“We think they died sometime between midnight and five in the morning,” Mathesson said. “We can’t get much closer than that right now. We’re checking everybody in the building, trying to find out when they got home.”
“Who were they?” Reardon asked.
“Two roommates. Both names are on the mailboxes downstairs. One of them is named Lee McDonald, and the other one – the one in the other room – is named Karen Ortovsky.”
“Anything else?”
“McDonald worked at a law firm. The other one worked for some fashion place. A designer, maybe. Something like that.” Mathesson’s face turned ruminative. “But there’s something kind of funny.”
“What’s that?”
“Well, we haven’t been able to find any address book or anything like that around here. There’s a lot of cash. Fifty-five dollars in this little desk, another seventy-five in the kitchen, and a hundred and twenty bucks in a night stand in the other room. But no address book at all. No file of telephone numbers. No list of friends. Nothing like that. It don’t seem quite right, to tell you the truth. I mean, hell, every woman has a list of names and telephone numbers.”
Reardon peered around the room. “Did you check the back of the phone book?”
“Yeah. Nothing. Blank. No names written in it or circled anywhere in the book.” He looked for some response in Reardon’s face, then he added: “A couple of boys are going through all the clothes in the bedroom, but so far we just got the stuff in their purses, you know. Company ID’s and credit cards. That sort of shit.”
Reardon took out his notebook. “Give me the names of the companies they worked for.”
Mathesson took out his notebook and quickly thumbed through it until he reached the correct page. “McDonald worked for a law firm named Bailey, Merritt and White. They’re at 1604 Sixth Avenue. The other one worked at Tristan Designers at 147 West 37th Street.”
“Okay. And find out which bank they used and check out any safety deposit boxes they might have had. There might be something in them we ought to know about. And keep looking for some kind of address book. I don’t see any signs of a forced entry here so they may have known the killer, may have had his name written down somewhere.”
“Yeah,” Mathesson said, “like I said, that might explain why they’re missing names and numbers.”
“Maybe,” Reardon said.
“Well, I guess you want to look around.”
“Yeah.”
“The other one’s tied up in the bedroom closet,” Mathesson said.
Reardon nodded. He took a deep breath, exhaled quickly, nervously, stepped past Mathesson and walked farther into the apartment. He did not like what he saw.
Lee McDonald lay near the far wall, opposite the apartment entrance. She had been butchered like a hog on a rack, stabbed in both eyes, her throat cut almost to the spinal column. There were deep slashes in both her thighs and one long deep cut across her left jaw. One breast had been almost severed from her body and hung like a flap over her rib cage. The other breast had been flayed open by numerous thrusts of the blade. She had been stabbed completely through one hand, splitting it in two between the middle and index fingers.
“All her clothes were just cut off her,” Mathesson said as he stepped up behind Reardon. “Like opening a package.”
Slithers of clothing lay scattered about the room like discarded ribbons. All the furniture on the right side of the room – two small chairs and a table – was overturned; one of the chairs had been thrown all the way to the other side of the room and rested on its side near Lee McDonald’s ankles. On the back wall a painting was tipped far to the right, and the small pink sofa that rested below it was dappled with blood. The left wall of the room was covered with blood, but none of the furniture was disturbed.
From the position of the body and its condition, and from the splotches on the walls, Reardon could visualize what must have happened in that room during the last two or three minutes of Lee McDonald’s life.
Someone had come through the front and only door of the apartment. He had had with him – under his coat or wrapped like a package or hidden in a newspaper – a broad-bladed knife, perhaps ten to twelve inches long and three to five inches wide at its greatest width. With this weapon, and perhaps some other one – even a gun – he had forced both women into the adjoining bedroom, where he had tied up Karen Ortovsky and dumped her in the bedroom closet like a bag of dirty laundry.
Then he must have told Lee to come with him into the living room. Either that, or she had attempted flight, tried to make it to the only door. But too late.
“Where’s the other woman?” Reardon asked.
Mathesson pointed to the open bedroom door. “In there.”
Reardon nodded and went into the bedroom.
In the brutal relativity of murder, Karen Ortovsky had gotten off easier. Her body lay in the bedroom closet adjoining the room in which Lee McDonald had died. She was bound and gagged, her legs bent under her at the knees and tied at the ankles. Her throat had been cut almost to the spinal column. Her eyes were wide open and a piece of tissue paper, part of the gag that had been crammed all the way to the windpipe, dangled ludicrously from the left side of her mouth.
Reardon stared at the face. It was an ordinary face. But it suddenly appeared to him to be the smallest, most delicately etched and hideously violated face he had ever seen on an adult. With its up-turned nose and small, thin mouth, barely wider than a half-dollar piece, it seemed to retain the features of a child.
Reardon knelt down beside the slumped body of Karen Ortovsky and with two fingers gently closed her eyes.
“Well, what do you think?” Mathesson asked as he walked into the bedroom. “Do you think there’s a connection with the deer thing?”
Reardon stood up slowly, feeling a weakness in his knees. “I don’t know.”
“Piccolini thinks there is, right?”
“Yeah.” He looked down again into the face of the body crumpled at his feet. “Sometimes enough is enough,” he whispered.
“Huh?”
Somehow, Reardon thought, if the eyes had been closed, like those of Lee McDonald, he could have borne the rest with greater ease. But the eyes of Karen Ortovsky had burned into him like naked light bulbs in a solid darkness, screaming for more than conventional justice could offer. Reardon knew immediately that Karen Ortovsky had been the last to die. He knew that she had cowered, tied like a beast, while the murderous tumult went on in the next room. She had heard each slash of the blade tearing into Lee McDonald’s flesh, had heard her roommate’s body pivot and stagger into tables, overturn chairs, flail wildly against each wall and then finally collapse helplessly to the floor, where only the final whimpering exhalations could be heard above the merciless whirring of the blade.
Reardon shuddered and quickly walked out into the other room.
“So now you’re back in homicide,” Reardon heard Mathesson say behind him, but he could not answer. “I knew you would be. I knew it was coming. Just like I said that day at the zoo, about those deer. It’s the same thing. Just like the guy with the cats. A maniac like that will eventually get around to people. It never fails. I’ve never seen it to fail.”
Reardon stood in the middle of the living room, as silent and immobile as an icon. “She seemed so small,” he said.
“Yeah,” Mathesson replied, “that little McDonald girl couldn’t of been more than five feet tall.”
“I meant Karen.” Reardon said. “Her face was so small, like a child’s face.”
“I didn’t notice, to tell you the truth.” Mathesson took a cigarette from his pocket and lit it. “But I knew it would come to people in the end. It always does. Just like that scumbag with the cats.”
Reardon shook his head. He turned toward the entrance of the apartment. “I’ve got to step out for some fresh air,” he said to Mathesson. “It’s stifling in here.”