I blushed a little in embarrassment. I should have saved it, because Dayna went even further.
“You two were just finishing when I showed up that first time. It was so beautiful the way he was on top of you, the both of you looking like nothing in the universe could make you happier.”
“Dayna!” Dawn drawled, blushing herself.
“What?” Dayna smirked. “It wasn’t like it was the first time I’d seen you two fucking. Brandi and I were watching him take your virginity, remember?”
“Really?” Adrienne perked up. “I didn’t know you guys were there.”
“We were hiding,” Dayna informed Adrienne.
“Wasn’t my idea,” Brandi said defensively.
“I can’t believe we’re talking about this,” Dawn complained.
“Look around, Dawn.” Dayna shrugged. “We’ve all done much more together since then.”
Dawn had nothing to say to that. Dayna just sat back and looked off, lost in her memories. “I still remember the first time I fucked you, Ben. You had such a beautiful cock. Still do, actually. I’d been horny all camp, and never really thought of fucking a younger boy before, let alone YOU. But you were a talent. You made me cum harder than I had with anyone else in a long, long time.”
Brandi was the next one to start reminiscing. “I still can’t believe you guys talked me into joining you.”
“It’s not like you two hooked up then or anything,” Dayna drawled. “You still hadn’t gotten into your head that your bratty little brother was growing up to be a man.”
“Actually, we sorta did,” Brandi mused.
“What?” Dayna chirped right before Dawn turned and looked up at me with her own “What?”
Brandi’s eyes were unfocused as she stared back into the past, a naughty little smile on her lips. “Ben had just finished fucking Dawn. You and I were sixty-nining when they finished, and you left me to suck his cum out of her,” she said in the general direction of Dayna. “You two were too busy to notice, but he was naked right in front of me, his big, beautiful cock still hard and so wet from Dawn’s pussy. I couldn’t help myself. I put a finger to his lips to keep him quiet, and then I just did it. I bent over and sucked his dick.”
“Holy shit! You never told me!” Dayna screeched.
“I never told anyone,” Brandi said. Only then did she come out of her mini-trance and glance over at me.
I just smiled at her and said softly, “Sometimes I wondered if that really happened, or if it was all just a dream.”
“It was real,” Brandi intoned. “It was just the beginning.”
“Now I feel bad,” Adrienne sighed. “My first time with Ben was so ... messed up.”
“Why? What happened?” Dayna inquired.
Adrienne blushed and looked embarrassed, darting her eyes to me. Clearly, no one knew that we’d first had sex because she was blackmailing me over my affair with Keira McNeil. But also, Adrienne didn’t know if anyone else even knew about Keira at this point. It was all so much in our pasts that we’d sort of forgotten about it. I knew Brooke had figured it out, but beyond them?
Then again, these were my sisters and lovers. We were family. If I couldn’t share with them who could I? I glanced over at Adrienne and nodded. “It’s okay,” I said out loud. Our own personal connection informed her she could handle it however she wanted.
In the end, Adrienne just said, “I wasn’t the person I was today. There was a cold, manipulative bitch in me; and I seduced Ben just because I could, even though it really messed up some sweet relationships he had with other girls. It was a long time before Ben helped me change for the better, but he did.”
I added, “In Adrienne’s defense, it wasn’t all her fault. I was quite the moron back then, always being led around by my dick. A better man wouldn’t have succumbed to her advances.”
“C’mon, Tiger,” Adrienne giggled and posed her body for maximum sex appeal. “This is ME.”
We all got a little laugh at that, and Dayna was the first one to interrupt, saying, “Well I for one am happy that you were a 16-year-old ball of hormones back then. I never would have made it through that summer camp without you.”
Dayna giggled and then added, “And I’m glad you were a manipulative bitch, Adrienne; otherwise I might never have gotten to know you, either. And of course, I’ll miss you little sis.” She looked over at Dawn. “Though we weren’t together as much as I would have thought, what with your whole full-on dedication to Ryan. Still can’t believe that boy never wanted a threesome with us.”
Dawn giggled. “Don’t worry. I’m sure my next boyfriend won’t turn you down should you ever come back this way again.”
Dayna grinned at Dawn and leaned forward again. “Why wait? I’ve missed you for the last year and a half. I’ve missed him for a while, too. What do you say we make up for lost time right now?”
Dayna shifted her hungry gaze to me, staring at the obvious bulge in my shorts. In surprise, I arched an eyebrow and asked, “What about Kevin?”
Dayna sighed and smiled sweetly. “You’re family. You don’t count.”
Dawn just giggled and then reached around me, deftly opening the button in my pajama pants flap before reaching in and extracting my cock up through both my boxers and the pants. “Go right ahead.”
“Right here?” Dayna smirked, glancing at Adrienne and Brandi. Both of the other girls were just staring at my exposed prick.
“Why not?” Dawn shrugged. “Like you said: we have the whole place to ourselves.”
Dayna grinned, her crystal clear blue eyes glittering. “Let the orgy begin!”
There are few things in life more pleasant than getting a blowjob from the woman you love more than anyone in the world. One of those few things is to get a blowjob from the woman you love AND her gorgeous sister. I was in absolute heaven and melting into the couch while both Dawn and Dayna knelt before me, passing my prick back and forth between them like a baton, sucking on my mushroom head and jacking the shaft in their warm hands. Though they could not have done this together in a long, long time, the Evans sisters nevertheless displayed perfect coordination, never missing a beat nor bumping heads when they decided to lick me from both sides at the same time or alternate who was nibbling on the crown while the other suckled my balls.
On the other couch, Brandi and Adrienne were saying their own goodbyes. They cuddled and kissed and whispered with intimate familiarity. Although I’d been distracted by my Cadence and Dawn dramas over the past semester, I’d noticed that my older sister and adoptive sister had been spending a lot of their free time together. They’d been forming a bond of friendship and family, and several times I’d gone looking for one of them and found her in the other’s bed.
Brandi noticed I was looking over at them, and she took great delight in stripping Adrienne’s camisole off her body before my hungry gaze. I actually bucked my cock into Dayna’s throat when Adrienne’s tits were exposed. Dayna swallowed my thrust easily and almost casually turned it into a deep throat, humming happily and surrounding my cock with the intense vibrations of her vocal cords.
It was almost enough to put me over the top. But I controlled my orgasm and panted for breath. Dayna popped off and smiled at me. “That’s right. Take your time, Ben. We have ALL night.”