Day after Halloween: smashed pumpkins in the streets, trees draped with toilet paper; some windows soaped; candy wrappers on the sidewalk. Simple, old-fashioned mischief, the kind we haven’t had in the city in some years. For safety reasons, trick-or-treating doesn’t happen in most neighborhoods there, and pranks are usually on the vandalous side. Many times Halloween parties end in injuries and fatalities.
Of course, the day before Halloween here had been fatal for Hayley Perez. A reminder that no matter where you are, the world is a dangerous place.
The scarecrow in the Food Mart’s parking lot had been dismembered: its head lay on top of the bales of hay, its clothes strewn around. Black spray paint on the white wall said THE DEVEL MADE ME DO IT! No one ever said graffiti artists can spell.
I went inside, made my selections, and took them to the same checker I’d spoken with last Tuesday night. While she was ringing the order up she asked, “Did you find Amy Perez?”
“No, I haven’t.”
“You hear about her sister, Hayley?”
“The woman who was murdered? Yes.”
“I’m wondering: Amy didn’t come in to work today, and nobody’s seen her. Maybe she and that scumbag Boz Sheppard killed her sister and took off. Nobody’s seen him, either.”
“Why would they do such a thing?”
“Money. I hear Hayley had a big life-insurance policy.”
“Oh, yeah? How much?”
“Not sure, but they say Amy was the beneficiary.”
“Who says this?”
“Well, everybody.” She swung out her arm to include the whole store, maybe the whole town.
Small-town gossip. One misleading remark, and everybody thinks it’s gospel.
Still, I asked, “D’you know what company insured her?”
“There’s only one broker in town-Bud Smith. He represents a lot of companies.”
“But Hayley had been gone a long time; she must’ve taken out the policy somewhere else.”
“She’s been back long enough. Was staying with Boz Sheppard out in that trailer where she was killed. Didn’t show her face in town much, though.”
“Why not?”
The clerk shrugged. “Ashamed because she ran off and came back with nothing to show for it? Didn’t want to run into her mother? I mean, who does want to run into Miri? You should ask Bud Smith.”
Bud Smith was in his mid-forties and losing his blond hair; a short military-style cut couldn’t disguise it. He was lean and wiry, dressed in a loud plaid polyester jacket that was decades out of date and a shirt and tie of the same era. Obviously a fan of vintage clothing. He was on the phone when I entered his office in a lakeside strip mall, but greeted me with a smile and waved me toward a chair.
The smile faded as he said into the phone, “No, stay there. Stay right there. I’ll come as soon as I can.”
For a moment after he hung up he stared down at the desk. Then he looked at me and said, “What can I do for you?”
When I said I was helping the Perez family deal with the details of Hayley’s death, his face grew even more somber: he reminded me of an eccentrically attired funeral director.
“Such a tragedy,” he said, “such a waste.” His sorrowful expression looked genuine.
“We understand Hayley had taken out a life-insurance policy with you. And that the beneficiary was her younger sister, Amy.”
“Uh, yes, she did.” He began fiddling with a stack of papers on his desk, tapping them into a neat pile. “Are you putting in a claim? If so, Amy should be the one-”
“Amy’s out of town and we haven’t been able to reach her. Basically, all we want to know is if the policy exists and what its terms are.”
“Hayley should have had the policy in her possession. She picked it up”-he flipped backward through his desk calendar-“on September twenty-sixth.”
So she’d been in town for quite a while. Why, as the clerk at the Food Mart had said, hadn’t she “shown her face”?
I said, “Perhaps she put it in a safe place. The trailer where she was staying wasn’t very secure.”
“Apparently not, since she was murdered there.” Smith hesitated, running his hand over his clean-shaven chin. “I’m not sure I should be discussing the policy with you. Are you a relative?”
“A good friend. Ramon Perez is manager at my husband’s and my ranch.”
“Oh, you’re Hy Ripinsky’s new wife. I heard he got married again. Forgive me. I’ll be glad to tell you anything you need to know.”
I love to ask questions in small towns where I’m an insider. Hate it when I’m an outsider and they raise the bar against me.
Bud Smith went to a file cabinet and came back to his desk with a slim manila folder. “She came in on September seventh. Said her mother was unreliable-which is true-and that her other siblings, except for Amy, were either dead or in prison. She wanted to provide for Amy should something happen to her. We agreed on a fifty-thousand-dollar whole-life policy, which would accumulate a cash value that could be withdrawn at any time if Hayley, as owner of the policy, needed money.”
“Why fifty thousand?”
“The premiums were affordable, and Hayley felt it was enough to give Amy a new start in life.”
“She explain what she meant by that?”
“No. And I didn’t ask. I don’t pry into my clients’ personal affairs.”
“Did Hayley have to undergo a medical exam to get the coverage?”
“Not at twenty-five. She filled out the usual health disclosure form; that was enough.”
“And what address did she give you?”
He consulted the file. “Her mother’s, but she asked the policy not be sent there, which is why she picked it up.”
“This type of policy-is there a double indemnity clause, in case of accidental death or murder?”
The right corner of Smith’s mouth twitched. “Yes. Of course. Unless she was killed by the beneficiary… Not that Amy would’ve done such a thing. The girl’s a little wayward, but not bad.”
“How d’you know?”
“My avocation is volunteering as a life-skills coach. Helping kids who are at risk. My friend Dana Ivins, who runs the organization, had several sessions with her. She-Dana-thought Amy had great potential.”
“This organization is called…?”
“Friends Helping Friends. The name is designed to let troubled teens know we coaches don’t consider ourselves superior, but just people who’ve undergone and overcome the same obstacles they’re facing.”
“Sounds like a good program.”
Bud Smith’s smile was a shade melancholy. “We try. That’s all we can do-try.”
Friends Helping Friends operated out of a dilapidated cottage on an unpaved side street at the west end of town, across the highway from the point where Zelda’s was situated. A sign on the door said COME RIGHT IN, so I did. A short hallway opened in front of me. To my left was a parlor full of shabby but comfortable-looking furnishings; in the room to my right, a thin woman with short gray hair and round glasses that gave her face an owlish look sat at a desk. She saw me and smiled.
“What can I do for you?”
I introduced myself. “I’m interested in speaking with one of your coaches, Dana Ivins.”
“You are in luck.” She got up and extended her hand across the desk to me. “I’m Dana.”
“Bud Smith told me you’ve been working with a girl named Amy Perez.”
She frowned. “Sit down, please. I’m afraid Bud shouldn’t have revealed that. Part of our success is that we keep our clients’ names confidential.”
“Would you explain to me how the organization works?”
“Well, the name describes it. We pair young people who are at risk with coaches who have had similar problems earlier in life. They can meet here in our parlor if the clients’ homes aren’t a supportive environment-which in most cases they’re not-or if they aren’t comfortable being seen with their coaches in public. Or they can pick another meeting place-so long as it isn’t the coach’s home; that’s inviting trouble from parents who resent our intrusion. We listen to the clients’ stories and tell them ours and what we’ve learned from them. It’s strictly a volunteer program with very little overhead, and what there is is funded by donations from local businesses. This is my house, so we don’t have to pay for offices.”