"Couple killed in that home invasion end of July."
"That's right. Lia Parkman is Kristin's cousin, Susan Hollander's niece."
"Jesus," he said. "Now why the hell didn't anybody tell me that? The one roommate said something about she was depressed about a recent death in the family, but that wasn't just a death, it was a fucking bloodbath. But the perps are dead, aren't they? Murder and suicide out in Coney Island?"
" Coney Island Avenue," I said. "Which is actually in Midwood."
"Close enough. You're doing some work for the daughter, and I don't suppose you're putting a new roof on the house. You're doing what, investigating?"
"It's unofficial," I said. "But yes, I'm investigating."
"And offhand I can only think of one thing you could be investigating. Case is closed, right?"
"Yes."
"And the daughter thinks the whole story hasn't come out yet. Or you think that, or both. Which is it?"
"Both."
"And that's what put you on to the cousin? Help me out here. How does she fit in?"
I brought him up to speed, just hitting the high points- the front door key, the numeric code for the burglar alarm. "Lia Parkman had a key and she knew the keypad code," I said. "This afternoon I managed to sit down with her and ask her who might have borrowed the key or doped out the code. She said she couldn't think of anybody, but I knew she was holding something back."
"Sometimes you can tell."
"I could tell," I said, "but I couldn't do anything about it. Maybe I should have kept at her. I had to make a judgment call, and I decided I was better off letting her think about it. I gave her a card, told her to call me if she came up with anything."
"And she did."
"If I'd come straight home," I said, then broke it off. "But I didn't, and by the time I got here she'd called and left a message. I called her right back and got her voice mail."
"That's because her phone was turned off. When that happens the voice mail kicks in. You leave her a message?"
"No, what for? I figured I'd try her until I got her. And I did, a couple of times, with the same results. I didn't even know it was a cell phone, I figured it was the phone in her room and she was out."
"They rarely have actual phones in their rooms, the college kids. It's all cell phones. It's simpler, when you're moving all the time."
"Even if I'd left a message," I said, "she never would have received it. He must have already killed her by then."
"He must have been very fucking slick," he said. "Did I mention two of her three roommates were home when it happened? They were studying, they had music playing, but even so. He had to get in the building, get in the apartment, get into her bedroom, take her down, then drag her into the bathroom, strip her, hold her under until she drowns, and then get out of the place without bumping into anybody."
"If he's clever about it," I said, "and if his luck is running- "
"Oh, it's doable, no question. And he wasn't perfect."
"The towel."
"The towel is one. He probably just assumed towels are in the bathroom, you don't have to take one. But her bath towel was on a hook in her closet, and she wouldn't have left it there and then got in the tub. The vodka bottle's another. It's more plausible without the liquor- she stumbles, hits her head on the tub, whatever, drowns before she recovers consciousness. That's more plausible than an afternoon drunk on two ounces of Georgi with a girl who's not a drinker to begin with. Plus where's the bag?"
"The bag?"
"You ever buy a pint of booze and not have them put it in a paper bag for you? She'd have left the bottle in the bag until she got home, not tossed the bag on her way home. And the fingerprints. He was cute, wiping the bottle, getting her prints on it, but he used the wrong hand and didn't bother with the cap. That's not enough to hang him, but it's plenty to make a person take a second look."
"You think so? Most people wouldn't even notice."
"Well, I noticed."
"But you're pretty good at this," I said. "A little smarter than the average bear."
He colored, surprised by the compliment. "I don't know about that," he said. "If I was that goddam good, I'd be able to tell you who killed her."
"According to Lia," I said, "his name is Arden Brill."
"Hell," he said. "It sounds more like Arden than anything else, doesn't it? Could you play it one more time?"
I had gone into the bedroom to fetch the answering machine, but Elaine woke up while I was unplugging it and insisted I leave the machine where it was and bring Wentworth in. She disappeared into the bathroom, and emerged during the second playing of the message, wearing a robe and fresh makeup. Since then we'd heard the message another half-dozen times, and were getting less certain with each hearing.
" Arden," he said. "Isn't that a place? The Arden Forest?"
"In Shakespeare," Elaine said. "I don't think there's a real forest."
"No? It's just made up?"
No one was entirely sure, and he pointed out that either way, it was an unusual first name. A last name, sure. Elizabeth Arden, for example. Elaine recalled Eve Arden, the actress, who was before Wentworth's time. I pushed the button and we listened to the message again.
"It could be Auden," he said. "Like the poet?"
"Or Alden," I suggested, "or maybe Alton. They're both occasionally used as first names."
Elaine checked the phone book. There were several Brills, but none with the initial A. "Of course that's just Manhattan," she said. "And who knows where he lives, or if his phone's listed."
"It's probably not his name," I said.
"Well, here's the way I see it," Wentworth said. "If it is his name, he's probably not the guy."
Elaine said, "Wait a minute, I must be missing something. If there actually is an English scholar named Arden Brill, that means the girl was lying? That doesn't make any sense."
Wentworth shook his head. "Let's assume she wasn't telling a story," he said, "because why would she? No, she was telling the truth. A guy told her his name was Arden Brill and he was doing a thesis on her aunt. Now if there really is such a person, then not only was she telling the truth, but so was he. His name really is Brill and he really was doing a paper, a thesis, whatever. So he's legit."
"And if there's nobody by that name- "
"Then he's a phony," I said, "and he got close to Lia so that he could copy her key and find a way around the burglar alarm. So if Brill is real, somebody else had a reason to want Lia Parkman dead. And if there's no such person as Brill, then he's the one."
"And a lot of good it does us to know that," Wentworth said, "because we've got no idea who he is."
After he left, promising to get back to us when he knew something, Elaine said there was another possibility. "There could be a man named Arden Brill, and he could even be a doctoral candidate in the English department. But that doesn't mean he's necessarily the man who got in touch with Lia Parkman."
"Don't stop there."
"Well, say I want to win your confidence. I make up this story about my thesis and your aunt, di dah di dah di dah. But suppose you check? So I pick a name of somebody who really exists, some scholar she wouldn't ordinarily run into in a million years, and when she checks, yes, there is an Arden Brill in the English department, as a matter of fact he's hard at work on his doctorate, which is probably on bird symbolism in the poetry of Robinson Jeffers and nothing to do with Susan Hollander, but nobody's going to tell her that. You see what I mean?"