When the game starts, I don’t know if it’s because I think Bree might be there, but I cheer even louder, kick even higher, and smile even bigger than I normally do. I want to show everyone that Lara Kelley is doing just fine. Lara Kelley didn’t let this destroy her — even though she almost did at first.
We’re up 14–7 at halftime, when the West Lake band, their cheerleaders, and the dance team take the field. I search for Bree, and I think maybe I spot her. I have to admit, their routine is pretty good.
Then it’s our turn and, for the first time in a while, I’m really nervous to perform. It’s the halftime show. All eyes on us. And I don’t want to mess up any tumbles or do the slightest thing wrong, because Bree might take it as a sign that she damaged me in some way. That somehow she won. But then, as I think that, I see myself sitting in Linda’s office. Hear her telling me that’s an unproductive thought that I need to learn how to toss.
So I pretend it’s a piece of paper and mentally throw it in a pretend garbage can as the band starts up. Taking a deep breath, I just let my muscle memory take over and do what we’ve been practicing over and over.
It’s all good.
Luis and Julisa meet me on the sidelines when we come off the field.
“You hungry?” Luis asks. “I’ll buy you a wrap.”
“Sure,” I say.
“What about me?” Julisa complains. “Are you buying me a wrap?”
He looks at her like she’s crazy. “You’re my sister,” he says. “Buy your own wrap!”
“Oh, come on,” I tell him. “Be a good twin and get one for Julisa, too!”
“I get suckered into everything,” he says, sighing before heading off for the food cart.
“I have to run to the bathroom,” I tell Julisa. “I’ll meet you back here.”
“Meet me at the food cart,” she says. “I’ll go keep Luis company in line, since he’s treating.”
As usual, there’s a line for the girls’ room. I’m standing behind a group of girls in black-and-silver tracksuits. I wonder if they know Bree.
“How does it feel being back at your old school?” one of them asks the black-haired girl standing with her back to me.
“Weird,” she says. “Really weird.”
My heart starts thumping in my chest, and my palms are damp. It’s Bree.
“I never thought I’d come back here, ever,” she continues. “Not after … what happened.”
I stand there, frozen.
And then Christine, one of the other cheerleaders, comes out of the bathroom, and says, “Hey, Lara,” and Bree turns around, looking at me, wide-eyed.
Her face looks thinner and paler against the stark black of her hair.
I feel a flood of nerves explode within me, and I have the urge to bolt. Instead, I quietly say, “Hi, Bree.”
“Lara,” she says. “Hi … I was wondering if I’d … see you here.”
“Yeah … me too,” I say. “You —”
Hurt me so much … Made me try to kill myself over a guy who didn’t even exist … Made me afraid to trust anyone including myself …
“— look different with dark hair.”
“I did it a while back,” she says, fidgeting a little. “Mom hates it.”
The girls she’s with are watching and listening. They know what happened, and they’ve figured out that I’m Lara Kelley.
The girl who fell for Bree’s trick. The girl who tried to kill herself.
I am that girl, but I’m not just her anymore. I’ve been working really hard to become more. I straighten my shoulders.
“I liked the routine you guys did,” I say, even though what I really want to say is Why, Bree? Why did you do it?
“Thanks,” Bree says. “We’ve been practicing that one for a while.”
She glances at the line ahead, as if desperate for it to be her turn so she can avoid talking to me anymore. “How are things here?” she asks. “With you?”
I had to work so hard every day to get to where I am now … I hate you for what you did to me … Why did you do it, Bree? WHY?!!!
“Great!” I say, smiling brightly. “Cheerleading’s great. Homecoming’s coming up soon. It’s all good.”
I feel like I’ve turned into my mother. Everything is perfect with us Kelleys!
“Oh … I’m glad to hear that,” Bree says. We’re almost at the front of the line, and a stall opens up. “Is it okay if I go first?” she asks her friends. “I’m really desperate.”
They tell her to go ahead.
“Bye, Lara!” she says, before escaping into the bathroom stall.
Her teammates look at me curiously, like they’re not sure what to make of me. They seem surprised that there wasn’t more of a scene.
What they don’t realize is that when I get into the bathroom stall, my legs are shaking. I have to take several deep breaths to try to calm myself down before I emerge to go meet my friends at the food cart.
Julisa’s in line as I come out of the bathroom. At least it’s shorter now.
“I couldn’t wait. I left Luis waiting for you by the food cart,” she says. “Don’t let him eat my wrap!”
“I won’t,” I say.
The minute I see Luis, he asks, “What’s the matter?”
“How can you tell?” I ask.
“Because you’re even paler than usual, gringa.”
Even though I’m freaked out, he gets a giggle out of me.
“I just ran into Bree.”
“Is it the first time since …”
“Yeah. It was … weird.”
“Are you okay?”
Am I? I’ve been imagining that meeting for so long, now that it has taken place it’s almost anticlimactic. And I still don’t know why Bree did what she did. Maybe I never will. Maybe I just have to learn to move on, regardless.
“Yes,” I tell him, summoning up a smile. “You know, I think I am.”
He hands me my wrap and shifts from one foot to the other.
“So, before my sister gets back, I wanted to ask you … Do you want to go to the homecoming dance?”
He takes me totally by surprise.
“With you?”
“No, with Iron Man,” he quips, smiling, his warm eyes lighting up. “Yes, with me!”
I don’t know if it’s because I just saw Bree, or if it’s just because I’m a coward.
“I’m sorry … I can’t. I’ve got to get back.”
And I turn and run back to the sidelines.
I immediately regret it.
Syd says I should have said yes and just gone. She says it’s like trying to get back on a bicycle to ride after falling off. But if you fall off a bike and you break your arm, the doctor can tell you how long it’s going to take to heal. So many weeks wearing a cast, so many weeks of physical therapy, and, boom, you’re good to go.
But when someone lies to you and makes you afraid to trust, it’s different. No one can tell you how long it’ll take for that damage to heal. You can’t just take a pill or wear a cast or do so many reps of weights in physical therapy. I’m still seeing my therapist, and although I’m better than I was, I know there’s still a long way to go.
Syd and Liam are in the living room watching a movie, a bowl of popcorn balanced between them. He has his arm around her, and when she feeds him a piece, he kisses the tips of her fingers as she places the kernel to his lips.
When they laugh about something — and I don’t know if it’s because I’m sick of feeling like the third wheel or because I’m ready to feel happy for me, and I realize to do that I need to take a ride on the bicycle — I make a decision. When I get to my room, I text Luis and ask him if he’s found a date for the homecoming dance yet and say if not, I’ve changed my mind and I’d love to go with him. I apologize for being a coward yesterday.