“I’m sure your father will be thrilled to see you,” Dantzler said.
“I don’t know about that.”
Dantzler leaned forward. “I need the truth, Tommy. All of it.”
“Truth? About what?”
“About what happened in nineteen eighty-two.”
“What makes you think I know anything about what happened?”
“Come on, Tommy. You’ve had to keep dark secrets bottled up inside you for too long now. It’s time to let go of those secrets and come clean about what happened. About everything.”
“I don’t know what you’re insinuating, Detective Dantzler. Or why you think I have the answers.”
“Because of the way you changed, the drinking, your self-imposed estrangement from your father. None of it happened by accident or without a good reason. Something catastrophic triggered it. Also, when we first met, you said something very interesting. You said, ‘my father is innocent, Detective Dantzler. That much you can be sure of.’ Now-”
“I’m sure Rachel said the same thing,”
“Yes, she did. But for her, it was more hope than anything. Not with you. When you said those words to me, you were stating a hard, cold fact.”
Tommy set his cup down, leaned back, and washed his face with his hands. After almost a minute of silence, he finally said, “I can’t tell you what I know. And I wish you would go away and leave me and my family alone. If you persist in this quest, people are going to get hurt.”
“Johnny Richards is dead,” Dantzler said. “His body was found in the trunk of his car about an hour ago. He’s no longer a threat to you or your family.”
Tommy nodded but remained silent.
“I suspect Richards killed those two kids in ’eighty-two,” Dantzler continued. “But I can’t know for sure unless you tell me what happened. You have to fill in the missing pieces.”
“If I do, if I tell you everything, no one in my family will ever speak to me again.” Tears dripped from Tommy’s eyes. “And they would have every right to hate me. For the pain and suffering I caused them.”
“I don’t think so. In fact, I’d say you’ve got it all wrong.”
“How could they forgive me when I can’t forgive myself?”
“The truth, Tommy. How was Richards able to orchestrate all of this?”
Tommy took a drink from the cup and put it down. “I had been shooting some hoops at the YMCA gym. I was in the locker room getting dressed when I heard these two guys talking. We were the only three people in there at the time. I could see them in a mirror, but they couldn’t see me. Anyway, one of the men, not Richards, started telling Richards that if he didn’t cooperate and testify, he could get into a lot of trouble. The man said to Richards, ‘How many men have you killed? Thirty? Forty? Well, we’re willing to look the other way if you’ll testify against the Gambino family. This offer comes from high up.’ Richards laughed and said something like, ‘You can take your offer back to where it came from and tell your boss I said no deal. Never.’ It was obvious Richards wasn’t at all afraid of the other man.”
“Did you by any chance get the second man’s name?”
“No.”
“Ever see him again?”
“No.”
“Okay, what happened next?”
“The other man takes off, leaving only me and Richards in the locker room. I’m more than a little nervous after hearing all the stuff about him killing forty people, so I want to get out of there pronto. But as I started for the door, I accidently dropped my basketball. I grabbed the ball and made a beeline for the door when I hear Richards saying, ‘Come here, kid. Now!’ I froze like a statue. I wanted to run but couldn’t move at all. It’s pretty scary seeing a man who has killed forty people coming toward you.”
“What did Richards do?”
“Nothing. He asked me what I heard. Naturally, I told him I didn’t hear anything. Then he asked me what my name was and where I lived. I told him. After I gave him the information, he patted me on the shoulder and told me to get lost.”
“Do you think he believed you when you told him you didn’t hear anything?” Dantzler asked.
“At the time I wasn’t sure. Nor did I care. I only wanted out of the locker room. But given what subsequently happened, he obviously didn’t believe me. Or maybe he simply wasn’t willing to take a chance either way.”
“What did happen next?”
“A couple of days later, I’m walking home after baseball practice and this car pulls up next to me. It’s Richards. He orders me into the car, says we need to talk about a few things. I get in, thinking we’ll talk right there in front of the baseball field, where I felt fairly safe. But he takes off. Now I’m scared shitless, thinking maybe I’m gonna be victim forty-one. We drive down to the University of Kentucky campus, to the football stadium, where he parks in a vacant lot. Then he tells me he’s been doing a lot of research, and that he knows everything about me and my family. I listen, don’t say a word, still unsure if I’m going to live or die. Next, he wanted to know if my father owned any weapons. I told him Eli had a Winchester rifle and a twenty-two pistol. He asked if Eli had used the twenty-two recently. I told him I thought he had. He then told me to get the twenty-two, and to make sure to not touch the handle when I picked it up. He said I had until the next day to get the gun and give it to him. He also said if I didn’t get the gun, or if I told anyone about this meeting, bodies would fall. After that, he took me back to the practice field.”
“So you got the gun out of the safe,” Dantzler said. “Did you meet Richards the next day?”
“Yes. Behind Turfland Mall.”
“What did Richards tell you?”
“He told me that no matter what happened in the next few days I had better keep my mouth shut. He said only two people in the world know about any of this, and if I uttered a single word implicating him he would methodically murder every member of my family, beginning with little Rachel. He added that they would suffer in such a horrible way that they would plead with him to finish them off. I had no choice but to believe him and to do what he said.”
Tommy’s eyes glazed over with tears. He hung his head, saying nothing for more than a minute. When he finally lifted his head tears streamed down his cheeks.
“Three days later, two boys were dead and my father had been arrested for murder. And I could only watch, couldn’t speak up, even though I knew the truth. I was afraid, a coward. All these years… how could my family not hate me for what I allowed to happen?”
“You were a terrified kid trapped in an impossible situation.” Dantzler said, putting a hand on Tommy’s shoulder. “And believe me, Tommy. Johnny Richards would have done exactly what he said he would do had you pointed a finger at him. He was a ruthless killer.”
“Still… I should’ve handled it differently.”
“I don’t know what more you could have done.”
“Something… anything.”
“Do you think Eli knew it was you who took the pistol?”
“No.”
“Well, he had to know something,” Dantzler said. “There had to be a reason why he took the fall for a crime he didn’t commit.”
“Colt Rogers met with my father the day after he was arrested. He’s the one who passed along the threats Richards made against my family. Eli had to silently swallow the medicine or risk the chance everyone in his family would suffer and die.”
Dantzler stood. “Thank you for telling me this, Tommy. I know it was painful, and I know this situation has caused you more agony than I can imagine, but you’ve helped me solve the puzzle.”
“Am I in any kind of trouble?”
“Why would you be in trouble? You didn’t break any laws. The way I see it, you’re the hero in all this.”
“Heroes aren’t cowards.”