Frost turned pale. "Of course not. Ragnar forbids all alcohol."
Shay said, "What happened to Burke? He could have managed an outbreak of disease. He wouldn't have let the foundries shut down."
Stonewall crossed his arms. "Burke also wouldn't share his knowledge freely with his fellow men. His pride prevented him from telling Ragnar all his secrets. In his disbelief, he lacked a moral compass to guide him to the greater good. In the end, he killed a dozen men as he fled the city. He destroyed the southern gate, exposing us to the risk of attack; we've set up a barrier, but it's impossible to describe the harm Burke has done to our cause."
Shay clenched his fists. He wanted to scream at the stupidity of Stonewall's words, but fought to keep his cool. "Don't talk to me about sharing knowledge. I came here with books filled with information and ideas that could have helped launch a new human age. Ragnar took those books and flung them into the fire. Ragnar gave Burke every reason to be cautious about sharing what he knew."
Stonewall said, "Ragnar threw only one book into the fire. He had me gather up the rest. I still have them. He forgot about them five minutes after we left the loft. The prophet has many things on his mind."
"You have the books?"
"I'm a voracious reader. I was curious as to their contents," said Stonewall. "The Drifting Isles are remote and lonely. Books are highly valued there."
Shay was confused. It must have shown in his face, because Stonewall said, "You seem to think that because I'm a man of faith, I'm also a man of ignorance. It's a prejudice that Burke shared, I'm afraid."
"According to Chapelion, faith is the opposite of knowledge," said Shay. "It's difficult, I admit, to think that you can be well-read and still believe that Ragnar speaks directly with God."
Frost let loose a low growl as his fingers fondled the butt of his gun. "You're getting mighty close to blasphemy, boy."
Stonewall's eyes twinkled. He didn't look offended by Shay's argument. "You aren't so different from me, Shay. You place your faith in books. You've read things written long ago and believe them, even though these events unfolded centuries before your birth, and there's no direct evidence that they actually occurred. How am I any different? I've read a book that taught me that God chooses men from time to time as his prophets, to guide his people through periods of darkness. Ragnar is one of these men."
Shay started to speak, but held his tongue. He was getting sidetracked from his main mission. Stonewall evidently mistook his pause as an invitation for further explanation. "Some force spared Ragnar when dragons slew his family. Some force gave him the gift of persuasion that has allowed a man so young to gather so many followers. Some force placed Ragnar at the Free City, where he helped defeat Albekizan and Kanst and Blasphet. This same guiding force led Ragnar to gather the refugees into an army and seize control of this fortress. You weren't here to see him fight. With no armor, Ragnar plunges into the thick of battle and emerges with nothing but scratches. If you cannot accept this as evidence that he's God's chosen, then no evidence in the world will ever lead you to the truth."
"He could also just be lucky," said Shay. "I should have been killed a half dozen times in recent days. I'm alive more due to chance than to my own efforts. But I don't regard a little luck as evidence that I'm one of God's chosen. I've also had my share of misfortune." He felt a cold, hard spot in his belly as he thought of Jandra.
"One of the books you brought spoke of an invisible hand that guides the economies of mankind," said Stonewall. "I believe in an invisible hand that guides all men in all actions. Even you, Shay."
Shay grimaced. He hadn't come here to debate philosophy. "We're wasting time," he said. "I have to find Bitterwood, before the goddess finds him."
"The goddess is only a false idol, Shay," said Stonewall.
"This false idol almost killed me and she's currently possessing Jandra, whose life means a great deal to me. I can't stay here until Ragnar finishes talking to his invisible hand. I have a secret that can help you break the blockade."
"Let's hear it."
"When we were in the kingdom of the goddess we found wings that let a man fly. I gave them to… to a friend to carry. I have six pairs, not counting my own. With them, you can outfly dragons. It's how I got here. You could fly over the blockade in the dead of night, since I have a device for seeing in darkness as well."
"Only witches see in the dark," grumbled Frost. "I think Jandra's enspelled you, boy."
"Jandra's not a witch," said Shay.
"I know a witch when I see one." Frost spat to punctuate his sentence.
"Shouldn't you go somewhere to sleep off your goom?" asked Shay, finding Frost's presence tiring.
While Frost looked hostile, Stonewall looked concerned. "Are you claiming to have flown? With wings? Shapeshifting is a sign of witchcraft."
"I'm not shapeshifting," said Shay. "They're a machine."
With a thought, he willed his wings to unfold. They unfurled, glinting silver in the sun, tinkling like a thousand tiny bells.
He smiled, expecting this to provide convincing proof for his argument.
Instantly, he realized the error of this assumption.
Frost yanked the short shotgun from his belt and held it inches from Shay's face. The blacksmith's bloodshot eyes narrowed as he squeezed the trigger. Shay flinched.
Nothing happened.
Biscuit leapt forward, tearing the gun from Frost's fingers. He said, in a voice trembling with pent up anger, "A sober man wouldn't have forgotten the safety."
Frost looked at Biscuit, his mouth hanging slack, staring down the barrel of his own gun. Biscuit's thumb flicked the safety.
Shay turned his face away as Biscuit pulled the trigger. In the flash and bang that followed, he almost didn't see Stonewall leaping from the brick steps, drawing his sword.
With a thought, Shay launched thirty feet into the air in the half second it took Stonewall to land where he'd just stood.
Frost dropped to his knees. Half his head was missing. His body slumped forward, landing against Biscuit's trousers. Biscuit snarled, "An eye for an eye you bastard!"
Stonewall was staring up at Shay. Shay hesitated. Was it too late for reason? Five seconds ago, they'd been talking civilly. How had events turned so sour so quickly?
There was a clang at his back as something bounced from the broad circle from which his wings unfolded. He spun, and an arrow suddenly jutted from the bag over his shoulder that held Jandra's coat. A third arrow whizzed past his head, close enough he could feel the wind that trailed it.
It appeared the debate was over.
Shay turned his face skyward, then zoomed toward the blue above, swifter than arrows.
Biscuit's one good eye was full of hate as it glared at Stonewall. The man's hands were trembling as he rammed the bag of shot he'd snatched from Frost's belt into the barrel.
"Put the gun down," said Stonewall.
"You might not have been with them," Biscuit said. "But I know your hand was on the knife just as sure as Frost's."
"I've never tortured any man," said Stonewall. "Had I known what Frost was capable of, I wouldn't have told him my suspicions that you were Burke's confidante. Put the gun down."
"Not until I put down you and Ragnar and the rest of the monsters!"
Never once as Stonewall looked down the barrel of the gun did he fear death. Faith, however, wasn't the reason for his confidence. Shay had escaped so swiftly he'd been difficult for the eye to follow. Biscuit was a stationary target.
The first arrow struck him in the shoulder of the arm that held the gun. As the gun fell to the dirt, two more arrows struck Biscuit in the back, and another jutted from his neck. By the time he hit the ground, he looked like a pin-cushion.
Stonewall shook his head, saddened by the loss of two fine blacksmiths. He was sad, as well, that Shay was gone. He'd enjoyed their discussion. Since leaving the Drifting Isles, he'd found precious little in the way of informed debate. Still, Shay's wings were difficult to ignore. What spell had Jandra cast on him? Or could it be true? Were the wings simply machines?