No. Stella, you're mad. Keep it there.
“And you, drop that pissed look from your face before I smack it off,” I threaten Aaron, who cracks a smile.
“Don’t smile either!” I snap again, making his stupid handsome smile grow bigger.
“I can’t even talk to you two. I hate you both right now.”
“Now you’re just lying, Lucky. You love us,” Justin says, placing a kiss on my cheek.
“Do not.” My words sound childish but I don’t care.
“That’s all right. We love you enough to make up for it.”
Justin’s words make me heart clench. I glance over at Aaron who just stares at him. “I’m sorry you even have to look at me for confirmation of that, Lucky,” Aaron says, taking a step closer to me. “I love you so fucking much. That’s what we’ve been trying to do these past few weeks—make you fall in love with us. To show you how perfect we could be for you. I thought you could tell, I…” He glances up at Justin, “We love you more than anything. You’re it for us.”
The elevator dings, the door sliding open to reveal our room. “Put me down.” I can see Justin's reluctance, but he does, and I walk into the living room with both men following me.
“You tricked me and manipulated me to get what you wanted from me,” I say, turning to stare at them. They don’t even look guilty about it.
“I’d do it again in a heartbeat,” they say in unison.
I don’t even know how to respond to that. Part of me wants to smack them both, and the other part wants to jump around with joy and to tell them I love them too. I knew if they ever got their hands on me that I would fall for them instantly. That's why I pushed them away at first.
“Is what we did sneaky? Yeah. But you didn't give us a choice. You wouldn't give us the time of day,” Justin says, pleading their case.
“That’s no excuse,” I throw back at them.
“You love us?” Aaron asks, drawing my eyes to his. I know what he's doing. Aaron is pretty direct about things. That’s likely a big part of why I’m standing here. He probably concocted the whole plan, and then Justin more than likely took off with it.
“That’s not the point I’m getting at.” He wants me to admit it because if I do, then this fight will be over. I’m theirs. Simple as that.
“Lucky, do you love us?” This time I see something flash across his eyes. He’s scared.
“Yes, you brutes!” I all but yell at them, not wanting them to have any doubt that I love them.
They both smile big, and I just roll my eyes.
“You love us because of who we are, how we go about things, and, baby, how we handle you,” Justin says.
He’s right. I love the way the three of us fit together. It works for us. Like we were built for each other.
“No more tricks,” I say, pointing between them, my resolve melting away.
Justin at least tries to look a little guilty, while Aaron just shakes his head.
“Can’t promise you that. There isn’t a card I won’t play, pull, or use to keep you with us.” He steps forward, lifting me under my arms so that I’m at eye level with him. “Not one thing. We’d burn down the world just to keep you.”
How can I fight with that? I can’t even find the words, so I just kiss him.
13
JUSTIN
Aaron goes over, picks Stella up, and takes her to the bed. I join him in stripping her out of her clothes, and then we start to remove ours.
I loom over her, looking down at her body and touching her belly. “I love you, Stella. All we ever wanted was to keep you forever. To make a family with you. To bind you to us.”
Aaron joins me and rubs his hand on her lower belly too. “I love you too, and we’ve been trying like crazy to make our seed stick so that you could give us a baby and never have to leave us. We want to marry you together and be a family. We want you round with our baby, tits dripping with milk, and always filled with cum.”
“How can you be sure I’m pregnant? I went to the doctor. He put in an IUD. There’s no way.”
“Anything is possible with enough money, Stella. The doctor just gave you a normal exam and made sure you were healthy enough to be bred. Did the exam hurt, or did it feel like he put anything inside you?”
Her face looks surprised, but not upset. “No.”
“We wanted you, and we’d do anything to have you. Now that you’re here, we are never letting go.”
Aaron leans down, kissing her belly, and I move to suckle her nipple. She moans at the touches, and I look at Aaron and nod my head.
“Let us make love to you together, Lucky. It’s time.”
She reaches out and touches both of us. “I love you both too. I’m ready.”
I look over at Aaron. “Get the lube.” Aaron moves to the side table, and tosses me the tube. Then he gets on the bed and lies down on his back. He pulls Stella on top of him. She straddles his hips, her legs spread wide as she exposes her ass to me.
We’ve been preparing her ass for the past month, but we haven’t both taken Lucky at the same time. We wanted to save it for a special moment, and this seems to be it. It’s the ideal way we’d like to fuck her so that Aaron and I are able to be inside her at the same time. Both of her tight holes clenching around us as we both stuff our cock inside her.
Stella looks down at Aaron, and I can see there’s a little fear on her face. He brushes her hair out of her eyes, and kisses her lips gently. “It’s okay, Lucky. Let us love you together. We’ll make it perfect for you. You trust us to take care of you, right, baby?”
She looks back at me and reaches up. I lean my cheek into her palm, and she nods her head, giving us her body in the last way possible. She’ll be ours completely now, and it feels so fucking perfect.
As she leans forward on top of Aaron, his cock juts up behind her. I reach down and lift her hips a little so his cock lines up with her pussy, and she slowly sinks down on him. I drizzle the lube on her asshole, and she shivers at the touch.
“Easy, baby. Just remember to relax and breathe. It’s just like when we use our fingers.”
I see her relax a little, and Aaron leans down, sucking a nipple into his mouth. That should help distract her a little. I use two fingers to rub in the lube and slick up her tight hole. I’ve finger fucked her asshole a few times, but it’s still beyond virgin tight. I knew since Aaron got her pussy first, her ass was mine. I’m glad we waited to get to it, because now I won’t cum in it in five seconds like I did her cunt.
I press the tip of my cock to her asshole, holding it there and lubing it up. I see the tight ring clench at the pressure, and my cock drips cum on her hole, begging for entry. “Relax, baby, and push back against me. Let me in.”
Stella rocks back a little, and I barely breach the tightness. Fuck, that sweet ass is going to fight me as I try to get inside. It’s going to strangle my cock, and I leak more cum, feeling it suck me in a little more with each rock.
After a little more pressure, I pop through her tight asshole, and we all breathe a sigh of relief. “That’s it, Lucky, open up for me. Push back on my dick and help me slide in while Aaron stays in your pussy.”
Stella moans, loving my filthy words. She may seem sweet and innocent, but between us, she’s our dirty girl. She pushes back farther, taking more of my cock in her ass. She fucks herself on both of our cocks, slowly begging to be filled. Taking her ass virginity is so good. She’s so tight and squeezes me so perfectly that even though she lets me get off in her at least three times a day, I don’t have the stamina to last with this feeling. “It’s so tight, baby. You feel so good.”