep an eye on the sitting-room from there without having our low-voiced conversation overheard.
"This is simple," I whispered into his big red ear. "There are only five ways to figure the lay. First: Wagener stole the stuff for the Toplins. Second: the Toplins framed the robbery themselves and got Wagener to peddle it. Third: Wagener and the girl engineered the deal without the old folks being in on it. Fourth: Wagener pulled it on his own hook and the girl is covering him up. Fifth: she told us the truth. None of them explains why your little playmate should have been dumb enough to flash the ring downtown this morning, but that can't be explained by any system. Which of the five do you favour?"
"I like 'em all," he grumbled. "But what I like most is that I've got this baby right— got him trying to pass a hot ring. That suits me fine. You do the guessing. I don't ask for any more than I've got."
"It doesn't irritate me any either," I agreed. "The way it stands the insurance company can welsh on the policies—but I'd like to smoke it out a little further, far enough to put away anybody who has been trying to run a hooligan on the North American. We'll clean up all we can on this kid, stow him in the can, and then see what further damage we can do."
"All right," Garren said. "Suppose you get hold of the janitor and that Eveleth woman while I'm showing the boy to old man Toplin and getting the maid's opinion."
I nodded and went out into the corridor, leaving the door unlocked behind me. I took the elevator to the seventh floor and told Ambrose to get hold of McBirney and send him to the Toplins' apartment. Then I rang Blanche Eveleth's bell.
"Can you come downstairs for a minute or two?" I asked her. "We've a prize who might be your friend of last night."
"Will I?" She started toward the stairs with me. "And if he's the right one, can I pay him back for my bartered beauty?"
"You can," I promised. "Go as far as you like, so you don't maul him too badly to stand trial."
I took her into the Toplins' apartment without ringing the bell, and found everybody in Frank Toplin's bedroom. A look at Garren's glum face told me that neither the old man nor the maid had given him a nod on the prisoner.
I put the finger on Jack Wagener. Disappointment came into Blanche Eveleth's eyes. "You're wrong," she said. "That's not he."
Garren scowled at her. It was a pipe that if the Toplins were tied up with young Wagener, they wouldn't identify him as the robber. Bill had been counting on that identification coming from the two outsiders—Blanche Eveleth and the janitor—and now one of them had flopped.
The other one rang the bell just then and the maid brought him in.
I pointed at Jack Wagener, who stood beside Garren staring sullenly at the floor.
"Know him, McBirney?"
"Yeah, Mr. Wagener's son, Jack."
"Is he the man who shooed you away with a gun last night?"
McBirney's watery eyes popped in surprise.
"No," he said with decision, and began to look doubtful.
"In an old suit, cap pulled down, needing a shave—could it have been him?"
"No-o-o-o," the janitor drawled, "I don't think so, though it—You know, now that I come to think about it, there was something familiar about that fella, an' maybe—By cracky, I think maybe you're right—though I couldn't exactly say for sure."
"That'll do!" Garren grunted in disgust.
An identification of the sort the janitor was giving isn't worth a damn one way or the other. Even positive and immediate identifications aren't always the goods. A lot of people who don't know any better—and some who do, or should—have given circumstantial evidence a bad name. It is misleading sometimes. But for genuine, undiluted, pre-war untrustworthiness, it can't come within gunshot of human testimony. Take any man you like— unless he is the one in a hundred thousand with a mind trained to keep things straight, and not always even then—get him excited, show him something, give him a few hours to think it over and talk it over, and then ask him about it. It's dollars to doughnuts that you'll have a hard time finding any connection between what he saw and what he says he saw. Like this McBirney—another hour and he'd be ready to gamble his life on Jack Wagener's being the robber.