Cynthia led me by the hand into her inner sanctum, away from the office manager’s disapproving gaze, and cleared an empty space for me on her file-cluttered leather sofa. She sat in a matching chair across from me.
Cynthia was wearing a black two-piece suit. The jacket was double-breasted with a shawl collar, the skirt was tight without being too tight and came to the top of her knees, and her blouse was white silk. Lately, that was all she wore. Black and white. I asked her about it once, and she said she was establishing a “definitive image all her own.” More likely it was the definitive image of the consultant at the store where Cynthia bought most of her clothes. Not that I’m complaining. She looks stunning in black and white, with shoulder-length brown hair and matching eyes, with long, shapely legs. I’ve only known two women with more attractive legs. The first was my wife, who was killed along with our daughter nearly five years ago by a drunk driver who Cynthia, in fact, later defended. The second was a twenty-two-year-old murderer I fingered for the Minneapolis cops. She was killed while resisting arrest.
“So, are you working?” Cynthia asked.
It was an honest question. I’m a one-man band, and I usually take on only one case at a time, so I often suffer through periods of unemployment. Occasionally, when those droughts linger long enough to cause me financial distress, I’ll obtain lists of unclaimed property from various government agencies and then locate the missing owners for a percentage of the property’s value. Sometimes—when money is real tight—I’ll do bounty work for a Minneapolis bail bondsman I know. Still, I can’t kick. Last year—my best year yet—I worked one hundred and sixty-nine days and took home nearly thirty-six K after taxes, insurance, health care, and expenses. That might not sound like much. But when you live alone (without house or car payments) like I do, it’s plenty.
“As a matter of fact I am working,” I told Cynthia. “I’m trying to learn what happened to a woman who disappeared last October.”
“I thought you didn’t do runaways.”
“This is a little different. The smart money bets the woman was murdered, but the police can’t find a body or evidence of foul play. I was hired to come up with an explanation that the woman’s attorney can live with.”
“Who’s the lawyer?”
“Ahh, well …” I stammered.
“Not Monica Adler?” Monica was Cynthia’s most hated rival.
“No, no, no,” I assured her. “I haven’t seen Monica since— well, quite awhile. Why would I talk to her?”
“Good question.”
“No, it’s not her.”
“Who, then?”
“He came to my office—”
“Who?”
“Hunter Truman.”
“That piece of shit?”
“You’ve met?” I asked.
“Bastard works the court like a fucking whore; that’s how he peels his banana.”
“Do you eat with that mouth?”
Cynthia flushed a deep crimson and not just from embarrassment. I am always amused when Cynthia’s carefully constructed facade of upper-class gentility slips and the street kid peeks over the top, but she certainly is not. She works hard—and pays a great deal of money—to make sure the facade never slips.
“I am surprised that you would deign to accept employment from that gentleman,” she said, her voice calm and well modulated.
“A buck’s a buck.”
“If you are financially embarrassed, I could lend—”
“Oh, stop it,” I told her. “It’s a job like any other job, maybe a little more interesting than most.”
“But Hunter Truman?!” Cynthia asked, making the name sound like a disease usually treated with penicillin.
“He’s no worse than most of the lawyers I’ve worked for.”
“It hurts me to hear you say that.”
I have to admit it gave me a twinge, too, defending him.
“Will you forgive me if I buy lunch?” I asked.
“I’ll buy lunch,” Cynthia replied. “I don’t want to be eating on that … gentleman’s money.” She opened her office door and announced, “Taylor and I are going to lunch.”
“You’re lunching with Judge Kennelly,” Miss Efficiency corrected her.
“I am?”
“Twelve-thirty at Gallivan’s. You need to leave in ten minutes.”
Cynthia closed the door again. “Sorry,” she said.
“It’s okay,” I told her. “Actually, I came over to invite you to the Twins game tonight. They’re playing the hated Cleveland Indians.”
“I have a meeting tonight.”
“Who with?”
“My ETOS Club.”
“ETOS?”
“It’s a club several women and I started in law school. Once a month we get together and discuss the various sides of social issues. Exploring the Other Side, get it?”
“Yeah, I do. What kind of social issues?”
“Tonight we’re discussing why men embrace sports so dearly.”
“That’s a social issue?”
“Why do men like sports? Give me an argument,” Cynthia said.
“It’s a better excuse for getting together than forming a lame club.”
“I’m serious.”
“So am I. Where are you holding this meeting?”
“Don’t get angry.”
“Why would I get angry?”
“One of the members arranged for a private suite at the Metrodome, along the third-base line.”
“You’re watching the ball game? From a private suite? With booze and food and instant replay on TV monitors?”
She grinned. “Want me to bring you a souvenir?”
three
The snow had killed them. Twenty-three inches of it. It had kept the heads of witnesses low and their eyes down. It had clouded windshields, giving drivers a colorless, out-of-focus view of the world. It had buried footprints and tire treads and any hope of deploying dogs. One investigator had suggested that Alison Donnerbauer Emerton could be facedown in her own backyard, and they wouldn’t have known it until spring. But when spring finally came, Alison was not in her backyard. She wasn’t in the grove behind her house. She wasn’t in the fields bordering the street that lead to the cul-de-sac. She wasn’t anywhere that the Dakota County Sheriff’s Department could think to look.
All this was duly noted in Anne Scalasi’s file. Hunter Truman was right; there wasn’t much there. But the sheriff had obviously held back information from Truman—and the news media. As Edmond Locard, the great criminologist once said, “Every contact leaves a trace. The criminal must, of necessity, leave behind something at the scene of the crime.” And this time what the criminal had left behind was a single surface footprint on the flat rubber mat just inside Alison’s front door.
Anne’s file contained a four-by-five photograph of the print. Forensics identified it as the design of an LA Gear Air System running shoe, left foot, size ten, men’s. No wear could be detected on the tread, leading the detectives to conclude that it was new or little used. There was no depth to the impression and no second print, so the height and weight of the suspect couldn’t be determined. However, Raymond Fleck wore size ten, and while no running shoes could be found among his possessions, that fact had excited the detectives to no end.
One piece of evidence that had been released to the news media was the small amount of blood discovered on the carpet just inside Alison’s front door and the few drops found on the doorframe. Citing the shape of the drops and the laws of flow dynamics, forensics concluded that the victim was standing just inside the door when she was struck hard enough to cause instantaneous bleeding and that the force of the blow splashed the frame and carpet. The blood was Type A Positive. Same as Alison’s. And it had been there less than twenty-four hours. It supported Anne’s theory about a shove in. Other than that …
Officers had searched every room in the house three times, using spirals and zones and strip patterns, and came up empty. No hair samples that did not belong to Alison or her husband. No fibers that weren’t accounted for. No unexplained dirt or stains. There were plenty of unidentified fingerprints, but most were in high-traffic areas where you would expect them: the kitchen, the living room. There were none on the door or the doorframe. And none that matched Raymond Fleck’s.