‘Whyever not?’ said Lord Selachii.
‘Well, because during our history those we haven’t occupied we’ve tended to wage war on,’ said Lord Vetinari. ‘For some reason the slaughter of thousands of people tends to stick in the memory.’
‘Oh, history,’ said Lord Selachii. ‘That’s all in the past!’
‘A good place for history, agreed,’ said the Patrician solemnly.
‘I meant: why don’t they like us now? Do we owe them money?’
‘No. Mostly they owe us money. Which is, of course, a far better reason for their dislike.’
‘How about Sto Lat and Pseudopolis and the other cities?’ said Lord Downey.
‘They don’t like us much, either.’
‘Why not? I mean t’say, we do share a common heritage,’ said Lord Selachii.
‘Yes, my lord, but that common heritage largely consists of having had wars with one another,’ said the Patrician. ‘I can’t see much support there. Which is a little unfortunate because we do not, in fact, have an army. I am not, of course, a military man but I believe that one of those is generally considered vital to the successful prosecution of a war.’
He looked along the table.
‘The fact is,’ he went on, ‘that Ankh-Morpork has been violently against a standing army.’
‘We all know why people don’t trust an army,’ said Lord Downey. ‘A lot of armed men, standing around with nothing to do… they start to get ideas…’
Vimes saw the heads turn towards him.
‘My word,’ he said, with glassy brightness, ‘can this be a reference to “Old Stoneface” Vimes, who led the city’s militia in a revolt against the rule of a tyrannical monarch in an effort to bring some sort of freedom and justice to the place? I do believe it is! And was he Commander of the Watch at the time? Good heavens, yes, as a matter of fact he was! Was he hanged and dismembered and buried in five graves? And is he a distant ancestor of the current Commander? My word, the coincidences just pile up, don’t they?’ His voice went from manic cheerfulness to a growl. ‘Right! That’s got that over with. Now — has anyone got any point they wish to make?’
There was a general shifting of position and a group clearing of throats.
‘What about mercenaries?’ said Boggis.
‘The problem with mercenaries,’ said the Patrician, ‘is that they need to be paid to start fighting. And, unless you are very lucky, you end up paying them even more to stop—’
Selachii thumped the table.
‘Very well, then, by jingo!’ he snarled. ‘Alone!’
‘We could certainly do with one,’ said Lord Vetinari. ‘We need the money. I was about to say that we cannot afford mercenaries.’
‘How can this be?’ said Lord Downey. ‘Don’t we pay our taxes?’
‘Ah, I thought we might come to that,’ said Lord Vetinari. He raised his hand and, on cue again, his clerk placed a piece of paper in it.
‘Let me see now… ah yes. Guild of Assassins… Gross earnings in the last year: AM$13,207,048. Taxes paid in the last year: forty-seven dollars, twenty-two pence and what on examination turned out to be a Hershebian half-dong, worth one-eighth of a penny.’
‘That’s all perfectly legal! The Guild of Accountants—’
‘Ah yes. Guild of Accountants: gross earnings AM$7,999,011. Taxes paid: nil. But, ah yes, I see they applied for a rebate of AM$200,000.’
‘And what we received, I may say, included a Hershebian half-dong,’ said Mr Frostrip of the Guild of Accountants.
‘What goes around comes around,’ said Vetinari calmly.
He tossed the paper aside. ‘Taxation, gentlemen, is very much like dairy farming. The task is to extract the maximum amount of milk with the minimum of moo. And I am afraid to say that these days all I get is moo.’
‘Are you telling us that Ankh-Morpork is bankrupt?’ said Downey.
‘Of course. While, at the same time, full of rich people. I trust they have been spending their good fortune on swords.’
‘And you have allowed this wholesale tax avoidance?’ said Lord Selachii.
‘Oh, the taxes haven’t been avoided,’ said Lord Vetinari. ‘Or even evaded. They just haven’t been paid.’
‘That is a disgusting state of affairs!’
The Patrician raised his eyebrows. ‘Commander Vimes?’
‘Yes, sir?’
‘Would you be so good as to assemble a squad of your most experienced men, liaise with the tax gatherers and obtain the accumulated back taxes, please? My clerk here will give you a list of the prime defaulters.’
‘Right, sir. And if they resist, sir?’ said Vimes, smiling nastily.
‘Oh, how can they resist, commander? This is the will of our civic leaders.’ He took the paper his clerk proffered. ‘Let me see, now. Top of the list—’
Lord Selachii coughed hurriedly. ‘Far too late for that sort of nonsense now,’ he said.
‘Water under the bridge,’ said Lord Downey.
‘Dead and buried,’ said Mr Slant.
‘I paid mine,’ said Vimes.
‘So let me recap, then,’ said Vetinari. ‘I don’t think anyone wants to see two grown nations scrapping over a piece of rock. We don’t want to fight, but—’
‘By jingo, if we do, we’ll show those—’ Lord Selachii began.
‘We have no ships. We have no men. We have no money, too,’ said Lord Vetinari. ‘Of course, we have the art of diplomacy. It is amazing what you can do with the right words.’
‘Unfortunately, the right words are more readily listened to if you also have a sharp stick,’{10} said Lord Downey.
Lord Selachii slapped the table. ‘We don’t have to talk to these people! My lords… gentlemen… it’s up to us to show them we won’t be pushed around! We must re-form the regiments!’
‘Oh, private armies?’ said Vimes. ‘Under the command of someone whose fitness for it lies in the fact that he can afford to pay for a thousand funny hats?’
Someone leaned forward, halfway along the table. Up to that moment Vimes had thought he was asleep, and when Lord Rust spoke it was, indeed, in a sort of yawn.
‘Whose fitness, Mister Vimes, lies in a thousand years of breeding for leadership,’ he said.
The ‘Mister’ twisted in Vimes’s chest. He knew he was a mister, would always be a mister, was probably a blueprint for mistership, but he’d be damned if he wouldn’t be Sir Samuel to someone who pronounced years as ‘hyahs’.
‘Ah, good breeding,’ he said. ‘No, sorry, don’t have any of that, if that’s what you need to get your own men killed by sheer—’
‘Gentlemen, please,’ said the Patrician. He shook his head. ‘Let’s have no fighting, please. This is, after all, a council of war.{11} As for re-forming the regiments, well, this is of course your ancient right. The supplying of armed men in times of need is one of the duties of a gentleman. History is on your side. The precedents are clear enough, I can’t go against them. I have to say I cannot afford to.’