"So you oppose the Freedom of Information Act?'
"Not at all. I'm simply saying that it was never designed to facilitate industrial espionage." Marder shifted in his chair. "Now, you mentioned Flight 545."
"Yes."
"First of all, we don't agree that the accident was the result of slats deployment."
Uh-oh, Casey thought. Marder was going out on a limb. What he was saying wasn't true, and it might very well-
Marder said, "We're currently investigating this situation, and although it's premature for me to discuss the findings of our inquiry, I believe you have been misinformed on the situation. I presume you've gotten this slats information from Fred Barker."
"We are talking to Mr. Barker, among others…"
"Have you spoken to the FAA about Mr. Barker?" Marder said.
"We know he's controversial…"
'To put it mildly. Let's just say he adopts an advocacy position that is factually incorrect"
"You believe it is incorrect"
"No, Ms. Malone. It is factually incorrect," Marder said, testily. He pointed to the papers Malone had spread out on the table. "I couldn't help noticing your list of slats incidents. Did you get that from Barker?"
Malone hesitated a fraction. "Yes."
"May I see it?'
"Sure."
She handed the paper to Marder. He glanced at it.
Malone said, "Is it factually incorrect, Mr. Marder?'
"No, but it's incomplete and misleading. This list is based on our own documents, but it is incomplete. Do you know about Airworthiness Directives, Ms. Malone?"
"Airworthiness Directives?"
Marder got up, went to his desk. "Every time there is an inflight incident involving our aircraft, we review the incident thoroughly, to find out what happened and why. If there's a problem with the aircraft, we issue a Service Bulletin; if the FAA feels compliance with our bulletin should be mandatory, it then issues an Airworthiness Directive. After the N-22 went into active service, we discovered a slats problem, and an Airworthiness Directive was issued to correct the problem. Domestic carriers are required by law to fix the airplanes, to prevent further occurrences."
He came back with another sheet of paper, which he handed to Malone. "This is a complete list of incidents."
Slats Events of Norton N-22
1. January 4,1992. (DO) Slats deployed at FL350, at.84 Mach. The flap/slat handle moved inadvertently.
2. April 2,1992. (DO) Slats deployed while the airplane was in cruise at.81 Mach. A clipboard reportedly fell on the flap/slat handle.
3. July 17,1992. (DO) Initially reported as severe turbulence, it was later learned that the slats had extended as a result of inadvertent flap/slat handle movement.
4. December 20,1992. (DO) Slats extended in cruise flight without movement of the flap/slat handle in cockpit. Confirmed slat cable rigging was out of tolerance in three places. A/D 51-29 was issued as a result of
5. March 12,1993. (FO) Airplane entered a prestall buffet at.82 Mach. The slats were found to be extended and the handle was not in the up and locked position.
6. April 4,1993. (FO) First officer rested his arm on the flap/slat handle as he was operating the autopilot and the action moved the handle down, extending the slats.
7. July 4,1993. (FO) Pilot reported the flap/slat handle moved and slats extended. Aircraft was in cruise flight at.81 Mach.
8. June 10,1994. (FO) The slats extended while the airplane was in cruise flight without movement of the flap/slat handle. Confirmed slat cable rigging was out of tolerance.
"The underlined sentences," Marder said, "are what Mr. Barker omitted from the document he gave you. After the first slats incident, the FAA issued an Airworthiness Directive to change cockpit controls. The airlines had a year to comply. Some did it immediately, others didn't. As you can see, the subsequent incidents all occurred in aircraft which had not yet made the change."
"Well, not quite…"
"Please let me finish. In December of 1992, we discovered a second issue. The cables running to the slats sometimes became slack. Maintenance crews weren't catching the problem. So we issued a second Service Bulletin, and added a tension measurement device, so ground crews could check more easily whether cable rigging was within spec. That solved it. By December, everything was resolved."
"Clearly not, Mr. Marder," Malone said, pointing to the list "You have more incidents in 1993 and in 1994."
"Only on foreign carriers," Marder said. "You see that notation, DO and FO? That stands for 'domestic operator' or 'foreign operator.' The domestic operators must make the changes called for in the FAA Airworthiness Directives. But foreign operators aren't under FAA jurisdiction. And they don't always make the changes. Since 1992, all incidents have involved foreign carriers that hadn't made the retrofits."
Malone scanned the list. "So you knowingly allow carriers to fly unsafe airplanes? You just sit back and let it happen, is that what you're telling me?"
Marder sucked in his breath. Casey thought he was going to blow, but he didn't. "Ms. Malone, we build airplanes, we don't operate them. If Air Indonesia or Pakistani Air won't follow the Airworthiness Directives, we can't force them to."
"All right. If all you do is build airplanes, let's talk about how well you do that," Malone said. "Looking at this list here, you had how many design changes on the slats? Eight?"
Casey thought, She doesn't understand. She's not listening. She doesn't get what she's being told.
"No. Two retrofits," Marder said.
"But there are eight incidents here. You'd agree to that…"
"Yes," Marder said irritably, "but we're not talking about incidents, we're talking about ADs, and there are only two ADs." He was getting angry, his face flushed.
"I see," Malone said. "So. Norton had two design problems on the slats for this aircraft."
"There were two corrections."
"Two corrections of your original erroneous design," Malone said. "And that's just for slats. We haven't gotten to the flaps or the rudder or the fuel tanks and the rest of the airplane. Just in this one tiny system, two corrections. Didn't you test this aircraft, before you sold it to unsuspecting customers?"
"Of course we tested it," Marder said, through clenched teeth. "But you have to realize-"
"What I realize," Malone said, "is that people have died because of your design errors, Mr. Marder. That plane is a deathtrap. And you don't seem to care about that at all."
"Oh for Christ's fucking sake!" Marder threw up his hands and jumped out of his seat. He stomped around the room. "I can't fucking believe this!"