Brooke grinned and kissed my nose, then slipped her legs off my shoulders while I pulled myself out. And then moving a few feet over to the left, I hoisted Dawn’s legs over my shoulders, settled my cock into position, and then thrust my way forward into my lover’s quim.
“Unnnghh! Yes!” Dawn grunted. “Fuck me, baby. Fuck me and cum inside me. I want to still feel you dribbling into my panties tomorrow morning.”
I grinned. DJ’s blowjob, then both DJ’s and Brooke’s clenching pussies had just about brought me to my limits of pleasure. Dawn wouldn’t have to wait very long. “One batch of scalding jizz, cumming right up!” I announced. And then with my hips thrust as far forward as humanly possible, I let loose with a torrent of sperm right against the back of Dawn’s womb.
“Unnnghh!” Dawn jerked as the first jet splattered against her insides. “Fill me, Ben! Fill me!” She screamed, vibrated, and eventually went limp, dropping her legs off my shoulders to fall heavily onto the blankets.
But we weren’t done it. Far from it. After I injected Dawn with a thick wad of cock cream, DJ sixty-nined with her and slurped all of my essence out, holding it her mouth to orally pass it back to her sister so that the 17-year-old blonde could swallow some of it down.
That sight plus Brooke’s enthusiastic fellatio brought me back to hardness. And while the two Evans sisters were still on top of each other french kissing with sticky globs of cum between them, I settled in behind the girls and alternated thrusting into each of their pussies every few minutes. The mental high of screwing the two beautiful blondes added fuel to my lustful fire, and eventually I blasted my second load into DJ.
This time it was Brooke’s turn to slurp me out of her best friend while Dawn crawled over to cuddle and pet my limp member. I was pretty winded and tired by that point, having done most of the recent thrusting work. But as soon as I showed signs of new life, Dawn bent over and began worshipping me with her mouth.
After a few minutes, my ego demanded I get more involved in the action and I made to have Dawn mount me, but she stubbornly insisted on remaining where she was, with her lips wrapped around my shaft. So I let her, and as I lay my head back and enjoyed the pleasant warmth of my girlfriend’s fellatio, I felt my cockhead nudging against the entrance to her throat.
“Dawn?” I asked warily just once. And then with a deep breath of air, my girlfriend pushed past her gag reflex and suddenly her lips were around the base of my cock. “Oh, SHIT!” I gasped, never expecting it out of her.
With tears in her eyes, Dawn quickly popped off and smiled with satisfaction. But not one to leave things half-finished, she quickly gulped some oxygen and then returned, deep-throating me completely and then fucking the head of my cock up and down in her throat.
This time, when I said her name, it was a much more urgent, “Dawn!” In point of fact, it was a warning, because as she bobbed up and down, within a few seconds the tight constriction had me blowing my third wad of the morning straight into her belly.
This time, Dawn choked and she popped off, taking the second burst of cum right in her face, forcing her to squeeze her eyes shut against the cannon force of my cock, which was still spurting creamy streams all over her forehead and cheeks. And even when we both thought I was done, Dawn was just opening her eyes when my dick spat out a final glob, which landed on her left cheek.
Panting with arousal and gratitude, I smiled as I saw the cum-covered face of my love. For her part, she wasn’t dissuaded by the unexpected semen-shower, smiling brightly with a twinkle in her crystal blue eyes. “That’s two,” she said happily.
“Two?” I wondered aloud.
“Two,” Dawn nodded. “One load in my cunt. One load down my throat.”
“And one into DJ,” I nodded towards the younger teen, who giggled and rubbed her own sodden pussy. Wryly, I shook my head, worn out from the three orgasms. “I’m not as young as I used to be.”
“Well, there’s one more to go,” Dawn said firmly. And with that, my girlfriend reached into her pack, one hand pulling out a handkerchief, which she used to mop up her face. And in the other hand, she had a familiar tube of Astroglide.
I distinctly remembered the day I first let my fingertips run around Dawn’s anus. She’d ordered me on no uncertain terms never to try putting a finger inside. Even when Dayna was bugging me to bugger her, Dawn had distastefully described the act as disgusting.
But at my arched, questioning eyebrow, Dawn looked at me with dead seriousness and obvious lust. “You got my oral virginity. You got my cherry. I want you to have all three Ben. I want you to be the only man to ever fuck my ass.”
“Are you sure?” I asked for the umpteenth time.
“Shut up before I get nervous about this,” Dawn rolled her eyes and then hesitantly lifted her legs up and back. If we were going to do this, she wanted to be able to look me in my eyes. She’d blown past my feeble attempts at reasoning that she didn’t need to do this and that I loved her anyways, but Dawn wanted to make her own statement about her level of commitment, both to herself as well as to me.
Ever supportive, DJ helped to hold Dawn’s legs back while Brooke went down on me, my sister’s hot little mouth making sure I was hard despite my misgivings. Sure, I wanted to fuck Dawn’s ass, but I was wary of hurting her. And I’d already been weakened by three recent orgasms. But Brooke’s talented tongue kept me energized and then she guided my hips into place.
DJ then took over, gripping my shaft and aiming the head at Dawn’s puckered rosebud. Dawn and I were too busy staring each other in the eyes with love, tenderness, and affection to pay much attention. But once DJ had my cock settled, I instinctively knew to push.
Dawn’s anus resisted me at first. But then she took a breath and consciously relaxed as she exhaled, and with a little more pressure from my end, her sphincter popped open and my mushroom head pushed through.
Immediately, Dawn panicked and clamped up tighter than anything, squeezing my cock almost painfully. But as DJ stroked her forehead and I stroked her arms, Dawn relaxed again and with copious amounts of lube easing the way, my shaft began burrowing deeper into her bowels.
“Unnnnnnnghhh,” Dawn threw her head back and groaned as she felt my cock descending. “So fucking full,” she sighed as her eyes closed and her neck went limp. And after a few more seconds, I bottomed out inside Dawn’s once virgin-asshole.
“That’s everything,” I murmured.
Dawn smiled, at first just a smile of satisfaction that she’d taken it all. But when I started to pull back, Dawn gasped and that smile started becoming a bigger grin. And with her eyes wide open, blue irises glittering, my girlfriend looked at me and started laughing. “FUCK! Dayna was right. This feels GOOD!”
The enthusiasm in Dawn’s voice was unmistakable. She seemed as surprised as I was, something that confused me for a moment. But there was nothing confusing about the way Dawn suddenly lunged her hips at me, re-impaling her ass on my cock. And then she was urgently tugging down on my arms so that we could kiss wetly and urgently while my paramour began to fuck her own ass against me.
“Oh, Ben! Ohhh, Ben! Fuck my ass! Fuck it! Fuck me!” Dawn crooned while scissoring her legs behind my lower back and using the leverage to hump herself even harder against my invading prick.
“Oh, Dawn!” I groaned.
“Like it Ben? Is it tight? Is my ass tight for you? Don’t you love fucking it?” She gasped with a giggle in her voice. “Oh, it’s incredible Ben! I never thought…! I should have listened to Dayna. I feel so fucking full! I want you to do this to me all the time! Fuck my ass! Fill my ass with your thick column of meat! I’ll let you do this whenever you want, Ben! Fuck it! Fuck my ass! Fuck my tight little ass!”