“Great. He’s dead.” Molly threw her body against the back of her chair, her arms crossed tightly across her chest. “That gets us nowhere.” “Rodney knew about Kate Plummer,” she said. “He knew things about where she was.” “I know that, Edie. That’s not new.” “He only knew some details, not all of it. But the two of you,” she looked at Molly, “together, you might know about the girl.” “What does that mean, Edie? He and I can’t do anything together. He’s dead.” Edie folded her trembling hands in her lap, and spoke in a hushed voice. “Rodney is only one that can help.” “Edie,” Molly said, exasperated. Edie leaned forward, “What I tell you, you no hear from me.” “Okay,” Molly said, believing she’d found someone crazier than herself. “You no tell anyone. You no tell Jin,” she said Jin’s name with a faltering, quivering voice. “I promise, Edie,” Molly said.
Edie looked around, as if expecting someone to suddenly show up, catching her in the act of telling her secret. “Rodney didn’t take her. He just saw her, here,” she pointed to her head. “People think he took her, think he hurt her, because police take him in.” “That’s why they killed him,” Molly nodded. “Yes, beat him.” “Awful,” Molly said, sadly. “His sister take him away, back home. She take him that night. Pack him in the car and go, before he got more hurt.”
Molly perched on the edge of her seat, More hurt?
“His sister take him to Delaware, but his parents no want him. Too much trouble. They—”
“Wait!” Molly interrupted. “He was dead. What do you mean too much trouble?” “He no dead. He almost dead, still breathing.” “What?” Molly said incredulously. “He no die,” Edie said. “He lived? Rodney is alive?” Molly was in disbelief. Edie nodded. “He might be able to lead us to Kate’s body,” Molly said anxiously. “No!” she said, thumping the table again with her fist. “He no involved!”
Molly grabbed Edie’s hand. “Edie, you have to help me. If Rodney knew things, maybe you’re right, maybe together we can find Tracey and figure out what happened to Kate.” Edie suddenly looked five years older than she did when she had walked into the restaurant. “I don’t know where he is,” she said. “Damn it, Edie, come on,” Molly said loudly. “What are you worried about? You must know where he is.” Edie shook her head. “If police find him, they arrest him again. Or worse, Rodney beat again,” she hissed. “I won’t tell the police, Edie. I promise,” Molly pleaded, her mind raced through the possible outcome: finding Kate’s body.
Edie looked around the restaurant nervously. Molly urged her again, using Edie’s own thoughts, that together, Molly and Rodney could find Tracey. Finally, Edie conceded. “Very dangerous, you involved, Molly. Very dangerous.” She looked down at her tea once again, “Pastor Lett, she know where to find Rodney. I not see Rodney. I just know he alive.”
The Perkinson House, Molly thought, remembering the locks on the windows and the sensation of the strong hands upon her own at the cellar doors. Molly knew that she would not keep her promise to Edie. She had to call Sergeant Moeler.
“Why, why, why?” Pastor Lett sobbed, repeatedly hitting the back of the couch with her fisted hand. She raised her arms toward the ceiling, “Why? Why do I have to go through this again?” She paced, frustrated, saddened once again by the ghost of a brother she once had, once cherished, and still loved. She knew what she had to do. She’d seen Molly in the woods, spying on her. She gathered her store of empty boxes, pulled on her overcoat and gloves, and picked up the phone.
Hannah’s voice was soft, tired, as if she were on the edge of sleep and had been brought back to wakefulness, “Hannah, it’s Carla. I’m sorry to bother you so late.” “What’s wrong, Carla?” “We need to talk. Can we meet at your house, right away?” she asked, urgently. “Yes, yes, of course. Are you going to call, or shall I?”
“I will. Just be ready. We need to move fast.” She was thankful for Hannah’s lack of questions. She hung up the phone and dialed again. “Newton, it’s Carla. We have an issue. Trouble.” “Carla? Okay, yes. Um, where?” “Hannah’s house. I’ll meet you there.” She hung up before hearing Newton’s reply.
As Pastor Lett drove through the empty streets of Boyds, she felt as though she were being watched through the darkened windows of the homes she passed. She went by Molly’s house, and she envisioned her stewing over the whole situation. She couldn’t blame her for wanting to find Tracey. She didn’t like to have harsh feelings towards others, but she was hurt, maddened even—seeing her at her house in the middle of the night, then at the manse. The pastor side of her wondered how she would get past the ill feelings that brewed within her to find her way to forgiveness.
Newton’s car was already in Hannah’s driveway when she arrived. She rushed up the back steps. The dogs barked as she rapped three times on the door with her gloved hand. Hannah’s tense face greeted her, her dark brown hair piled in a loose bun on her head. She guided her silently to the parlor where Newton sat fidgeting with his keys, his Members Only jacket zipped right up to his chin.
“Thank you for meeting me,” Pastor Lett said quickly. “We have an issue, or at least, I think we might have an issue. I’m not certain, but just in case, I think we need to move swiftly.” They eyed one another seriously.
“What is it, Carla? What’s happened?” Hannah folded her hands in her lap.
“Molly Tanner’s been snooping around,” she paced nervously, “asking about Rodney.” She poured a cup of tea from the silver pot that Hannah had set out for them, and took a slow sip. The warmth of the liquid calmed her nerves. “Molly?” asked Hannah. “Why would Molly ask about Rodney? I just don’t understand.” She adjusted her sweatshirt, flustered. “Why, she’d have no reason not to trust you,” Newton said, quickly. “I don’t think she’s causing trouble, really, but I want to take precautions.” “Carla, what exactly are you worried about?” Hannah asked.
Pastor Lett stood and walked behind Hannah’s Victorian sofa, looking out the window, running her hand through her hair, then down her face, trying to figure out exactly what she was worried about. She returned to the sofa and sat down, bracing her hands on her knees. “I don’t know,” her words were rushed, frustrated. “I’m worried that they’ll search the Perkinson House.” She ejected a sigh of relief. She’d finally said it, after all of those years of hiding behind each other’s glances, behind the safety of their carefully-executed stories. It had been released, laid naked on the table before them.
“The Perkinson House?” Hannah asked.
“She saw me, one night, when I had rowed over there.”
“Oh, Carla,” Newton said, fidgeting with his hands. “This is bad, real bad. What are we going to do? After all these years. The Perkinsons trusted you. We have to do something.” He spoke quickly, as if the taste of the words would cause him pain.
“I know that, Newton!” Carla said sharply. “We need to go there, to make sure the cellar is secure, and, if they get a search warrant, to make sure there are no….holes for them to find.”
“Yes, yes, right. We need to go right now.” Newton stood to leave.
“What should I bring?” Hannah asked.
“No, Hannah, you stay here. It’s late and cold. I don’t want you out there in this weather. Besides, Carla and I can handle this,” Newton said, protectively.
“Nonsense, Newton. I’m coming, and that’s that. Now, what do we need?” Her hands on her hips told him that she had made up her mind.