“Mmm, what have we here?” She grinned, feeling the bulge.
“Nothing. What’s up, Felicia?” I said dismissively.
“I just missed you, Ben. It’s been days since I last got to talk to you. We somehow never managed to cross paths.”
I smiled thinly. Maybe it was more that Felicia was avoiding me whenever she saw me with the girls.
“And after what happened in the cabin,” the gorgeous older girl continued. “I wasn’t exactly sure if you’d be happy to see me again.” She grinned and grinded her ass down a little harder on my dick. “Guess you are.”
“What do you want from me, Felicia?” I asked wearily.
“Nothing much,” she giggled. And then her voice got husky as she leaned forward, putting her face just inches from mine. “Just guilt-free sex. No strings attached. Just make me cum harder than I can possibly imagine.”
“I’m doing just fine with the girls.”
“Oh, I know,” Felicia sat back. “I’m sure Adrienne and Dawn are working really hard now that you three have patched up your differences.” She giggled. “I guess that’s why you’ve still got my interest. Any man who can satisfy two such gorgeous creatures of femininity has GOT to be worth a ride or two.”
“But why would I risk them for you?”
Felicia leaned in to my ear. “Because…,” she husked sensuously. “I can outfuck the both of them any day…”
The intensity in Felicia’s voice was the last straw in making my dick rock hard. Felicia rubbed herself against it and her pale blue eyes twinkled while a vicious smile crossed her face.
“Not enough,” I grunted. “Believe me. I’m getting more than I can handle already.”
Felicia rose to the challenge, a sneer on her lips. “Oh, I know you are. Don’t think I haven’t been watching you.” Her eyes glinted dangerously and for a second, I actually felt a touch of fear. “Adrienne, Dawn. These are obvious. Then there’s Dawn’s little sister DJ. She’s so adorable. Those tits on that skinny body just doesn’t seem fair, does it? When she grows up, she just might eclipse both her older sisters for beauty.”
“What’s your point?”
“I’m not making a point, just making conversation. Of course, there’s one other girl who’s always with you: Brooke. Your little sister. Isn’t that the little scandal? And in this tight little community, it would really be too bad if a rumor got started about the two of you.”
“Rumors fly all the time,” I said dismissively.
“But rumors based on fact are rather stubborn, wouldn’t you say?”
I grunted beneath my breath. “So it’s blackmail, is it?”
“Nothing of the sort. I’m just making conversation.”
“Riiight.” I sighed. “Didn’t think you’d stoop to this. And even if you got what you wanted, what makes you think I’d be any good with what you’re trying to hold over me?”
Felicia giggled, “I have confidence in my powers of inspiration once I get you in my grasp.”
“Then you’ll leave my sister alone?”
Felicia couldn’t contain her excitement, now certain we’d turned the corner. “I swear.”
I sighed and checked my watch. Three hours before dinnertime. “Let’s get this over with.”
Felicia and I walked arm-in-arm to her cabin. Well, I walked. Felicia was wrapped around my arm, chattering non-stop as usual.
The decision wasn’t so impulsive this time. My conscience still questioned what I was doing, but I was doing it with my eyes wide open to the consequences. I had my doubts, but I didn’t want any rumors being spread about Brooke and me, and I latched onto that notion with every fiber of my being.
I was going to fuck Felicia. It was actually going to happen.
I should have been excited, but I was still nervous about Adrienne and Dawn. Perhaps I shouldn’t have been. After all… my girls had a plan.
If only I knew what it was.
“Oh, shit that was nice,” I groaned, sliding my now limp cock slowly out of Dawn’s clenching pussy. She, Adrienne, and I were completely naked on our second trip as a threesome to our special clearing, and we’d just finished our last round of fucking. My mind drifted away on a cloud of bliss and happy emptiness.
“We want you to fuck Felicia.”
I blinked a couple of times. No way I heard that right. “Excuse me?” I asked.
Adrienne sat up, her big tits jiggling slightly as she fixed me with an intense gaze from her hazel eyes. My own eyes automatically drifted downwards to her swaying breasts, hypnotized by their glorious magnificence. My brain was still sluggish and I struggled to even focus on the tits. My stunning girlfriend repeated, “We want you to fuck Felicia.”
Each word stuck into my brain as if it were made of jello, lodging deeply and slowly sinking even deeper. I was in no condition to really process this.
“You want to, don’t you?” Adrienne continued, her eyes searching into mine.
I didn’t have the strength for higher thought and so I started nodding in agreement immediately, the rest of me reacting automatically. But then my panic/loyalty reflex kicked in and my eyes went wide, waking me up just enough to stammer, “Uh, I mean, no! Of course not!”
“Bennn…”
“My dick wants to, of course. But you can’t blame me for that,” I protested, trying to cover my ass.
“We’re not blaming you,” Dawn had sat up by now, smiling quietly to herself while stirring my spunk inside her own pussy. “We want you to.”
My brain was awake now, but Adrienne held her hand up to stop me from saying anything further. “So do it. No consequences. No jealousy. Just promise me you won’t half-ass it, or even 90 % it. You’ve got to give Felicia the fucking of your life.”
“Huh?” I was completely confused.
Adrienne leaned forward, an evil grin on her face. “I want you…” she began in a deep voice. “To work your Big Ben magic on her. I want you to hold absolutely nothing back.”
Dawn moved in. The two girls had gotten together last night to discuss Adrienne’s plan, without me, and she was in on whatever they’d decided. “I still remember what you did to Gwen that afternoon of the football game, Ben. Think you can do the same thing to Felicia?”
“Are you serious?” I looked at my best friend, mouth gaping.
“Fuck her brains out,” Dawn nodded seriously.
“But why?”
Adrienne grinned. “That’s the part we can’t tell you.”
All of Brooke’s warnings about how the girls in my life manipulated me however they wanted flew into my head, triggering a surge of frustration. “And why the fuck not?”
“Ben!” Adrienne was taken aback by my tone. “With all the plans I’ve done for you, have any of them ever turned out bad?”
“Well… no.” Actually, they almost always ended up with me burying my dick into some hot babe… or four…
“Then trust me, Tiger.”
“Why can’t you tell me?”
“Because if you don’t know anything, you can’t spill anything should Felicia grill you,” Dawn clarified.
“Well, she might figure out you told me to go ahead and fuck her.”
“That’s not going to stop her from letting you do it,” Adrienne shrugged. “It’s what she wants. She’ll question our motives but she’ll go through with it. And that’s all we need.”