She spied Joann and Martin heading down the path toward their cottage. They would soon pass by her. She hurried back inside, not wanting to talk to them.
Getting ready for bed, she realized that, in the morning, someone was going to have to tell Jerry about Kathleen’s disappearance. She went to sleep hoping that somebody didn’t have to be her.
Jed’s long nap combined with a good night’s sleep had him up at dawn.
“Sue. Hon. I’m going to go see Jerry. I’ll tell him about Kathleen and… and I guess I’ll take it from there.”
Susan, drowsy with sleep, muttered agreement, punched her pillow, and rolled over to find a cool spot on the mattress.
She woke up an hour later and stared at the ceiling. She was alone. Her friends were in terrible trouble. Not knowing what to do, she decided to head over to the restaurant. Food didn’t sound terribly appealing, but a cup of coffee might be a big help.
She found a seat by the wall and, her back to the still empty restaurant, stared out at the sea. A young woman approached almost immediately, and Susan looked up, expecting a menu. She was handed a folded sheet of notepaper. “Your husband called. He said to give you this. I’ll find your waiter.” Susan grabbed the paper and opened it anxiously.
“I’m with Jerry. I told him about Kathleen, and while he looked a little worried, he didn’t seem unduly upset. I’m going to see his lawyer. Maybe we can do something here. You stay there and relax.”
Susan frowned. Just like a man. Jerry “didn’t seem unduly upset.” What did that mean? And how could she stay here and “relax”? Relax? Surely Jed knew she couldn’t relax while all this was going on!
On the other hand, Jed knew his message would be read by others, possibly the murderer. What, really, could he say? Susan boiled the note down to facts: Jed was going to stay in town. She should stay here. “Coffee. A full pot, please,” she ordered from a nearby waiter, busy setting the tables.
He dashed off and returned immediately, pot in hand. Susan sipped from the cup and felt her spirits rise. Jed must be planning to do something in town. He didn’t need her help. Now she had to decide where her efforts could best be used here.
She considered the various possibilities. The thing to do, she decided, was spend as much time as possible with the people who had known Allison here before she was murdered. There must be a connection between at least one other guest and Allison-and that person must have killed her.
“Would you like to order breakfast now?”
“Ah… yes. I’ll have the crab and avocado omelet and some fresh fruit.”
“Of course, Mrs. Henshaw. Shouldn’t take any time at all.”
Susan smiled and looked back at the water. She’d see who showed up next for breakfast. If logic and orderly investigation couldn’t solve this murder, she would just have to depend on serendipity.
As luck would have it, the next guest to arrive was looking for her.
“Susan Henshaw! You’re just the person to take my husband’s place this morning.”
“Doing what?” Susan asked, turning and looking up at Ro Parker.
“We’re taking the kayaks out to see the eastern beaches. They’re almost entirely deserted and well worth the trip. And, I don’t know about you, but I could stand to burn some calories.” Ro pulled up a chair, sat down, and lowered her voice. “We heard about your friend vanishing. I just want you to know that I, at least, don’t believe her vanishing act means she-or her nice husband-really did kill Allison. I just wanted you to know.” She put her hand on Susan’s arm and gave it what she probably thought was a friendly squeeze.
Susan knew anger would get her nowhere. “Thanks.” She leaned closer to Ro. “What are people saying about Kathleen?”
“Oh, dear. Well, I know she’s your friend, but I must say her stunt yesterday didn’t win her many friends here.”
“What do you mean?”
“Well, pulling a vanishing act makes her look very guilty.”
“But she was abducted. Her room was searched!”
“I know it looks like that. And I suppose it’s just possible. But, if you want to know what people think…”
“I do.”
“They think she’s taken off to try to deflect suspicion from her husband.”
“But her cottage-”
“She trashed it before she left. I don’t believe it, but you said you wanted to know what people were saying.”
“I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised. No one here really got to know Kathleen or Jerry before all this happened. There’s no reason to believe in their innocence.”
“And everyone knew Allison. She was quite gregarious and so charming. She fit right in with all the various little groups here.
“Oh, there’s my husband. Do tell me you’ll come out with us. He’ll be so relieved not to have to go.”
“What time? And how long will we be gone?”
“We’re leaving around ten and we’ll be back before one-for a late lunch. Now tell me you’ll come.”
Susan made up her mind quickly. “I will.”
“Fabulous. We’re meeting on the beach. James is going to fit us all out with life vests and such.”
“I’ll be there.” The timing sounded just about perfect. That would give her a few hours to think about what Ro had just said. Susan would never have described Allison as gregarious. When she had visited her sister in Hancock, she had refused to socialize without Jerry or June by her side. In fact, Susan herself had tried a little matchmaking and been discouraged. Convinced Allison was just shy, she had given up. But this new Allison, thin and gorgeous, had also, apparently, had a personality transplant. She had jumped into the social waters of Compass Bay with enthusiasm.
It was time for Susan to do the same.
At least she had an opening line.
By the time Susan met the bridge foursome on the beach, she had spoken to the other three couples who had spent time with Allison.
Abandoning any pretense that she was doing anything other than investigating a murder, she used the same approach each time. “I’m trying to find out what happened to Kathleen. When was the last time you saw her?” she started by asking Joann and Martin.
Martin looked up from his bowl of oatmeal with a startled expression on his face. “Sorry? We thought everyone knew what had happened to her. She left the resort, didn’t she? Ran out on her husband.”
“Martin! We know nothing of the kind!” Joann spoke sharply. Susan noticed she was eating the macadamia nut pancakes with coconut syrup with a side order of pork bangers. In terms of calories and cholesterol, their two breakfasts were complete opposites. “I’m sorry, Mrs. Henshaw… Susan. My husband sometimes lacks tact. Of course, we are all shocked and concerned about the disappearance of your friend. I myself believe she was driven insane by the shock of learning that her husband is a murderer and she has done herself some dreadful harm. We’re on an island. Such an easy place to disappear.”
Susan reminded herself that she was investigating and that defending her friends wasn’t going to get her anywhere or help her learn anything new. “I can’t image Kathleen doing anything like that. She’s upset that her husband was wrongly accused of murder, but Kathleen was a police officer in New York City before her marriage. I don’t think there’s a whole lot that shocks her or could send her over the edge.”
“A police officer,” Martin said. “Amazing. She’s so sensational looking. Who would have guessed.”
Joann looked at her husband with such anger that Susan thought for a moment that she was going to strike him. “Good-looking women, Martin-if you call that anorexic scrawniness good-looking-are used as decoys. She probably spent her time on the police force dressed up as a hooker trying to attract johns.”