A twig snapped in his grasp, and birds flew chirping madly out of the tree at the gun-like sound. ‘No, but some of us could try not to be so stubborn and so stupid.’
‘Why don’t you just say whatever you want to say, Karim, before I get really bored? Is there something in my list of faults that you left out when we talked at the beach? You need to get another complaint off your chest?’
‘You’ve had a happy life, haven’t you?’
The shadows were reaching out from the tree trunks, and I shivered and moved into one of the remaining patches of light, but he didn’t follow.
‘You never stopped to consider that your happy family existed at the cost of mine. They should never have got married, my parents. They wouldn’t have, except your father said the most unforgivable thing, and then your mother forgave him for it with such a magnificent show of compassion. Never mind how my mother felt. Never mind that my father might have had feelings about the whole thing. But you haven’t considered that. How could you consider that, when the consideration would disrupt your happiness? How could you consider that if my mother had married him she would have been happy all the years I was growing up, and she wouldn’t have had to cheat and lie and sneak around? You think it’s hard becoming disillusioned with a parent when you’re twenty-one, Raheen? Well, try it when you’re fifteen. God, I was angry with her for over two years. Until I found out what your father said. He was the one who ruined her life, and my father’s, and mine. And don’t you dare look at me as if to say I’m transferring my anger on to your father. This is not transference. It’s the real thing.’
I wasn’t about to defend my father, or even point out how silly it was of him to attack my father and yet simultaneously assume he would have been the perfect husband. ‘I don’t know what this has to do with going back to Karachi. Karim, I don’t understand what we’re fighting about.’
‘You’re going to go back, aren’t you? After everything that’s happened you’re going to go back, because all you really want is to go on the way you’ve been going on. Like your father, who could so easily transfer his affections simply because it was easier to love someone who wasn’t Bengali, you arrange your life around everything that’s easy, even though it means wrapping yourself in a little cocoon and deciding that things that happen away from the street where you live don’t touch you. And then you pretend your street is the world.
‘And what happens tomorrow when you decide that being with me is too hard, what happens then, Raheen? How dispensable will I prove to be? As dispensable as I was when I left Karachi, and all you could do was write letters about how much fun you were having, and how foreign I was becoming day by day, and how you really weren’t interested in anything I had to say about how hard it was, how goddamn miserable it made me, to be away from Karachi, which meant being away from you.’
‘That’s not true, Karim.’ I was pulling a leaf apart between my fingers, the fleshy part separating easily and falling off the veins. ‘Go and read my letters again.’
‘I can’t. I cut them up, remember, and burnt what was left.’
‘Well, I remember what I wrote. I remember I used to tell you everything that was going on in school, every little detail, so that when you came back you wouldn’t have to feel like an outsider for even a second.’
‘You made me feel like the outsider. You told me what was happening without telling me it would be so much better if I were there.’
This was turning into some twisted nightmare. ‘I was only matching the tone you set in your letters, Karim. Your first letter to me, the first correspondence between either of us, started with you saying: Bet you’re boiling in that deadly summer sun, and here it’s cool enough for a sweater. Ha-ha!’ I repeated it again to emphasize the lightness of the letter’s tone. ‘Ha-ha!’
‘How could I use any other tone but “ha-ha!” when it was so obvious you didn’t want to hear anything from me that wasn’t a joke? Raheen, you used to see me crying, before I left Karachi, your best friend since we were born, you used to see me crying, because my parents were always yelling and my father was threatening to take me away and do you know how hard it is for a thirteen-year-old boy to cry in front of anyone? I cried in front of you, only in front of you, because I just needed you to ask what’s wrong and you couldn’t, you couldn’t, you didn’t even care enough to want to know. Go back to bloody Karachi. Go back and turn into Runty and see if I give a damn. Coming here was the stupidest thing I could have done.’
I caught hold of his sleeve. ‘Why did you come, then?’
‘I was going to take you to Boston with me. To see my mother. But I don’t want her to see you.’ He pulled away from me and headed out of the glen.
I threw the bits of leaf at him in frustration but they swirled and came back at me. I could hear his footsteps pick up and become a run, and I knew I’d never catch up with him.
If he’d stayed any longer he would have accused, you still haven’t called my mother. As though it was any easier calling her now I knew what she had suffered at the hands of both my parents. I remembered Aunty Maheen’s voice from that first aborted phone call—Darling, who is it? — and the sudden ache that made me hang up the phone because it wasn’t Uncle Ali she was speaking to. That was four years after the divorce. It made no sense, the strength of my reaction.
Yes, it did.
Yes, it did.
It seemed easier not to see her, that was the truth. It seemed easier not to have to see her and her husband and imagine how Karim must have felt — perhaps still felt — to see them together. Because if I had to imagine how Karim felt about the divorce, I’d have to face how I failed him. I used to walk around all day in those weeks after the divorce trying to shake off the suffocating feeling that came from imagining his hurt, and I felt that if I heard his voice, if I heard him weep, I would break into a million pieces. So instead I told him I didn’t know what to say; when he wrote back, I told myself that if he had my voice inside his head to speak to, that was enough. I never broached the subject again in any of my letters. In doing that, I drew a dividing line between us. I do not want your pain sitting on my heart, boy. Keep it away.
I leaned against the tree. I had done that, and both Karim and I knew it. When he told me I lived in tiny circles, that I didn’t want to acknowledge how I was connected to the outside world, he had been talking about the failure of my friendship to take part of his pain upon myself. Even if he didn’t know that’s what he had been talking about.
I veered off the path, and half-ran, half-slid, down to the river. I sat there a long time, watching the water flow past. Karim’s life after Karachi unfolded in front of me, and I did nothing to stop it, not even when I imagined Aunty Maheen telling him she was leaving. His loneliness then was complete. I stayed by the river long enough to push past tears, past hurt, until what remained was my shame. But I still didn’t leave. I stayed, allowing the shame to grow and grow, until finally there was a tiny exhalation, a release.
I stood up then and made my way back to the present. But when I neared my dorm, there were words etched into the soil near where he had fallen when he leapt from the tree: I’m sorry. I love you.
Or was that a soil-speck, not a full stop, between the first sentence and the second?
. .
In Boston, summer was in full swing. Sunlight glinted off the John Hancock building, glinted off the Charles. A convertible sped past, leaving a smell of ice cream in the air. I glanced down at the directions Aunty Maheen had dictated over the phone.