From his expression Pine could read the man clearly. He was curious but guarded. He was looking for an advantage. For anything to get him out of here at the earliest possible moment so he could get on with his criminal career.
“They said FBI and CID,” began Vincenzo, and then he stopped right there, sat back and eyed them. “To what do I owe a visit from so many alphabet letters?”
He had selected his opening move with a pawn, thought Pine. Nothing too dramatic. He was here for info, too.
Puller said, “We’re interested in your son, Tony.”
Vincenzo said nothing to this, but he also didn’t seem surprised by the statement. He looked at Pine. “And you?”
“I’m actually interested in your father, Ito.”
The inmate showed a glimmer of surprise at this request. He folded his arms over his chest. “Why?”
“I’d like to talk to him.”
“Same question.”
“He’s a person of interest in a case I’m looking into.”
“You sure you ain’t after the wrong Vincenzo brother?”
“Bruno’s dead.”
“That’s right. He took a shiv in prison for being a snitch.” He looked over his shoulder, making his point. “Is that what you want for my future?”
“Are there any other Vincenzo brothers besides Ito and Bruno?” asked Pine. “Because I couldn’t find any.”
“No, that’s it. Big Italian Catholic family, but the rest were girls. What case?”
“A kidnapping that Ito was involved in.”
“Bullshit. My old man ran an ice cream shop here in Trenton, about a half mile from our house on the strip where they had all the mom-and-pop shops. It was called Vinnie’s Creamery.”
“ ‘Vinnie’ as in...?” said Pine.
“Just shortened from Vincenzo. What, you think Ito’s Creamery has a nice ring to it?”
“Okay.”
He smiled. “My old man was as pure as the driven snow. Only sold vanilla.” Vincenzo showed white teeth as he smiled at his little joke. “Sound like a kidnapper to you?”
“Circumstances can change people,” interjected Puller.
“What, you mean like Tony?”
“Like a lot of people. But, yeah, like Tony.”
“You’re Army, he’s not.”
“He works here at Fort Dix. That makes it my problem.”
“Tony’s a good boy. It’s probably a misunderstanding.” He looked dead eyed at them as he said this obvious falsehood.
“You have any idea where he might be?”
“I’m in here, he’s out there.”
“You’re saying he’s never come to visit you even though he works here?”
“I don’t remember saying anything like that.”
“How’d you come to inherit Ito’s house?” asked Pine.
Vincenzo’s gaze swiveled back to her. He seemed to enjoy the back-and-forth between the two federal officers. “I was the oldest. And my siblings couldn’t have cared less about it.”
“What about your mother?” said Pine.
“What about her?” said Vincenzo sharply.
“She’s not doing very well.”
He shrugged. “My sisters put her in a place. I wasn’t in a position to have a vote. I was locked in my own dump.”
“I’ve been to see her.”
“So, she’s really not doing good?”
“She has dementia.”
“Lot of that going around, I hear. Got some of that in here, older guys. They talk funny.”
“Your siblings live around here?” asked Puller.
“Nowhere near. I don’t think Jersey agreed with them. They got out quick as they could. Me, I like it just fine, only not so much in this place.”
Pine had a sudden thought. “Did your dad ever use the nursery rhyme ‘eeny, meany, miney, moe’ with you and your siblings while you were growing up?”
Vincenzo grinned. “How the hell did you know that?”
“So he did?”
“Yeah, with six kids he used it to pick one of us.”
Pine licked her lips and tried to prevent her nerves from running away from her. “Pick you for what? To... reward?”
Vincenzo shrugged. “Sometimes. But other times to punish. When one of us did something wrong and the others wouldn’t rat him or her out.”
Pine sat back, disappointed and trying hard not to show it. Ito Vincenzo had used that nursery rhyme in deciding whether to take Pine or Mercy that night. She wanted to know if being picked in that manner was a good or bad thing. Vincenzo’s response had obviously not helped.
Puller glanced at her briefly and said, “Back to the house. Tony’s living there.”
“Okay.”
“You knew that?” asked Puller.
“I know it now.”
“When’s the last time you heard from your dad?” asked Pine.
Vincenzo took a moment to scratch his cheek and then rub his nose, which gave him an opportunity to think things through, Pine knew.
“I don’t know. What’s in it for me?”
Finally, we’re getting somewhere, she thought.
Puller sat forward, taking charge. “Let’s cut to the chase, Teddy. You help us, then you help yourself.”
Vincenzo sat forward now too, all business. “How much? And it has to be in writing. To my lawyer. I’m taking no chances with you feds screwing me over.”
“The time you got left here? We can make eight years six.”
“And you can also make eight years four. I’m not getting any younger.”
“Five. But it depends on what you can tell us. Bullshit gets you zip. Deal goes off the table and does not come back.”
Pine could tell by the declarative way Puller said this that these negotiation parameters had been preapproved in his chain of command.
“Oh, tough guy, are we? I’m shitting my pants right now.” Vincenzo said this with a smile that again came nowhere close to his eyes.
“I’m waiting,” said Puller.
“What do you want to know?”
“Where is Tony? And where is Ito?”
Vincenzo glanced at Pine. “Why the hell do you give a shit about my old man?”
“Sometime in 1989, he was gone from home. For several months, maybe? Spring, summer? Ring a bell?”
“That’s a long time ago, lady. I get hung up on stuff from last week.”
“And three years off your time here is a damn good reason to try to remember.”
Vincenzo nodded and his manner turned less flippant and more focused. “Okay, look, I want to help, but I’ll need to give it some thought.”
“Only think in facts. I know enough that the bullshit Chief Puller mentioned applies fully to me as well.”
“Okay, your point is clearly made, lady. I’m not looking to extend my stay here any longer than I have to.”
“He talk to you about Bruno?” she asked.
“Sometimes; they were brothers. He was my uncle.”
“What did he say? I’m talking about what happened to Bruno, when he went to prison the last time.”
“Well, one thing my old man told me stuck with me. He said his brother made a deal that never came through. Cost him his life.” He glanced sharply at Puller. “Which is the position I might find myself in. Snitches don’t have long life expectancies in prison. You walk from this, I’m dead.”
“We can throw in solitary if that’ll make you feel better,” said Puller.
“Did Ito say he was going to do something because of what happened to his brother?” asked Pine.
Vincenzo refocused on her, his expression calming. “Nothing specific that I can remember. He was pissed, that I know.”
“Your father was clean. Not even a traffic ticket. Bruno was mob. Why would he care?”
“It was his own flesh and blood. That means something or used to. Yeah, my old man knew what Bruno was. But Bruno went to prison and he died when he shouldn’t have. Somebody had to pay for that.”