She had almost resolved on this course of action when the key turned in the lock and the door opened and there stood Quill, his face warm and smiling, filled with love. To her it looked like hate, and now she could see what somehow had eluded her before: Quill wanted her to die.
How could she have missed it? It was her knack, to see what people intended, what they were about to do. Yet she saw no further than his smile the first time they met, saw nothing but his genuine love and sympathy and concern for her. How could her knack have failed her?
Was it what Quill had said to her, in one of his many rambling discourses on Satan? That Satan was not loyal and did not uphold his disciples?
Why, then, would she see the truth now?
Or was it the truth? Was Satan now deceiving her into thinking she saw hatred where love truly existed?
There was no way out of this circle of doubt. There was no firm ground to hold to. Alvin Smith, who admitted to witchery, was kind and forgiving to her though she did him great harm. Quill, who was the servant of God in opposing witchery, twisted every word she said to make her bear false witness against Smith and his friends. And now he seemed to want her to hang. That was how it seemed. Could the truth be so simple? Was it possible that things were exactly as they seemed?
“I know what you're thinking,” said Quill softly.
“Do you?” she murmured.
“You're thinking that you want to recant your testimony against Alvin Smith and make the whole trial go away. I know you're thinking that because everybody does, just before the trial.”
She said nothing. For she could sense the malice coming from him like stink from an untended baby.
“It wouldn't go away,” said Quill. “I already have your testimony under oath. All that would happen is that perjury would be added to your crimes. And worse– having repented, you would be seen to have returned to Satan, trying to conceal his acts. Indeed, you already seemed to be concealing the other witches in Cambridge. You could not have expected to protect your friends and incriminate only the strangers, could you? Were you that naive? Were you so caught up in the snares and nets of Satan that you believed you could hide from God?”
“I've hidden nothing.” Even as she said it, she knew the futility of denial.
“I have here a list of the professors and lecturers at Cambridge who are known to create an atmosphere of hostility toward faith and piety in their classrooms. You are not alone in denouncing them– my colleagues and I have compiled this list over a period of years. Emerson, for instance, scoffs at the very idea of the existence of witches and witchery. You like Emerson, don't you? I've heard that you were especially attentive in spying outside his classroom.”
“It wasn't spying, I was given the right to listen,” said Purity.
“You heard him,” said Quill. “But my question is, did you see him? At a witches' sabbath?”
“I never saw a witches' sabbath, so how could I have seen him at one?”
“Don't chop logic with me,” whispered Quill. “The syllogism is false because your testimony has been false. You told me about one witches' sabbath yourself.”
“I never did.”
“The debauchery,” he whispered. “The crimes against nature.”
She looked him boldly in the face, seeing his lust for her blood so strongly depicted in the fire of his face, the tension of his body that she would not have needed a knack to detect it. “You are the one who hates nature,” she said. “You are the enemy of God.”
“Feeble. I advise against your using that line in court. It will only make you look stupid and I answer it so easily.”
“You are the enemy of goodness and decency,” she said, speaking more boldly now, “and insofar as God is good, you hate God.”
“Insofar as? The professors have taught you well. I think your answer, despite your attempts to deceive, has to be 'yes' to the question of whether you saw Emerson at a witches' sabbath.”
“I say no such thing.”
“I say that by using professorial language in the midst of a satanic denunciation of my role in God's service, your true spirit, held a helpless prisoner by Satan, was trying to send me a coded message denouncing Emerson.”
“Who would believe such nonsense?”
“I'll say it in a way the court can understand,” said Quill. He checked off Emerson's name. “Emerson, yes. One of Satan's spies, caught. Now look at the other names.”
“Coded message,” she said contemptuously.
“What you don't understand is that your very sneer shows your contempt for holiness. You hate all things good and decent, and your scornfulness proves it.”
“Go away.”
“For now,” said Quill. “Your arraignment is this morning. The judge wants to hear you when Alvin Smith makes his plea.”
But she was not fooled. Her knack was too trustworthy for her to doubt what she saw now.
“You're such a bad liar, Quill,” she said. “The judge never needs to have a witness at the arraignment. I'll be there because I'm to be arraigned as well.”
Quill was face-to-face with her again at once. “Satan whispered that lie to you, didn't he.”
“Why would you say that?”
“I saw it,” he said. “I saw him whisper to you.”
“You're insane.”
“I saw you looking at me, and in a sudden moment you were told something that you hadn't known before. Satan whispered.”
Had he seen it? Was it his knack to see other knacks working?
No. It was his knack to find the useful lie hidden inside every useless truth. He had simply seen the transformation in her facial expression when she understood the truth about his intentions.
“Satan has never told me anything,” she said.
“But you already told me about your knack,” he answered with a smile. “Don't recant– it will go hard with you.”
“Maybe I have a talent for seeing other people's intentions,” she said defiantly. “That doesn't mean it comes from Satan!”
“Yes,” he said. “Use that line in court. Confess your sin and then deny that it's a sin. See what happens to you under the law.” He reached out and touched her hand, gently, caressingly. “God loves you, child. Don't reject him. Turn away from Satan. Admit all the evil you have done so you can prove you have left it behind you. Live to let your womb bear children, as God intended. It's Satan, not God, who wants you twitching at the end of a rope.”
“Yes,” she said. “That much is true. Satan your master wants me dead.”
He winked at her, got up, and went to the door. “That's good. Keep that up. That'll get you hanged.” And he was gone, the door locked behind him.
She shook with cold as if it weren't summer with the heat already oppressive this early in the morning. Everything was clear to her now. Quill came here ready to do exactly what he had done– take a simple accusation of the use of a knack, and turn it into a story about Satan and gross perversions. He knew he had to do this because honest people never told stories about Satan. He knew that she would not name others she saw at witches' sabbaths because there were never any such conclaves, and all such denunciations had to be extracted through whatever torture the law would allow. Witchers did what Quill did because if they did not do it, no one would ever be convicted of trafficking with Satan.
This was how her parents died. Not because they really did have knacks that came from Satan, but because they would not play along with the witchers and join them in persecuting others. They would not confess to falsehood. They died because the City of God tried so hard to be pure that it created its own impurity. The evil the witchers did was worse than any evil they might prevent. And yet the people of New England were so afraid that they might not live up to the ideals of Puritanism that they dared not speak against a law that purported to protect them from Satan.