Then DJ moved over me and without further ado, the youngest Evans sister dropped her mouth to mine and gave me a VERY good approximation of Dawn’s volcanic kiss. Her lips molded themselves to mine and pushed my head back against the blanket with some good pressure. Her tongue pressed forth and parried my tongue to the side. And she moaned in obvious heat while dropping her naked torso on top of me, crushing those tits into my chest and rubbing herself urgently against my naked flesh.
Eventually, DJ broke back for air and sighed happily. “I always knew you’d be a great kisser, Ben.”
I grinned at the younger girl’s obvious confidence and enthusiasm. She was a budding Dayna just waiting to grow up. “Likewise, kiddo,” I smiled.
The blonde teen returned to kissing me and eventually she took hold of my shoulders and rolled us over. With some urgency, she maneuvered my hips around until I was lying between her spread thighs, and she lifted her knees into the air while wriggling her crotch around the blanket until she felt my erection nudging up against her pussy. There was no hesitation, no waiting to look at big sister Dawn. There was no brief discussion of our feelings for one another or concern for how this might change our friendship. DJ wanted to fuck, and to fuck well.
“C’mon, Ben,” DJ urged. “Show me what’s got both of my older sisters raving about what a stud you are. Show me what good fucking is supposed to feel like. Take me to heaven!”
And with that, I pivoted my hips, re-aimed my cock, and slowly began sinking my way into my youngest ever lover.
I didn’t get very far. DAMN! DJ was TIGHT! Even though she wasn’t a virgin, according to Dawn she’d only had sex twice before and my predecessor clearly had a smaller dick, for DJ winced as she was stretched farther than ever before. It wasn’t a question of lubrication; DJ’s pussy was a swamped inferno. But even with my toes scrabbling against the blanket’s surface and me focusing all my weight through my crotch, I could only manage a steady push that took a full two minutes before I was fully lodged inside DJ’s near-virginal pussy.
“Holy shit you’re big!” DJ groaned and clutched at me. I could feel her heartbeat through her vaginal walls, which seemed to be pulsing against me with a steady [bum-BUMP] [bum-BUMP].
“You’re so fucking tight!” I grunted and fought to stave off my impending orgasm, overstimulated by those pussy wall pulses. No wonder her boyfriend had popped off after only three strokes. And as I concentrated all my efforts on not bursting, I let my head move down to rest on the blanket beside DJ’s head.
She patted my back and got herself used to my thick invasion while I got myself used to her pulsing tightness. I’d nearly spurted into DJ’s 15-year-old pussy already, and the sudden memory of what happened to Allie Sanders set off an alarm in my head. “Are you safe?” I asked with some concern in my voice.
DJ giggled and nodded. “Mom put me on the pill when I turned 15. And you’re the first one in me without a condom.”
I looked to Dawn for confirmation, who was watching over us like a mother hen. She nodded and said, “Mom figured DJ would cut loose sometime this summer.”
I sighed with some relief and then turned my head, pecking the young girl’s cheek. “I just don’t want to do anything to hurt you.”
DJ winced but managed a wry grin. “Well, shoving a baseball bat up my cunt wasn’t exactly pleasant.”
I chuckled and then pushed myself up so that I was holding my weight above her. “Really? I’ve been told this part is quite nice.” And with that, I retracted my hips back several inches before gently pushing my way back in. I reveled in the feeling of her body beneath me, so much like Dawn’s and yet not. She was literally just a thinner, slightly shorter, younger version of Dawn.
When I pumped, DJ hissed and threw her head back, moaning in pleasure as she felt my thick shaft touching off every nerve she had in her pussy. “Yes… Fucking hell…”
“Feel good, Deej?” Dawn asked with a smile.
“Fuck, yeah,” DJ sighed happily as I began to push in and out of her tightness at a steady pace. “Knew this would work.”
“Knew what would work?” Dawn arched her eyebrow.
DJ smiled and put her hands on my biceps while I thrust in and out of her. “Mmm…” she moaned happily and then finally answered Dawn’s question. “Flirting with Greg Kinomoto.”
“What?” Dawn asked with some alarm.
Brooke was beside us, rubbing herself with one hand and caressing my back with the other while watching me fuck her best friend. She explained, “DJ only ever wanted to fuck Ben.”
“I didn’t care about other random guys around camp,” DJ husked. “I want to be fucked right and there was only one guy I knew could do it. That’s you, Ben.” DJ picked her head up and kissed me fiercely. I groaned into the kiss and pistoned my cock in and out of her a little faster.
Brooke finished up the explanation. “She was hoping she could talk you into it but you always seemed so reluctant. And I wanted Ben so badly but he only seemed to cave when I threatened to just go screw someone else to get my cherry popped. So we both came up with the idea of flirting with Greg and his buddies. Ever since that bonfire where he kissed you, you both seemed pretty pissed off at Greg and he’s avoiding the both of you. So we figured that if you were afraid we both might have sex with Greg, flirting with him would scare you guys enough to let us fuck Ben instead.”
Far from upset, Dawn got a grin on her face. “Manipulative little bitches.”
“You’d better believe it, sis,” DJ grunted with a grin and then immediately started moaning that an orgasm was sweeping over her. “Oh, FUCK! Ben! Fuck me! Fuck me harder! Deeper! I’m gonna cum!”
DJ howled her way through that first climax, moaning the whole time about how it was her first orgasm during sex. Brooke was pretty close herself, and when she leaned in towards Dawn, the older blonde pulled my little sister in front of her, palming Brooke’s tits and rubbing the brunette teen’s clit until Brooke spasmed with her climax, eventually collapsing back against Dawn’s chest.
“Thanks,” Brooke sighed happily.
“Anytime,” Dawn grinned and then bent to peck Brooke on the lips with a cute kiss.
“Fuck me from behind.” DJ’s command brought my attention back to the blonde 15-year-old beneath me. And I moved to obey by pulling out and sitting back on my heels, my thick shaft proudly jutting outwards.
Unable to help herself, Dawn then swept down and took me into her mouth, savoring the taste of her little sister’s orgasmic nectar on my cock and giving me a few healthy sucks while DJ got into position on all fours with her tight, cute ass facing back at me. And then the younger girl barked at her older sister, “Hey! That’s mine!”
“Just for now, Deej,” Dawn smiled. But she did tug on me and aimed my cock back towards her little sister’s snatch.
“Ohhh…” DJ groaned as I slowly sank into her from behind, holding her narrow hips in my hands for leverage as I fought past her tightness to once again bury myself balls deep in the teenager’s bare-shaven twat. And then soon after, the air was filled with the sound of flesh impacting flesh as my pelvis repeatedly banged off of DJ’s firm, perky buttcheeks.
Meanwhile, our sisters were not just lying back and watching. Dawn had lain down on her back and maneuvered Brooke into a sixty-nine position over her. And with a tease in her voice, Dawn said, “Now let’s see if Miss A.D.D. over there paid enough attention to my lessons to teach you properly.”