‘She didn’t tell him she was pregnant until it was too late for that, so Martin did the “honourable” thing without even telling his parents. She may not have gone to university but our Lorraine is no mug. She’s far cleverer than him, that’s for sure. He’s been her meal ticket for life.’
‘He can’t be that much of a mug if he’s the managing director of Reynard Shipping,’ I said.
‘Uncle Richard has all the brains in the family. While Martin may be called the managing director, it’s Uncle Richard who really manages everything. He makes all the decisions. He worries, rightly, what will happen to the firm after he’s gone. That’s why we’ve sold the Hong Kong end of the business. I think Uncle Richard is afraid that Martin will lose it all.’
How sad, I thought. Richard Reynard had two sons, one an artist who lived in the Scottish Highlands and had no interest in business, while the other was not quite up to running the family firm.
‘Would you say Martin and Theresa have a happy marriage?’ I asked.
‘What is this?’ she said sharply. ‘The Spanish Inquisition? You asked me that before. Do you know something I don’t?’
‘No,’ I lied. ‘I just wondered. Theresa seems to be quite keen on Bentley.’
‘I can’t think why. He’s a horrid little man.’
‘Doesn’t he have any family of his own to spend Christmas with?’
‘I know that he has parents,’ she said. ‘I’ve met them. But perhaps they’ve disowned him. This isn’t the first time he’s spent Christmas with us.’
‘If no one likes him, why is he still employed by your company?’
She sighed. ‘It’s only me who can’t stand him. That’s because he and I have history.’ She paused and I waited while she worked out in her mind if she was going to tell me about the history. She obviously decided not to. ‘Uncle Richard almost worships the ground he walks on and, I have to admit, he’s very good at his job, and fiercely loyal to the firm.’
‘Do Bentley and Martin get on?’
‘Not really. Martin hates the fact that Uncle Richard talks to Bentley about business strategy more than to him. I know I shouldn’t say this but, at times, I think that Uncle Richard wishes that Bentley was his son rather than Martin.’
It was quite a statement.
‘How about you?’ I asked. ‘Do you get on all right with Martin?’
‘Yes, I’d say so,’ she said. ‘Sometimes I feel a bit sorry for him. It’s not really his fault that he’s not quite up to the job. He tries his best. But God knows what will happen to us when Uncle Richard finally retires. Or dies.’
‘How about the other directors? The two from the law firm?’
‘They don’t seem to have much to do with the day-to-day running of things. Their job is more to do with ensuring that we, as a board, comply with all the local regulations.’
‘You could always bring in more directors,’ I said. ‘Bentley, for example.’
Henri pulled a face. ‘Martin won’t allow that. He’s totally adamant. I think he feels threatened, and for good reason. I suppose we will have to have more directors at some point, but Uncle Richard is keen to keep control in the family for the time being, especially while we are selling off some of the company’s assets.’
I couldn’t argue with that.
‘Now, what would you like to do today?’ Henri asked.
‘What is there?’
‘We could go to Stingray City.’
Henri arranged to charter a boat to take us but we wouldn’t be going until later in the day, when the cruise-ship passengers had all departed.
‘It would be a nightmare earlier,’ Henri said. ‘Far too many people.’
From the beach in front of the apartment, we could see five huge cruise liners at anchor off George Town, each of them disgorging thousands of passengers onto the island for the day, all of them searching for something to keep them busy.
So we spent much of the day lying on sunbeds in the shadow of a beach cabana while I tried to work out what I should do.
I wondered if I should tell Henri of my suspicions.
The last thing I wanted to do was to ruin our budding affair by further accusing her cousin of trying to kill me. It had caused enough trouble when I’d suggested he’d purposely given me a contaminated dive tank. To now accuse him of also sending the men with the carving knife to stab me to death would probably be terminal for our relationship.
Perhaps I could tell her only that I believed Martin had inadvertently become tax resident in the UK. But she would likely say, So what? Why are you telling me? and all the other stuff would all come out.
But I felt I had to tell someone.
It would surely be safer for me if someone else knew.
But who?
Bentley, the lawyer, must already know. Otherwise, why would he have been so outspoken on the Newbury balcony?
What had he said at the time?
I know, and that in itself is bad enough.
If the company lawyer knew then, surely, in due course, Martin would have to file a UK tax return. Unless Bentley was planning to turn a blind eye.
Henri went down to the sea for a cooling swim while I went back inside the apartment to call Quentin. I needed some legal advice and he was my go-to lawyer of choice.
‘I’m not sure what to do,’ I said to him. ‘I don’t know the law.’
I explained the gist of my problems.
‘With reference to the tax position, no crime appears to have been committed as yet, so you are under no obligation to report anything to the authorities,’ he said. ‘That would only change later if you had firm evidence to the effect that a tax return and payment had not been submitted when due, hence a fraud had been committed.’
‘So what would you do now?’ I asked.
‘Say nothing and get out of there as soon as possible. I’d write formally to Reynard Shipping at their registered address explaining that you believe that Martin Reynard may be UK tax resident for the current tax year. You should copy the letter to their accountants, if you know who they are. You would then be fully covered from a legal point of view.’
It all sounded so logical.
‘But I would also contact the UK police,’ Quentin went on, ‘to inform them of your suspicions regarding the attacks on you, and then leave them to deal with it.’
Maybe saying nothing and leaving as soon as possible were the sensible things to do, but did I really want to prematurely end my time in Cayman with Henri?
This was the first holiday I’d had for years.
But I decided that I should take my brother-in-law’s advice. He hadn’t become a top QC by getting much wrong.
I logged on to the internet and looked up commercial flights back to London. There was a direct service the following evening.
I would stay until then.
I made a reservation online.
Meanwhile, I would say nothing to any of the Reynard gathering and, when I was safely home, I would write the letters as Quentin had suggested.
And, to ensure my well-being, I would make certain that I was never left alone with Martin Reynard. In fact, I would spend every moment of my remaining time on Grand Cayman in the company of one Henrietta Shawcross.
Little did I realize that it would not be enough.
35
Henri went on working on her tan for the rest of the morning while I sat in the shade complaining that it was far too hot in the midday sun even for mad dogs and Englishmen.
‘Would you like a cold drink?’ I asked, standing up.
‘Yes, please.’
‘Water or wine?’
‘Both,’ she said. ‘Together. I’ll have a spritzer. With some ice, please.’