Dawn then grinned. “And we mean ALL night. I spiked your drink about an hour ago.”
My eyebrows shot up. But then Dawn just giggled and took over deep-throating my cock.
This was going to be a night to remember.
Apparently, when Dayna and Dawn had made reference to having the whole house to ourselves, they really meant it. After spending a couple of years listening to each other fucking in their bedrooms through paper-thin walls, the girls seemed to have every intention of fucking outside of the bedrooms for this one last night.
We started in the living room. Dayna finally got her sisterly threesome right there in the living room. She found out her little sister wasn’t wearing any panties, and parked herself on all fours in front of the couch, eating out Dawn. I knelt behind Dayna and held onto her hips while pistoning my cock in and out of her hot, wet box. And I was extra turned on by the fact that even though all three of us were buck naked from the waist down, we were still wearing our shirts while doing this: Dawn in my linen button-down, Dayna in her see-through nightie, and me in my shirt.
“Ohmigod, Dayna,” Dawn moaned, one hand up her shirt to fondle her own breasts, the other tangled in her sister’s hair to shove Dayna’s face harder against her crotch. “Eat me, baby. Eat me!”
“Mmph!” Dayna just mumbled into her sister’s pussy, licking away heartily while undulating her hips to meet my every thrust. I’d slid my own hands beneath her nightie, palming her big, bouncing tits, and I used them as handholds to really drive myself into her sopping wet cunt.
Of course, we actually HAD done this sisterly threesome way back at the beginning of the year, before Dawn made her commitments of monogamy with Ryan. So in order to do something Dayna hadn’t actually been a part of, we changed positions. Dawn shifted her butt to the edge of the couch and welcomed my cock inside her. Then Dayna stood above her sister, shoving her crotch into Dawn’s face to get eaten out. And every now and again, I would lean forward enough to take a nice bite out of Dayna’s ass as well.
“Mmm, we’re gonna have to work on your rugmunching techniques, girl,” Dayna reprimanded Dawn. “You’ve gotten out of practice. I’ll make sure Brooke and DJ put schooling you on their ‘To Do’ list.”
Dawn just giggled, a vibration that carried all the way down to her pussy snuggly-wrapped around my invading prick. I took the opportunity to both defend and support my girlfriend, taking another bite out of Dayna’s firm butt in front of me and worming a wet finger into her ass from behind, making the older girl squeal.
Dayna laughed and then turned around. “You know you’re gonna have to fuck my ass before this night is through, don’t you?”
I grinned and nodded. “You were my first assfuck, Dayna, and the one who got me turned on to how glorious it could be. How could I possibly refuse?”
Dayna couldn’t respond as Dawn had stepped up her oral attack, really working her big sister’s snatch and clit. Soon after, the busty blonde jerked, climaxed, and would have fallen over the back of the couch if Dawn hadn’t grabbed her and pulled her back.
Dayna slumped to sit beside us, out of the action for the moment. With an evil grin, I then rapid-fucked Dawn until I gave my girlfriend a quick orgasm. And before Dayna knew what was happening, I quickly jerked myself out of Dawn, slid a couple feet to the right, spread Dayna’s legs, and rammed myself into her wet cunt once again.
“Oh, fuck!” Dayna’s eyes flew open in surprise. Her face then dropped into a pleased smile, and she wrapped her hands around my head, pulling me to her while eagerly thrusting her hips back at me once again.
“Oh-fuck-oh-fuck-oh-fuck,” Dayna chanted mindlessly, her eyes closed and her head wobbly while I drilled her out. “Fuck me, Ben! Fuck me!”
I panted and braced my forehead on her shoulder, concentrating on hitting Dayna’s G-spot. And Dawn helped me out by leaning over, fondling her sister’s breasts and then leaning in to kiss her lips.
The hotness of that kiss was what ultimately set me off. Just the sight of Dawn’s and Dayna’s puffy pink lips massaging each other, parting ever so slightly to allow their tongues to snake out and intertwine, made my blood boil and more importantly, made my cum boil. I grunted and jackhammered into Dayna’s body, the friction and pressure sending her into orgasm as well. And at the last moment, I leaned in and joined the girls’ kiss while feeling my balls evacuate their contents and spew into my soulmate’s sister’s womb.
Of course, the three of us weren’t the only ones in the room. As soon as I extracted myself out of Dayna’s now flooded cunt and flopped onto the seat next to her, Dayna was already teasing her best friend. “Mmm ... Check it out Brandi. A veritable lake of your brother’s cum, swimming inside my pretty pussy. Wanna taste?”
Brandi was naked save for an unbuttoned purple satin blouse, and clinched together with a totally naked Adrienne, their legs scissored together so that they were pressed crotch-to-crotch. At the invitation, she turned with eyes aflame as she stared down between Dayna’s widespread legs.
“You know you want to, Brandi,” Dayna intoned sweetly, reaching down with her own fingers to open up her labia and let a dollop of cream ooze out of her. “C’mon. It’s not like you’re fucking him.”
I glanced over at Dawn and shared a little look with her, thinking back to her old mental dilemma over only tasting my cum and whether or not that crossed the line.
Faster than I would have thought, given all of her earlier proclamations that she and I wouldn’t have an intimate relationship anymore, Brandi made her decision. Pulling herself away from Adrienne, my sister moved past the coffee table and quickly sank to her knees. And before I could even blink, Brandi had her tongue buried in Dayna’s snatch, moaning in obvious heat as she loudly started slurping brother-jizz out of her best friend’s cunt.
“Ahhh, FUCK, Brandi!” Dayna threw her head back momentarily before dropping her chin back down and grinning. “So, so naughty, isn’t it?”
Brandi didn’t respond except to slurp even harder.
Dawn and I chuckled as we shared an amused look. And then her eyes dropped down between my legs to see that my cock was still rock hard. Well, she HAD said she’d spiked my drink. I didn’t know what with, and I didn’t really care to find out. I trusted her.
Seeing as how Dayna and Brandi were thus occupied, I glanced across the couches to Adrienne, a smile and an invitation on my face. The gorgeous golden blonde grinned right back, planting her hands on the seat to push herself upright. I was already imagining the positions Dawn, Adrienne, and I could bend ourselves into.
But before Adrienne could get herself off the couch, Brandi abruptly jerked out from between Dayna’s legs and stared at me with wild eyes, quickly shuffling over the few feet until she was kneeling in front of me with her hands now wrapped around my erection.
“Tonight doesn’t count,” my sister pronounced, jacking my shaft rapidly in her hands. She continued staring at me, her eyes stormy. And her mouth hung open as she panted with obvious need.
“Can you handle that?” Brandi pleaded. “Just tonight. And then tomorrow we go back to just being siblings, okay?”
Blinking fast in surprise, it took me a second for Brandi’s words to sink into my brain. But after only a moment’s hesitation, I smiled and nodded. “Sure. Okay.”
And with that, Brandi bent over and inhaled my prick into her mouth, sucking for more cum straight from the source.