I arched an eyebrow and Dawn signed mournfully, shaking her head sadly. Then she continued, “Now DJ’s flirted with most of the guys her own age around camp and managed to not do anything stupid just yet, because she and Brooke are having sex together and that’s taken the urgency off for these first few days. But my little sister is dead set on getting properly laid, and I’m afraid she’s begun to turn her attentions to older men who are just going to prey on her. She’s convinced that an ‘older man’ will have more experience and be a better lover. I’m convinced that guys like Greg and Connor will just use her and leave her.”
I was starting to get what Dawn was alluding to, and I had to admit that my loins liked the idea. DJ was very cute. And yet my arousal was tempered both by the pained look in Dawn’s eyes and my own current worries about Brooke. I still hadn’t gotten my little request off my chest and I couldn’t relax until I did.
Dawn sighed. “When we first got here, DJ asked me if she could join us, make a threesome out of it. I told her I didn’t want to share. I was in love, Ben. I wanted you all to myself, you know?”
I nodded.
“But now I’m afraid that things will be worse if DJ finds some other stranger. I trust you Ben. I’m still not sure I want to share you, but I trust you. Can you do this and make it good for her, but still love me?” Dawn’s lower lip quivered.
I didn’t answer immediately, instead moving forward to kiss my girlfriend tenderly. She sighed happily and wrapped her hands behind my head to more firmly kiss me back. And when we pulled away, I looked her in the eye and said, “I’ll always love you. You never have to worry about that. No matter what else happens to us, you will always come first.”
Belatedly, I got the innuendo and I grinned. “And if you want, I can make sure you always cum first.”
Dawn rolled her eyes, but the vulgar humor broke some of the tension and she managed a wry grin. “I’m still not entirely sure I’m comfortable with letting her join us. She’s just a kid, you know?”
I sighed and rolled my eyes, thinking of Brooke. “Believe me, I know.”
“But then I think of what we were doing when we were fifteen,” Dawn continued. “Maybe we weren’t having sex yet, but the two of us got pretty hot and heavy. And I guess DJ’s just developed a little faster than me. It’s not like she’s still a virgin.” She shrugged helplessly.
I took a deep breath. “But Brooke is.”
“Brooke?” Dawn sat up straight and gave me a funny look. “What’s this got to do with Brooke?”
I exhaled and gathered my strength, looking around the field to make sure no one was within earshot. “I wasn’t sure how to say this, but Brooke wants ME to be her first.”
Dawn smirked and a twinkle came into her eyes. “Ohhh… Okay, that makes sense.”
My eyebrows shot up in confusion. “Makes sense?”
“She’s been giving you these weird looks all summer and every time she did, I would watch you tense up,” Dawn smiled. “Now I know why. I’d started to guess anyways.”
“We don’t have to,” I put in hurriedly. “I promised I’d be loyal. I love you, Dawn. And Brooke knows that. I’d never do anything to—”
“Ben, Ben,” Dawn calmed me down. Her posture relaxed even more. “It’s okay. She’s your sister. I get it.”
“But—”
“And after all, didn’t we just agree to let DJ join us? If I can accept you having sex with my sister, I can certainly accept you having sex with yours. Brooke loves you, Ben. I get it.”
I arched an eyebrow. “Really?”
“Makes sense. It’s the same reason I’d rather you be the one DJ learns sex from. Yeah, DJ’s not a virgin, but she hasn’t had good sex either.” Dawn smiled and leaned back with both arms, which thrust her chest forward and began to stimulate my arousal. “We can both teach them. After all, we’re their big siblings. I taught DJ, now it’s your turn to teach Brooke.”
“But that’s different, you’re both girls,” I frowned.
“Not so different. Sex is sex. Learning is learning. And I don’t have a dick for DJ to learn with.” Dawn grinned. “Hell, if Dayna had been a boy, I would have lost my virginity to my big brother instead of you,” she laughed.
Feeling the tension drain out of me, I started laughing too. And then Dawn let out a big sigh of relief. “You know, I thought I was going to feel really jealous and uncomfortable at the idea of DJ sleeping with you. She’s still so young and we’re only nine days into really being boyfriend/girlfriend. But now that it’s here, I don’t mind at all.”
“Really?”
Dawn smiled sweetly. “I love my little sister, Ben. I want to protect her and see her happy. And knowing she can learn with you far outweighs any jealousy of mine. It’s not like you’re going to go fall in love with her, will you?”
I shook my head. “Not planning on it. But I will warn you Dawn, one thing I’ve learned is that it’s not as simple as a few orgasms and a few pointers. Once you’ve slept with someone, it changes things… forever.”
“Yeah,” Dawn smiled and pulled my face to hers, rubbing our noses together. “It brings us closer. You’ll have tapped all three Evans sisters, Ben. And I’ve already had sex with Brandi. Now we’re just binding our two families as close as they can possibly be.”
“So how is this gonna work?” DJ asked, fidgeting nervously. Dawn looked reassuringly at her little sister while I held Brooke’s hand, similarly trying to instill her with calmness and confidence.
“There’s no pressure,” I said in a gentle tone, looking at Dawn while I said this. “We can do as little or as much as you guys are comfortable with, even if it means doing nothing.” And I meant it. Sure, the horndog part of me wanted to bury my tool inside cute DJ, whose tight body and flowing blonde hair reminded me of Dawn at fifteen. And I was certainly aroused by the naughty idea of having sex with my virginal little sister. But the nice guy in me was coming out again. No pressure. Never. And while I hadn’t been that close to DJ, she was a friend and very important to my family, and I couldn’t bear to do anything to her that she might regret.
Now if I couldn’t do anything like that to DJ, I certainly could never force myself on Brooke. I resolved that if I saw the slightest hesitation in her, I would call this whole thing off, like I had with Megan way back when.
“Why don’t you two just hang back,” Dawn suggested. “Ben and I will get things going and if you feel comfortable enough, just join in.” The breeze off the creek picked up just then and blew through my girlfriend’s hair, sending it fluttering to the side of her while she turned her beautiful face to me. I saw the sparkle in her clear blue eyes. Whatever reservations she might have over letting me, her love, have sex with her little sister and my little sister, Dawn was clearly excited by the situation.
I lay back across the blankets as Dawn crawled over me. She paused to remove her baby T-shirt, leaving her upper body clad only in her bra as she bent down to taste my lips. And as the heavenly pleasures of our kiss began spreading through my body, I felt my own tension over the situation starting to melt away.
My shirt came off shortly afterwards, followed by Dawn’s bra. She then rose up on her knees and went through the awkward gymnastics of removing her shorts and panties until she’d fully undressed, and then rolled onto her back as I similarly got myself completely naked. We moved together with the ease and comfort of lovers quite familiar with each other’s bodies, and even through closed eyes we instinctively knew where to move next in order to maximize each other’s pleasure.
“Ohhh, Ben…” Dawn sighed when she settled her crotch over mine. My long dick, trapped against my own belly, nestled in the cleft of Dawn’s juicing pussy. And while my kisses trailed down her neck, she slid forward to offer her swollen breasts to my lips. I nursed happily on one while manually stimulating the other as she began to glide her torso back and forth, using my dick as a rail.