She opened her mouth to reply, then decided to laugh instead. It was a real laugh, no giggle.
I raised a brow. “Your subconscious taking over?” I inquired.
“No.” She sobered. “I couldn’t help it. It struck me, of course Gil killed her. He couldn’t bear the thought of Mira’s husband being unfaithful to her, it was an insult to her womanhood, so he killed Phoebe. Do you blame me for laughing?”
“No. I’ll laugh too when I get around to it. Does anything else strike you? A motive for him you wouldn’t laugh at?”
“Of course not. It’s ridiculous. You’re just floundering around. Have you finished with me?”
I looked at Wolfe. His eyes were closed. “For now, yes,” I told her, “unless Mr. Wolfe thinks I skipped something.”
“How can he? You can talk in your sleep, but you can’t think.” She stood up. “What are you going to do?”
“Find a murderer and stick pins in him. Or her.”
“Not sitting here you aren’t. Don’t bother, I know the way out. Why don’t you go and tackle Wally Kearns? I’ll go with you.”
“Thanks, I’ll manage.”
“Where did he take Mira?”
“Either to Homicide West, two-thirty West Twentieth, or to the District Attorney’s office, one-fifty-five Leonard. Try Twentieth Street first.”
“I will.” She turned and was off. I followed, to let her out, but she was a fast walker and I would have had to trot to catch up. When I reached the door she had it open. I stepped out to the stoop and watched her descend to the sidewalk and turn west. The floodlights and ropes and police cars were gone, and so was Judy’s cab. My wrist watch said five minutes past midnight as I went in and shut the door. I returned to the office and found Wolfe on his feet with his eyes open.
“I assumed,” I said, “that if you wanted something from her I hadn’t got you would say so.”
“Naturally.”
“Have you any comments?”
“No. It’s bedtime.”
“Yeah. Since you’re with me on this, which I appreciate, perhaps I’d better sleep here. If you don’t mind.”
“Certainly. You own your bed. I have a suggestion. I presume you intend to have a look at that place in the morning, and to see Mr. Kearns. It might be well for me to see him too.”
“I agree. Thank you for suggesting it. If they haven’t got him downtown I’ll have him here at eleven o’clock.” I made it eleven because that was his earliest hour for an appointment, when he came down from his two-hour session up in the plant rooms with the orchids.
“Make it a quarter past eleven,” he said. “I will be engaged until then with Mr. Anderson.”
I opened my mouth and closed it again. “Didn’t you phone him not to come?”
“On the contrary, I phoned him to come. On reflection I saw that I had been hasty. In my employ, as my agent, you had made a commitment, and I was bound by it. I should not have repudiated it. I should have honored it, and then dismissed you if I considered your disregard of the rules intolerable.”
“I see. I can understand that you’d rather fire me than have me quit.”
“I said ‘if.’”
I lifted my shoulders and dropped them. “It’s a little complicated. If I have quit you can’t fire me. If I haven’t quit I am still on your payroll, and it would be unethical for me to have Miss Holt as my client. It would also be wrong for you to accept pay from me for helping me with the kind of work you are paying me to do. If you return the twenty-five to me and I return the fifty to Miss Holt, I will be deserting an innocent fellow being in a jam whom I have accepted as a client, and that would be inexcusable. It looks to me as if we have got ourselves in a fix that is absolutely hopeless, and I can’t see—”
“Confound it,” he roared, “go to bed!” and marched out.
VI
By 8:15 Tuesday morning I was pretty well convinced that Mira Holt was in the coop, since I had got it from three different sources. At 7:20 Judy Bram phoned to say that Mira was under arrest and what was I going to do. I said it wouldn’t be practical to tell a suspect my plans, and she hung up on me. At 7:40 Lon Cohen of the Gazette phoned to ask if it was true that I had quit my job with Nero Wolfe, and if so what was I doing there, and was Mira Holt my client, and if so what was she doing in the can, and had she killed Phoebe Arden or not. Since Lon had often been useful and might be again, I explained fully, off the record, why I couldn’t explain. And at eight o’clock the radio said that Mira Holt was being held as a material witness in the murder of Phoebe Arden.
Neither Lon nor the radio supplied any items that helped, nor did the morning papers. The Star had a picture of the taxi parked in front of Wolfe’s house, but I had seen that for myself. It also had a description of the clothes Phoebe Arden had died in, but what I needed was a description of the clothes the murderer had killed in. And it gave the specifications of the knife — an ordinary kitchen knife with a five-inch blade and a plastic handle — but if the answer was going to come from any routine operation like tracing the knife or lifting prints from the handle, it would be Cramer’s army who would get it, not me.
I made one phone call, to Anderson, to ask him to postpone his appointment because Wolfe was busy on a case, and he said sure, it wasn’t urgent; and, since Fritz takes Wolfe’s breakfast to his room and I seldom see him before he comes down to the office at eleven, I put a note on his desk. I wanted to make another call, to Nathaniel Parker, the lawyer, but vetoed it. For getting Mira out on bail he would have charged about ten times what she had paid me, and there was no big hurry. It would teach her not to drive a hack without a license.
At a quarter past eight I left the house and went to Ninth Avenue for a taxi, and at half past I dismissed it at the corner of Carmine and Ferrell, and walked down Ferrell Street to its dead end. There were only two alternatives for what had happened during the period — call it ten minutes — when Mira had been away from the cab: either the murderer, having already killed Phoebe Arden, had carried or dragged the body to the cab and hoisted it in, or he had got in the cab with her and killed her there. I preferred the latter, since you can walk to a cab with a live woman in much less time than you can carry her to it dead, and also since, even in a secluded spot like that and even after dark, there is much less risk of being noticed. But in either case they had to come from some place nearby.
The first place to consider was Kearns’s house, but it only took five minutes to cross it off. The alley that led to it was walled on both sides, Mira had been parked at its mouth, and there was no other way to get from the house to the street. On the left of the alley was a walled-in lumber yard, and on the right was a dingy old two-story warehouse. On inspection neither of them seemed an ideal spot for cover, but across the street was a beaut. It was an open lot cluttered with blocks of stone scattered and piled around, some rough and some chiseled and polished. A whole company could have hid there, let alone one murderer and one victim. As you know, I was already on record that Mira hadn’t killed her, but it was nice to see that stoneyard. If there had been no place to hide in easy distance… Three men were there, two discussing a stone and one chiseling, but they wouldn’t be there at eight in the evening. I recrossed the street and entered the alley, and walked through.
By gum, Kearns had a garden, a sizable patch, say forty by sixty, with flowers in bloom and a little pool with a fountain, and a flagstone path leading to the door of a two-story brick house painted white. I hadn’t known there was anything like it in Manhattan, and I thought I knew Manhattan. A man in a gray shirt and blue jeans was kneeling among the flowers, and half way up the path I stopped and asked him, “Are you Waldo Kearns?”