Nate shrugged. “Wouldn’t it have been something if we’d drawn down on each other by mistake? That would be a hell of a thing.”
Joe stifled a smile. It wasn’t funny what they’d almost done to each other, but the way Nate said it was.
Joe said, “It’s good to see you, Nate.”
“Likewise.”
“I’m sorry about what happened in the canyon. I found the scaffold.”
“Did you tell anyone?”
“Marybeth and Alice Thunder. Both have kept it to themselves.”
Nate nodded, grateful. He said, “I found the guys who did it, and the woman who put them up to it. I put the guys down, but I let the woman off . . .”
“No details,” Joe said, putting his hand up to stop Nate from saying more.
Silence hung in the air.
Joe said, “Nate, can we get past what happened last year?”
Nate nodded. He said, “I’ve had plenty of time to think about it, as I’m sure you have. It boils down to this: You were wrong, but you had no choice.”
Joe said, “I think I agree.”
“Then we don’t need to talk about it anymore,” Nate said.
Joe liked that.
“So,” Nate said, “where did that son-of-a-bitch Bud Longbrake go?”
Before Joe could speculate on an answer, he heard the sound of motors outside and the quick whoop of a siren that blew open the quiet night. Flashing red and blue lights filled the window and danced across the walls and made the living room seem like an unlikely party scene.
Joe stepped over and parted the curtains with the back of his hand. “The sheriff is here,” he said. Two department vehicles: Sollis’ SUV and McLanahan’s pickup. There were two heads in Sollis’ unit, but the sheriff was alone in his.
“You want me to take them out?” Nate asked, reaching for his .500.
“Jeez, Nate.”
“I’ll catch you later then,” Nate said, retreating toward the mudroom. Joe watched him. He doubted the sheriff had sent anyone around the back to block the back door since he’d arrived with such fanfare at the front.
“My house,” Joe called after him, and Nate was gone.
Joe laid the shotgun on the couch and cautiously opened the door before McLanahan could bang on it. He wanted to show himself in the open, and that he offered no threat.
The sheriff looked purposeful and self-satisfied in the flashing lights of the vehicles. Sollis stood smugly behind him and to the left, with his hand on his holstered weapon. Deputy Reed was farther back, looking solemn.
“Hello, Joe,” McLanahan said. Then to Sollis, over his shoulder, “Arrest this man for breaking and entering and attempting to tamper with a witness. Maybe trespassing as well, if the club wants to charge him.”
Joe sighed. “Except I didn’t do any of those things.” He pointed out the boot on the floor, the reason he had probable cause for entering without a warrant or notice.
“I’ve got photos of what I saw,” Joe said. “I really did think Bud Longbrake was dead or hurt, so I entered. The garage door was unlocked.”
“Anybody with you?” McLanahan asked, peering over Joe’s shoulder.
“No.” Thinking: Nate should be sprinting across the lawn out back toward the edge of the property. Still, he felt guilty for misleading the sheriff.
McLanahan rocked back on his heels and hooked his thumbs in his belt loops so he could lean back and look down his nose at Joe. McLanahan twitched his mustache from side to side, and said, “Not sure I’m buying it.”
Joe shrugged. “I’m not trying to sell you anything.”
“How’d you get access to the club, anyway?”
Joe caught himself before he looked away. “I know the keypad combination.”
“Right,” McLanahan said, snorting. Joe thought he was caught, and he felt cold dread in his belly.
“Probably got it from your dear mother-in-law,” McLanahan said, sure of himself.
Joe felt the dread dissipate. He said, “Rather than screw around with me, I’d suggest you put out an APB on your star witness, Bud Longbrake. He’s gone.”
The sheriff grinned and looked over his shoulder at Sollis, who smiled back at him. Reed found something interesting to stare at on the top of his boots. They knew something he didn’t.
“No need for that,” McLanahan said. “Bud’s safe and warm in sheriff department custody, but I ain’t sayin’ where. He’s probably enjoying a cocktail to calm his nerves. He called us because he heard you were coming after him. He said he feared for his life.”
“That’s ridiculous,” Joe said. “I’d never hurt Bud.”
“Poor old guy,” McLanahan said, ignoring Joe. “He’s under so much pressure, and you make it worse. He’s a sick man, you know.”
Joe shook his head. He recalled Orin Smith saying something similar. “I don’t know about that,” Joe said. “I just need to talk to him.”
“Not before the trial,” McLanahan said, shaking his head. “Not unless he tells me to let you in. Even then, you’d have to get through Dulcie Schalk, and I don’t think you’re real popular with her right now.”
Sighing, Joe said, “You’re on the wrong track, McLanahan. You’ve been wrong since the murder. Bud wants revenge on Missy and he’s using what happened to get back at her. I don’t blame him, but this crime . . . there’s a lot more to it. Things you’ve never even considered or looked at.”
“Yeah, yeah yeah,” McLanahan muttered, dismissing him. Then to Sollis, “Take this yahoo in and get his statement. Then we’ll decide if we want to arrest him and on what charges. Reed, you drive his truck down to the county building. I’ll call Dulcie and see how she wants to proceed.”
Joe said, “You don’t have to do this.”
“Sure I do,” McLanahan said, turning aside to spit a stream of tobacco juice onto the lawn. To Joe, he said, “Why aren’t you out there trying to catch poachers or something? Shouldn’t you be doing your job instead of mine? You ever think about that?”
“I do,” Joe said. “I just figure one of us needs to do your job.”
Reed snorted a laugh and looked away quickly.
McLanahan froze, and Joe saw something ugly pass over his face. Joe squared up, ready if McLanahan swung.
The sheriff took a deep breath and said to Sollis, “Cuff the son-of-a-bitch.”
On the way through the grounds of the Eagle Mountain Club, handcuffs biting his wrists, Joe thought that he was pleased to have hooked back up with Nate. But he couldn’t help thinking it might be too late to affect the outcome of the trial. And he’d never imagined spending a night in a county cell.
He thought of his daughters. Their grandmother up for murder, their father in jail.
April’s words mocked him: “I guess maybe I’m not the only one in this perfect little family who makes mistakes.”
SEPTEMBER 14
Justice has nothing to do with what goes on in a courtroom; Justice is what comes out of a courtroom.
—CLARENCE DARROW
37
On Wednesday morning, the day Bud Longbrake was to take the stand to testify against Missy Alden for the murder of Earl Alden, Joe sat next to Marybeth in the eighth row of the Twelve Sleep Country Courthouse and dug his index finger into his shirt collar to try to loosen it against the tight cinch of his tie. It didn’t give much, and he felt that he was slowly strangling to death.
He surveyed the room. Everyone seemed to have taken the same seats they’d occupied the previous two days since the trial began.