"Hell's bells," I muttered. "The Inquisition."
Forthill grimaced. "The Inquisition has become the primary reason Malleus maintains itself in secrecy—and why we very seldom engage in direct action ourselves. It's all too easy to let power go to your head when you're certain that God is on your side. The Inquisition, in many ways, attempted to bring our struggle into the light—and because of the situation it helped create, more innocent men and women died than centuries of the most savage supernatural depredation.
"We support the Knights of the Cross and do whatever we can to counsel and protect God's children against supernatural threats—the way we protected the girl you brought to me the year Michael's youngest was born. Now the order recruits people singly, after years of personal observation, and maintains the highest levels of personal, ethical integrity humanly possible." He turned to us, with a file folder in his hands. "But as you pointed out earlier, Harry. We're only human."
I took the folder from him, opened it, and found Buzz's picture. I recognized the short haircut, and the severe lines of his chin and jaw. His eyes were new to me, though. They were as grey as stone, but less warm and fuzzy.
"Father Roarke Douglas," I read. "Age forty-three. Five eleven, hundred eighty-five. Sniper for the Rangers, trained in demolitions, U.S. Army Chaplain, parish priest in Guatemala, Indonesia, and Rwanda."
"Good Lord preserve us," Michael said.
"Yeah. A real holy warrior," I said. I eyed Forthill. "And this guy was brought in?"
"I've met Roarke on several occasions," Forthill said. "I was always impressed with his reserve and calm in the face of crisis. He repeatedly distinguished himself by acts of courage in protecting his parishioners in some of the most dangerous locations in the world." He shook his head. "But he… changed, in the last few years."
"Changed," Michael said. "How?"
"He became a strong advocate for… preemptive intervention."
"He wanted to hit back first, eh?" I asked.
"You wouldn't say that if you'd seen what life can be like in some of the places Father Douglas has lived," Forthill said. "It's not so simple."
"It never is," I said.
"He was, in particular, an admirer of Shiro's," Forthill continued. "When Shiro died, he was devastated. They had worked together several times."
"The way you worked with Michael," I said.
Forthill nodded. "Roarke was… not satisfied with the disposition of Fidelacchius. He made it known to the rest of Malleus, too. As time went by, he became increasingly frustrated that the sword was not being put to use."
I could see where this one was going. "And then I got hold of Amoracchius, too."
Forthill nodded. "He spent the last year trying to convince the senior members of Malleus that we had been deceived. That you were, in fact," an agent of an enemy power, who had taken the swords so that they could not be used."
"And no one thought to mention the way those archangels gave orders that I was supposed to hold them?"
"They never appear to more than one or two people at a time—and you are a wizard, Harry," Forthill said. "Father Douglas hypothesized that you had created an illusion to serve your purpose, or else had tampered directly with our minds."
"And now he's on a crusade," I muttered.
Forthill nodded. "So it would seem."
I kept on reading the file. "He's versed in magic—well enough, at least, to be smart about how he deals with me. Contacts in various supernatural communities, like the Venatori Umbrorum, which probably explains that protective amulet." I shook my head. "And he thinks he's saving the world. The guy's a certifiable nightmare."
"Where is he?" Michael asked quietly.
"He could be anywhere," Forthill replied. "Malleus sets up caches of equipment, money, and so forth. He could have tapped into any one of them. I tried his cell phone. He's not returning my calls."
"He thinks you've been mindscrambled by the enemy," I muttered. "What did you expect to accomplish?"
"I had hoped," Forthill said gently, "that I might ask him to be patient and have faith."
"I'm pretty sure this guy believes in faith through superior firepower." I closed the file and passed it back to Forthill. "He tried to kill me. He abducted Alicia. As far as I'm concerned, he's off the reservation."
Forthill's expression became distressed as he looked at me. He turned to Michael, beseeching.
Michael's face was bleak and unyielding, and quiet heat smoldered in his eyes. "The son of a bitch hurt my little girl."
I rocked a step backward at the profanity. So did Forthill. The room settled into an oppressive silence.
The old priest cleared his throat after a moment. He put the file back in the cabinet and closed the door. "I've told you what I know," he said. "I'm only sorry that I can't do more."
"You can find her, can't you?" Michael asked me. "The way you found Molly?"
"Sure," I said. "But he's bound to be expecting that. Magic isn't a cure-all."
"But you can find her."
I shrugged. "He can't stop me from finding her, but he can damn well make sure that something happens to her if I do."
Michael frowned. "What do you mean?"
"Maybe he stashes her in a box that's being held fifty feet above the ground with an electromagnet, so that when I get close with an active spell up and running, it shorts out and she falls. The bastard is smart and creative."
Michael's knuckles popped as his hands closed into fists.
"Besides," I said. "We don't need to find him."
"No?"
"No," I said. "We've got the swords. He's got the girl." I turned to go. "He's going to find us."
Father Douglas called Michael's house later that night, and asked for me. I took the call in Michael's office.
"You know what I want," he said, without preamble.
"Obviously," I said. "What do you have in mind?"
"Bring the swords," he said. "Give them to me. If you do so without attempting any tricks or deceptions, I will release the girl to you unharmed. If you involve the police or attempt anything foolish, she will die."
"How do I know you haven't killed her already?"
The phone rustled, and then Alicia said, "H-Harry? I'm okay. H-he hasn't hurt me."
"Nor do I want to," Father Douglas said, taking the phone back. "Satisfied?"
"Can I ask you something?" I said. "Why are you doing this?"
"I am doing God's work."
"Okay, that doesn't sound too crazy or anything," I said. "If you're so tight with God, can you really expect me to believe that you'll be willing to murder a teenage girl?"
"The world needs the swords," he replied in a level, calm voice. "They are more important than any one person. And while I would never forgive myself, yes. I will kill her."
"I'm just trying to get you to see the fallacious logic you're using here," I said. "See, if I'm such a bad guy to have stolen the swords, then why would I give a damn whether or not you murder some kid?"
"You don't have to be evil to be ambitious—or wrong. You don't want to see the girl harmed. Give me the swords and she won't be."
There clearly wasn't going to be any profitable discussion of the situation here. Father Douglas was going to have his way, regardless of the impediments of trivial things like rationality.
"Where?" I asked.
He gave me an address. "The roof. You come to the east side of the building. You show me the swords. Then you come up and make the exchange. No staff, no rod. Just you."
"When."
"One hour," he said, and hung up.
I put the phone down, looked at Michael, and said, "We don't have much time."
The building in question stood at the corner of Monroe and Michigan, overlooking Millennium Park. I had to park a couple of blocks away and walk in, with both swords stowed in a big gym bag. Father Douglas hadn't specified where I was supposed to stand and show him the swords, but the streetlights adjacent to the building were all inexplicably dark except for one. I ambled over to the pool of light it cast down onto the sidewalk, opened the bag, and held out both swords.