So wrong ... and yet so right.
It felt like just seconds ago that I was in this position. Dayna was bent over doggy-style, her arms folded on top of the mattress with her head resting on them, her face turned to the side. She was exhausted, still a little wiped out from the mind racing effects of her previous orgasm when Adrienne and I had very nearly fucked her brains out. But she just HAD to feel this. The girl really was an anal freak.
“Ohhh ... fuck my ass, Ben...” Dayna crooned while I nudged against her sphincter. And as I pressed my hips forward, the mushroom head popped, once again, into my very first asshole.
Obviously, I’d had anal sex before. But with fond nostalgia, I remembered that Dayna’s was indeed the first asshole I’d ever nailed, at summer camp two years ago. So much had changed in two years, and I now moved with supreme confidence as I slid down her lubricated chute and burrowed my thick prick until I was balls deep up her 20-year-old ass.
“Fuck!” Dayna gasped when she felt me hit rock bottom. “Feels like a fucking baseball bat inside me!”
“So good,” I groaned.
“Come on, Ben,” Dayna husked. “Fuck my ass. Ream out my tight ass and spurt all your hot cum into my bowels. Fuck my ass, Ben.”
I groaned again, and an answering groan met me from just next to the bed. “Nnnghhh...” Adrienne’s voice drew my attention to the side. I looked over to see my girlfriend flat on her back, her mouth locked onto Brandi’s as the two beautiful girls shared an open-mouthed kiss. Dribbles of my cum still dotted their chins and cheeks from their previous, sloppy snowballing. And Adrienne’s legs were scissored behind my sister’s ass while Brandi nudged the strap-on dildo a little deeper into her cunt.
“Now I can say I’ve been fucked by all three of you,” Adrienne groaned.
“We’ll have to get Eden and Emma in on the action so you can say all five of us siblings nailed the gorgeous Adrienne,” Brandi replied with a naughty smile.
I shook my head wryly. I still remembered Brandi’s initial qualms with sibling incest, questioning whether or not we should be fucking each other. Even when she’d accepted her own fallen nature, she’d pleaded with Brooke not to become intimate with me as well. But over time, my older sister had come to accept this physical expression of our love. She now welcomed it, and when she’d initially found out I’d started fucking Brooke last year, Brandi had simply smiled and said, “Good for her.” And now she was cracking jokes about bringing Eden and Emma along. Things certainly had changed.
“Ohhh...” Adrienne groaned again, and my sister started stroking in and out of her.
“Take it ... Feel my dick inside you,” Brandi husked.
“Oh, fuck me ... Why the hell do I even need a man?” Adrienne mused. “Everything I want is right here. Soft lips. Supple breasts. A tasty pussy AND a thick cock. I should use these fucking toys more often.”
Brandi giggled and I just smiled. Despite Adrienne’s musings, I wasn’t worried about her leaving me. In the meantime, I was busy cornholing Dayna. Her ass was so hot, maybe the hottest I’d ever been in. And no matter how many times she’d been sodomized in her young life, it was still tight and exquisitely pleasurable. For a moment, it felt like déjà vu as I was transported back in time to that first buttfucking in our summer camp clearing.
“Fuck me, Ben,” the busty blonde groaned. “I’m gonna cum ... I’m gonna cum with your dick in my ass! Fuck me... Fuck my ass ... Yes! Yes! YES!!!”
Dayna’s body locked up and her ass clamped down while her orgasm swept through her. She squeezed me even tighter so that my slow but steady pumping was brought to a halt, my cock trapped inside her vise-like grip. And the rest of her torso began shaking as the climax took over.
“YES!!!” Dayna shrieked again, and her body bucked just once, quite violently. And then her legs gave out and she collapsed straight down onto the mattress. I fell down with her, and the moment my heavy weight hit her back and my dick was driven an extra half-inch into her rectum, her ass muscles unclenched and I was suddenly spewing my load up Dayna’s asshole.
“Urrrgh!” I grunted as I felt myself geysering forth a huge load into Dayna’s bowels. She was flat on her face, her body being compressed downwards by my weight while I was flat on top of her with my dick fully imbedded up her backside.
Next to us, Adrienne was screaming her pretty little head off as Brandi’s fake cock drove her to orgasm. Her voice eventually trailed off as the climax passed and Brandi put her head down to rest. My abs tensed a few more times as I spat out my last few globs of semen into Dayna’s butt, and then there was nothing left but the quiet sounds of all four of us panting for breath.
Then Dayna chuckled, her breathing labored under my crushing weight. “Fuck, that was amazing, Ben,” she managed to croak. “I’m going to LOVE having you guys living here this year!”
We took a break after that particular round and paused to clean ourselves up. The upstairs bathroom had a glass sliding door and after a quick discussion, the girls parked me on the toilet seat and forced me to watch while the three of them jumped into the cramped shower together, soaping up each other’s bodies, rubbing each other’s tits and pussies, and giggling the whole while. I got hard again just watching.
Then Adrienne and Dayna stepped out, toweling off and grabbing onto each other while they skipped back into the bedroom to continue their lovemaking. That left Brandi still in the shower crooking her finger for me to join her. I grinned, thinking of how our late night showers had first led us into each other’s bed way back when.
As I stepped beneath the hot spray and felt my sister begin soaping me up, I thought in amazement at how well things were going so far. Adrienne had been casual friends with Brandi for a short time, so it made sense that they would get along initially. But “getting along” and getting mixed up in an orgy together are two very different things. And yet both girls had jumped in without hesitation.
Then there was the way Adrienne and Dayna were seriously into each other. I supposed it made sense. The two girls had similar outgoing personalities to go along with their blonde hair and tall, stacked bodies. But I still hadn’t expected them to hit it off so quickly. It really seemed like the four of us would be fantastic roommates together.
This only left one more roommate: Dawn.
I was distracted from my thoughts of Dawn when Brandi knelt in the tub and started blowing me. And I was further distracted when my sister dried me off, pulled me into HER bedroom in the other direction, and proceeded to climb aboard my upright prick. We’d gotten our urgent missed-you-for-months fucking out of the way that afternoon while Adrienne was downstairs with Dawn. So now Brandi was just able to ride me comfortably and easily until she squeaked her way to two climaxes and I filled my sister with incestuous brother-spunk.
But afterwards, while Brandi laid her head on my chest and listened to my heartbeat, I sighed forlornly and softly asked, “What do you think Dawn is up to right now?”
Softly, my sister replied, “Probably the same thing she’s been up to since Thanksgiving. She’s with Ryan now. Don’t worry about it, Ben.”
I exhaled slowly. “I can’t help but worry. This wasn’t the way things were supposed to be. She and I were supposed to be together.”
“Is that what you really want?” Brandi asked me softly. “If so, tell me now so I don’t get too attached to Adrienne. She’s a really sweet girl once you get to know her and it would really suck ... for me ... if I lost her friendship down the road because you couldn’t keep your commitment to her.”