“I found the gun, Kat.”
“I know.”
“It was hidden in his house. In a false panel under his bed.”
“I know that too. But didn’t you ever find that odd? The guy was always so careful. He’d use his weapon and dump it. But suddenly, you find the murder weapon stashed with his unused guns.”
The quasi amused smile stayed on his lips. “You look like your old man, you know that?”
“Yeah, so I hear.”
“We had no other suspects or even theories.”
“Doesn’t mean there weren’t any.”
“Cozone put out a hit. We had a murder weapon. We had a confession. Leburne had means and opportunity. It was a righteous bust.”
“I’m not saying you guys didn’t do good work.”
“Sure sounds like it.”
“There are just some pieces that don’t fit.”
“Come on, Kat. You know how these things go. It is never a perfect fit. That’s why we have trials and defense lawyers who keep telling us, even when the case is completely solid, that there are holes or inconsistencies or that the prosecution’s case doesn’t”—he made quote marks with his fingers—“fit.”
The band stopped playing. Someone took the microphone and began a long-winded toast. Suggs turned and watched. Kat leaned closer to him and said, “Can I ask you one more question?”
He kept his eyes on the speaker. “I couldn’t stop you if I still carried my piece.”
“Why did Stagger go up to see Leburne the day after he was arrested?”
Suggs blinked a few times before turning his face toward her. “Come again?”
“I saw the visitors’ logs,” Kat said. “The day after the feds arrested Leburne, Stagger interrogated him.”
Suggs mulled it over. “I would say something like ‘I think you’re mistaken,’ but my guess is, you’ve already confirmed it.”
“Did you know about it?”
“No.”
“Stagger never told you?”
“No,” Suggs said again. “Did you ask him?”
“He said he went up on his own because he was obsessed with the case. That he was impetuous.”
“Impetuous,” Suggs repeated. “Good word.”
“He also said that Leburne didn’t talk to him.”
Suggs started peeling the label off his beer. “So what’s the big deal, Kat?”
“Maybe nothing,” she said.
They both stood there, pretending to listen to the speaker.
Then Suggs asked: “When did Stagger visit exactly?”
“The day after Leburne was arrested,” Kat said.
“Interesting.”
“Why?”
“Leburne didn’t even come up on our radar until, what, a week later.”
“Yet Stagger was up there first.”
“Could have been a good hunch on his part.”
“One you and Rinsky missed, I guess.”
Suggs frowned. “You really think I’m going to take that bait, Kat?”
“Just saying. It’s bizarre, right?”
Suggs made a maybe-yes/maybe-no gesture. “Stagger was gung ho, but he was also pretty good about leaving us alone. He respected that Rinsky and I were running the investigation. The only thing we let him do was run down that fingerprint hit, but by then, we already had Leburne dead to rights.”
Kat felt a small tingle in the base of her spine. “Wait, what fingerprint?”
“It was nothing. A dead end.”
She put a hand on his sleeve. “Are you talking about the fingerprint found at the murder scene?”
“Yep.”
Kat couldn’t believe what she was hearing. “I thought you never got a hit on it.”
“Not while the case was live. It was no big deal, Kat. We got an ID a few months after Leburne confessed, but the case was already closed.”
“So you just let it go?”
He looked crestfallen by her question. “You know Rinsky and me better than that. No stone unturned, right?”
“Right.”
“Like I said, Stagger checked it out for us. Turns out it was some homeless guy who offed himself. A dead end.”
Kat just stood there.
“I don’t like the expression on your face, Kat.”
“The fingerprints,” she said. “Would they still be in the file?”
“I guess so. I mean, sure. It would be in the warehouse by now, but maybe—”
“We need to run them again,” Kat said.
“I’m telling you. It’s nothing.”
“Then do it for me, okay? As a favor. To shut me up, if nothing else.”
Across the room, the speaker finished up. The crowd applauded. The tuba started up. The rest of the band followed.
“Suggs?”
He didn’t reply. He left her alone then, winding his way through the crowd. His friends called out to him. He ignored them and headed toward the exit.
Chapter 20
Brandon needed to walk it out.
His mom would be proud of that. Like every parent, Brandon’s mom bemoaned the time her child spent in front of screens—computers, televisions, smartphones, video games, whatever. It was a constant battle. His dad had understood better. “Every generation has something like this,” he’d tell Brandon’s mother. Mom would throw her hands up. “So we just surrender? We let him stay in that dark cage all day?” “No,” Dad would counter, “but we put it in perspective.”
Dad was good at that. Putting things in perspective. Offering a calming influence on friends and family. In this case, Dad would explain it to Brandon like this: Way back when, parents would bemoan the lazy child who always had their nose in a book, telling the child they should get out more, that they should experience life instead of reading it.
“Sound familiar?” Dad would say to Brandon.
Brandon would nod his head.
Then, Dad said, when he was growing up, his parents were always yelling at him to turn off the television and either get outside or—and this was kind of funny when you remember the past—read a book instead.
Brandon remembered how his dad had smiled when he told him that.
“But, Brandon, do you know what the key is?”
“No, what?”
“Balance.”
Brandon hadn’t really understood what he meant at the time. He’d been only thirteen. Maybe he would have pressed the point if he knew that his father would be dead three years later. But no matter. He got it now. Doing any one thing—even something fun—for too long isn’t good for you.
So the problem with taking long walks outside or any of that nature stuff was, well, it was boring. The worlds online may be virtual, but they were constant stimuli in constant flux. You saw, you experienced, you reacted. It never bored. It never got old because it was always changing. You were always engrossed.
Conversely, walking like this—in the wooded area of Central Park called the Ramble—was blah. He looked for birds—according to the web, the Ramble “boasted” (that was the word the website used) approximately 230 bird species. Right now, there were zero. There were sycamores and oaks and plenty of flowers and fauna. No birds. So what was the big deal about walking through trees?
He could, he guessed, understand walking through city streets a little better. At least there was stuff to see—stores and people and cars, maybe someone fighting over a taxi or arguing over a parking spot. Action, at least. The woods? Green leaves and some flowers? Nice for a minute or two, but then, well, Dullsville.
So no, Brandon wasn’t walking through this Manhattan woodland because he suddenly had an appreciation for the great outdoors or fresh air or any of that stuff. He did it because walking like this bored him. It bored him silly.
Balance for the constant stimuli.
More than that, boredom was a kind of thinking tank. It fed you. Brandon didn’t take walks in the woods to calm himself or get in tune with nature. He did it because the boredom forced him to look inward, to think hard, to concentrate solely on his own thoughts because nothing around him was worthy of his attention.
Certain problems cannot be solved if you are constantly entertained and distracted.
Still, Brandon couldn’t help it. He had his smartphone with him. He had called Kat, but the call had gone to her voice mail. He never left messages on voice mail—only old people did that—so he sent her a text to call him when she could. No rush. At least, not yet. He wanted to digest what he had just learned.