“And were the slaves freed when the Indians were forced to move?”
“No, they were moved right on out with the cattle. But my people didn’t go. They run off and came back to the hills. Been here ever since. Most of ’em was half-breeds, mixed black and white.”
“And Indian?”
“I don’t believe so. They used to say that the Indians gave fifty lashes to any of their tribe who married a slave.”
“But why did you claim to be Indian?” asked Elizabeth, shuddering as she sipped her tea.
“Because between 1830 and very recently, being anything else was not healthy around here. If they’d said they were black, they could’a been took back in slavery till the War between the States, and even after that they was worse off than the Indians. At least we never had no lynchings to worry about.”
“But everyone knew you weren’t really Indian?”
Amelanchier nodded. “It was my gran’daddy, the Wise Man, who changed that. When I was a little bitty girl, he told folks that the best way to keep a secret is not to tell it out, so from then on, the children were told they was real Indians. When I go, the truth goes with me; I never told a one of my young’uns any different. I never knowed you could tell from the bones of the dead.”
“Not until I told you,” said Elizabeth. She mustn’t think about that now; she mustn’t! “I don’t want your people to lose the land. It isn’t fair.”
“I wish Comfrey would have told me before he asked you’uns to come here. But he thinks I’m an old woman who don’t know nothing but plants.”
“It can’t be helped,” said Elizabeth briskly. She wondered how much time they had before Jake found her. “We have to figure out some reason other than the truth for you to have killed them! How about this: you killed them because you didn’t want the bones of your relatives disturbed by irreverent white scientists?”
“I was thinking of that myself,” said Amelanchier. “More tea?”
CHAPTER SIXTEEN
“WHAT DO YOU MEAN she’s gone?” Milo demanded. “Did she leave a note?”
“No. I thought she must have gone down to the creek or something, but I’ve called and she doesn’t answer.”
“Have you checked the site?” asked Milo. He couldn’t think of any reason for her to go there, but it was the only possibility that occurred to him.
“No. Shall we go out there now?”
“In a minute. Comfrey Stecoah is coming along. What happened here that would make Elizabeth leave? What did the deputy want?”
“He found out I’m a Cherokee, and he wanted to see if he could scare me into a confession. On account of the tomahawk.”
Milo considered this piece of information. “Was Elizabeth frightened?” he asked finally.
“If you mean, did she think I was going to scalp her, I don’t think so.”
“Well, what was she doing?”
“She spent most of the morning remeasuring those skulls. That, and moping about how nasty you’ve been lately.”
Milo’s lips tightened. “I have not been nasty! I’ve been professional. Those measurements had to be done correctly, whether it hurt her feelings or not.”
Jake scowled back. “Yeah? Well, suppose she did them correctly in the first place?”
“I wish she had,” said Milo softly.
“Maybe she did,” said Dummyweed brightly. He had no idea what they were talking about, but he felt that as representative of the law, it was time to say something, and that seemed appropriate.
It seemed to make sense to Jake. “Yeah,” he said evenly. “Maybe she did.”
Milo, who had never considered that possibility, was shaken. “What do you mean?”
“I sat here and watched her do those figures again for a couple of hours, man,” Jake informed him. “And she was getting the exact same answers she got the first time.”
“That’s impossible!”
“Why?” asked Dummyweed, interested.
They ignored him.
“The numbers don’t fit the chart,” said Milo, as if that settled it.
“Okay,” nodded Jake. “Assume for a moment that Elizabeth’s figures are right. That leaves two choices. One: that Alex faked or screwed up ten years of research on Plains Indians, or two…”
“That the Cullowhees are not Indians,” said Milo faintly.
“Take your pick,” shrugged Jake.
“Let me see those skulls!”
When Comfrey Stecoah found them in the common room some ten minutes later, Milo had measured two of the skulls, and his face looked as much of a death’s-head as any of them. Jake and the deputy were kneeling beside the crate, looking equally grim.
“Where’s the young lady?” asked Comfrey, looking around.
“You tell us!” Jake shot back.
“Elizabeth is missing,” Milo said as calmly as he could. “We’re going to check the site for her. Would you come with us, please?”
Comfrey shook his head, presumably at the strangeness of the female sex. “What made her take off?” he wondered aloud.
“I think it was a discovery she made this morning, Mr. Stecoah. According to the tests she did”-he paused for effect-“the Cullowhees are not Indian!”
“Oh, is that all?” said Comfrey. “Shoot far, I could’a told you that.”
Milo, to whom live people were always a closed book-of hieroglyphics-thought he had gone mad. Surely he could not have just heard… “What did you say?”
“I figured it out for myself when I was doing research into the origin stories. That’s how I spotted you, Little Beaver,” he said, nodding at Jake.
“Don’t call me-”
“Reckon we belonged to your gang a long time back. But all the other folks around here still believe they’re Indians, and I never told ’em no different.”
“But why did you call us in to do the study if you already knew?” Milo’s head was spinning.
“Oh, for the government, son. To make it look good. We filed a formal request for recognition with the Bureau of Indian Affairs, and we had to send a list of things we were doing to substantiate our claim. Old maps, birth certificates showing residence in this county. I figured a scientific study would look real official.”
“But it would disprove your case,” said Milo patiently.
“Oh, shoot, that didn’t worry me! You don’t understand the government. I know you fellows always tack words like ‘probably’ and ‘generally’ into your reports. You never say anything flat out simple. Most folks don’t read all those technical reports nohow, and them that do may not believe ’em. The report would look good in our case file, though.”
“But we’ll have to say that you aren’t Indian, and they won’t give you the land.” Another thought struck him. “Who are you, anyway?”
“Well, judging from what I found out, I’d say we were escaped slaves from the Cherokee nation. We got a family of Rosses up on the ridge; that’s a Cherokee last name.”
“So’s Stecoah,” murmured Jake.
“Is that possible?” asked Milo, turning to Jake.
“Sure. The Cherokees were the biggest slaveholders of any of the five nations. Bought ’em from the settlers.”
“Didn’t marry any, though,” said Comfrey.
“Usually not,” Jake admitted.
Milo shook his head incredulously. “So you’re a mixture of blacks and Anglo-Saxons. No wonder you didn’t fit the chart! And all this was for nothing, because you won’t get the land.”
Comfrey smiled easily. “Oh, I think we will. Don’t you, Little Beaver?”
Jake scowled. “Probably.”
“How can they give you a reservation when you’re not Indians?” asked Milo.
“I expect the other tribes will insist on letting us in,” Comfrey told him. “Otherwise, it might be bad for them in the long run.”
“This makes absolutely no sense!”
“Yes, it does,” Jake assured him.
“It’s politics,” explained the leader of the Cullowhees. “You see, if they kept us from getting tribal recognition, what would their grounds be?”