Ellery hesitated. ”I’m a writer.”
The real-estate man gaped. ”You write stories?”
“That’s it, Mr. Pettigrew. Books and such.”
“Well, well,” beamed J.C. ”I’m real honored to meet you, Mr. Smith.
Smith . . . Now that’s funny,” said J.C. ”I’m a reading man myself, but I just don’t seem to recollect an author named¯What did you say your first name was, Mr. Smith?”
“I didn’t say, but it’s Ellery. Ellery Smith.”
“Ellery Smith,” said J.C., concentrating.
Mr. Queen smiled. ”I write under a pen name.”
“Ah! Name of . . . ?” But when Mr. Pettigrew saw that Mr. ”Smith” simply kept smiling, he rubbed his jaw and said: “Course you’d give references?”
“Would three months’ rent in advance give me a good character in Wrightsville, Mr. Pettigrew?”
“Well, I should smile!” grinned J.C. ”You come with me, Mr. Smith. I’ve got exactly the house you’re looking for.”
* * *
“What did you mean by asking me if I’m superstitious?” asked Ellery as they climbed into J.C.’s pea-green coupe and drove off. ”Is the house haunted?”
“Uh . . . no,” said J.C. ”Though there is a sort of a queer yarn connected with that house¯might give you an idea for one of your, now, books, hey?” Mr. ”Smith” agreed; it might. ”This house, it’s next door to John F.’s own place on the Hill. John F. Wright, that is. He’s President of the Wrightsville National. Oldest family in town.
“Well, sir, three years ago one of John F.’s three daughters¯the middle one, Nora¯Nora got herself engaged to this Jim Haight. Jim was head cashier at John F.’s bank. Wasn’t a local boy¯he’d come to Wrightsville from New York a couple of years before that with fine recommendations. Started out as an assistant teller, and he was making good. Steady boy, Jim; stayed away from the bad element, went to the library a lot, didn’t have much fun, I s’pose¯a movie at Louie Cahan’s Bijou, or standing around Band Concert Nights with the rest of the boys, watching the girls parade up and down eating popcorn, and joshing ‘em. Worked hard¯plenty of up-and-go, Jim had, and independent? Say, I never saw a lad stand on his two feet like Jim did. We all liked him a heap.”
Mr. Pettigrew sighed, and Ellery wondered why such a glowing subject should depress him.
“I take it Miss Nora Wright liked him more than anyone,” said Ellery to grease the wheels of the story.
“That’s a fact,” muttered J.C. ”Wild about the boy. Nora’d been the quiet kind before Jim came along¯has to wear specs, and I guess it made her think she wasn’t attractive to boys, ‘cause she used to sit in the house while Lola and Patty went out with fellows¯reading or sewing or helping her ma with organization work.
“Well, sir, Jim changed all that. Jim wasn’t the kind to be stopped by a pair of eyeglasses. Nora’s a pretty girl, and Jim started to rush her, and she changed . . . My, she changed!”
J.C. frowned. ”S’pose I’m blabbing too much. Anyway, you get the idea. When Jim and Nora got engaged, the town said it was a fine match, especially after what had happened to John’s oldest daughter, Lola.”
Ellery said quickly: “And what was that, Mr. Pettigrew?”
J.C. swung the coupe into a broad country road. They were well away from town now, and Ellery feasted his eyes on the succulent greens of the countryside.
“Did I say something about Lola?” asked the real-estate man feebly. ”Why . . . Lola, she’d run away from home. Eloped with an actor from a visiting stock company. After a while she came back home to Wrightsville. Divorced.” J.C. set his lips stubbornly, and Mr. Queen realized he wasn’t going to hear any more about Miss Lola Wright.
“Well, anyway,” continued J.C., “John and Hermione Wright decided to give Jim and their Nora a furnished house for a wedding present. John cut off part of his property near his own house and built. Right next door, ‘cause Hermy wanted Nora as close by as possible, seeing she’d . . . lost one of her girls already.”
“Lola,” nodded Mr. Queen. ”Divorced, you said? Came back home afterwards. Then Lola Wright doesn’t live with her father and mother anymore?”
“No,” said J.C. shortly. ”So John built Jim and Nora a sweet little six-roomer next door. Hermione was putting in rugs and furniture and drapes and linen and silver¯the works¯when all of a sudden it happened.”
“What happened?” asked Mr. Queen.
“To tell the truth, Mr. Smith, nobody knows,” said the real-estate man sheepishly. ”Nobody ‘cepting Nora Wright and Jim Haight. It was the day before the wedding and everything looked fine as corn silk, when Jim Haight ups and leaves town! Fact. Ran away. That was three years ago, and he’s not been back since.”
They were on a winding, rising road. Ellery saw wide old houses on voluptuous lawns, and elms and maples and cypress and weeping willows taller than the houses.
Mr. Pettigrew scowled at the Hill road. ”The next morning John F. found a note of resignation on his desk at the bank, but not a word as to why Jim’d skipped town. And Nora wouldn’t say a blessed word. Just shut herself up in her bedroom and wouldn’t come out for her father or mother or sister Patricia or even old Ludie, the hired girl who’s practically brought the three Wright girls up. Nora just kept bawling in her room. My daughter Carmel and Patty Wright are thick as molasses, and Pat told Carmel the whole thing. Pat did a heap of crying herself that day. I guess they all did.”
“And the house?” murmured Mr. Queen.
J.C. drove his car to the side of the road and shut off the motor. ”Wedding was called off. We all thought Jim’d turn up, thinking it was just a lovers’ spat; but he didn’t. Whatever broke those two up must have been awful important!” The real-estate man shook his head. ”Well, there was the new house, all ready to be lived in, and no one to live in it. Terrible blow to Hermione. Hermy let out that Nora’d jilted Jim. But people did keep jawing about it, and after a while . . . ” Mr. Pettigrew paused.
“Yes?” prompted Ellery.
“After a while people began saying Nora’d gone . . . crazy and that that little six-roomer was jinxed.”
“Jinxed!”
J.C. smiled a sickly smile. ”Funny how some folks are, isn’t it? Thinking the house had anything to do with Jim and Nora’s breaking up! And of course ain’t nothing wrong with Nora. I mean, she’s not crazy. Crazy!”
J.C. snorted. ”That wasn’t the whole of it. When it looked like Jim wasn’t coming back, John F. decided to sell that house he’d built for his daughter. Pretty soon along came a buyer¯relative of Judge Martin’s wife, Clarice, man named Hunter of the Boston branch of the family. I was handling the deal.”
J.C. lowered his voice. ”Mr. Smith, I give you my word I’d taken this Mr. Hunter over to the house for a last inspection before signing the papers, and we were looking around the living room and Mr. Hunter was saying, ‘I don’t like the sofa just there,’ when he gets kind of a scared look all of a sudden and grabs his heart and falls down right in front of me! Died on the spot! I didn’t sleep for a week.”
He swabbed his forehead.
“Doc Willoughby said it was heart failure. But that’s not what the town said. The town said it was the house. First Jim ran away, then a buyer dropped dead. And to make it worse, some smart-aleck of a cub reporter on Frank Lloyd’s Record wrote up Hunter’s death and he called the house ‘Calamity House’ in his yarn. Frank fired him. Frank’s friendly with the Wrights.”
“Of all the nonsense!” chuckled Mr. Queen.