Dave had a very sincere, unhumorous smile, and shook hands strongly. “I’ve been looking forward to meeting you. Somebody out of the past. Somebody who knew the real world.”
Julian didn’t quite get that. He said, “Nice to meet you. What’s the most fascinating job in the country?”
“Sit down. Sit down, everybody,” said Sean. When they were seated, he explained, “Possibly not for Dave. It’s probably just tedious routine for him, but he’s in charge of the Radio Astronomy Observatory on Luna.”
Julian shook his head. “What’s radio astronomy? Astronomy is a field on which I was completely blank even in the 1960s. You can imagine to what extent I’m ignorant now, after a third of a century of progress. Did you say Luna? You mean there’s an observatory on the moon?”
Dave Woolman nodded. “It was decided as far back as 1960 that the radio telescope, rather than the spaceship, would probably be the first instrument to establish contact with intelligent life beyond the solar system. Since your time, we have receivers of such sensitivity and antennas of such enormous size, that we are optimistic about sending and picking up radio signals from the nearer stars. The search for these signals began in 1960 at the National Radio Astronomy Observatory in Greenbank, West Virginia. The Luna Observatory is a great advantage. It’s located on the far side, and hence cut off from a great deal of the local radio interference that an earth-bound observatory suffers.”
“I’m impressed,” Julian said. “Have you been able to pick up any messages from other worlds?”
A strange silence fell over the whole group.
Woolman said finally, “I am afraid I’m not in a position to answer that.”
The elderly Bert Melville changed the subject. He had been looking at Julian intently, and now he turned to Harrison and said, “You know, Jule and I used to belong to a consorium based in New York, the Bahamas, and Switzerland. We used to swing some pretty big deals.” His laugh quavered a bit. “Those were the days, eh, Jule? Remember the time we squeezed out Bob Percy and took over Diversified?”
“Yes. Yes, I remember that operation. Bob shot himself afterwards.”
“I’d forgotten about that part of it,” Melville said.
Harrison seemed slightly impatient. He said to Julian, “Did you think over what we were discussing the other day—in short, Utopias?”
“Yes, yes I did. Frankly, I didn’t come up with much in the way of a conclusion.”
Harrison nodded. “I was just giving you some preliminaries to work on, Mr. West. Are you acquainted with the work of a contemporary of yours, the British writer Arthur C. Clarke?”
Julian frowned a little. “It seems to me that the Leetes have mentioned him a couple of times, as a popularizer of science.”
“Yes.” Harrison got to his feet and went over to the library booster, which sat on the desk. He dialed as he said over his shoulder, “This is from one of his books. Astonishingly prophetic. I’ll read you just this one passage.
“’Civilization cannot exist without new frontiers; it needs them both physically and spiritually. The physical need is obvious—new lands, new resources, new materials. The spiritual need is less apparent, but in the long run it is more important. We do not live by bread alone; we need adventure, variety, novelty, romance. As the psychologists have shown by their sensory deprivation experiments, a man goes swiftly mad if he is isolated in a silent, darkened room, cut off completely from the external world. What is true of individuals is also true of societies; they too can become insane without sufficient stimulus.’”
Harrison deactivated the screen and turned back to Julian. “What’s your reaction to that?”
“I don’t know.” Julian shifted in his chair. “It makes a lot of sense.”
The seventy-three-year-old Bert Melville leaned forward impatiently. “Jule, the damn country is turning to mush. Ninety-eight percent do nothing but putter around with their hobbies: they paint paintings nobody wants to look at; they write books nobody reads; they move into mobile towns and travel around the country doing nothing but trying to enjoy themselves.”
Harrison took it up with his usual energy. “Ethically, the country is going to pot. Institutions that have come down to us through the ages are being completely eroded. Look at sex. All the young people now behave like rabbits. They start educating them on how to screw in God only knows how many different positions as soon as they’re into their teens. The family is disappearing, and the population is beginning to decrease. Whatever happened to religious training? The churches are empty except for old folks—those churches that remain at all.”
The usually taciturn Ley put in his word. “It’s like Mr. Melville said. ‘The country’s turning to mush.’ They don’t even have boxing any more. ‘Somebody might get hurt.’ Hell, when I was a kid Joe Louis was still alive. Fought his way up out of the slums, thrilled millions, and made millions. What’s wrong with that? Give the kids a desire to make something of themselves, to fight their way up. I read about this Manolete, the bullfighter in Spain. Another slum kid, but with guts. Became the best bullfighter of all time. Made tons of bucks thrilling people, taking his chances. Inspired other poor Spanish kids to make their play for the big time. How about car racing? I was at Indianapolis one year, at the Old Brickyard. Talk about thrills. The crowd was on its feet half the time, yelling themselves crazy. Those guys that drove those cars had guts, and they inspired younger people to get in there and fight.”
“All the old virtues are topsy-turvy,” Sean muttered. “For instance, anybody at all can dial as much pornography as he wants from the International Data Banks. You should see some of it. A six-year-old kid can look at it if he wants.”
Julian was looking thoughtful. “I’ve argued some of this with Academician Leete and his family. What he points out is that with this new system of the International Data Banks, it’s the best people, those with the highest Aptitude Quotient, who wind up running the country. The rest aren’t needed.”
“Ah?” Harrison said triumphantly. “Who says they’re the best? A bunch of machines! There are some things, Mr. West, a machine can’t measure.”
“The whole idea rather turned me off at the beginning,” Julian admitted. “But Academician Leete has some strong arguments and I don’t have much material to base my disagreements on. Whom can’t the computers measure?”
Harrison, in his enthusiasm, was on his feet. “Whom can’t they measure? The men who count most. The men who have counted most down through the centuries. Men with the dream, with the urge for power, with ruthless ambition, men of aggression, of charisma. The men whose ambition is such that the whole world is pushed forward as a result of their efforts.”
“Such as whom?” Julian said, his voice skeptical.
Harrison nodded at the validity of the question. “Do you know that Alexander the Great was the despair of his tutors, that Winston Churchill was a third-rater in school, that Ulysses S. Grant graduated twenty-first in a class of thirty-nine at West Point? Hitler was a high school dropout and failed his entrance examination to the art academy. Charlemagne couldn’t read or write. Caesar wrote Latin inadequately, much to the embarrassment of Latin teachers to this day. Lord Nelson received only a summary education and at the age of twelve went to sea as a midshipman. Lincoln had less than a year’s schooling. Washington had little formal learning; his biographer says, ‘His chief education was received from practical men and outdoor occupations, not from books.’ Thomas Edison had exactly three months of education and at the age of twelve became a newsboy on the railroads. Dickens had a vocabulary of twenty-five hundred words, and Shakespeare was spurned by most of the literati of his day because he never went to university.