"Tiny likes pussy," Patti said. Her own cunt was drenched, bubbling, pulsing for what she had in mind – Tiny's cock. "Get on your back and let him taste your pussy."
Betsy moaned. "I'm afraid," she gasped, her head reeling as she wavered between passion and fear.
"Maybe you're ready for the cock I promised, huh?"
Betsy staggered back, a dreamy smile on her face. "I'm ready. Today we lose our cherries. Right?"
Patti giggled. "I'm ready."
"Where did you hide it?" Betsy moaned, her eyes scanning the barn. "In the hayloft?"
"It's not hidden," Patti said. She continued to rub her sensitive tits into Tiny's flank.
"Let me break your cherry first, okay?" Betsy was trembling, a tinge of fear surfacing.
"I don't need any help," Patti said. She dropped to her knees, mashing her tits into Tiny's hind leg. She spotted the head of his cock peeking from its sheath. "If you want to see the cock, get down here with me."
Curiously, Betsy dropped to her knees. Blinking, she spotted the fat head of Tiny's dick. "Holy shit, Patti. Do you see that?"
Patti giggled. "You mean this?" She reached under her pony and curled her fingers around his thick-skinned cock-sheath and stroked.
Betsy's mouth dried up. The shock of what she had just witnessed caused her to lose her balance. She fell back, legs in the air, virgin pussy totally exposed.
Patti laughed. "Wait until he gets hard." She stroked Tiny's prick, exposing more of his thick glistening cockshaft. His cock was growing under her gentle hand.
Betsy gawked. "What are you doing?"
"Getting his prick ready to break your cherry," Patti said.
"I didn't know you were talking about his cock. I thought it was a fake one." She was frightened, yet at the same time fascinated with what she was seeing.
Patti's fingers shifted slowly up and down Tiny's prick. She caressed her pony's heavy balls. "His cum is all inside here," she explained.
Betsy couldn't speak. Her mouth gaping open, her eyes wide, her breathing raspy, she could only stare.
"Say something, Betsy," Patti sighed as more hard pony-cock became exposed. "C'mon over and touch him."
Betsy shook her head. "I'm not going to touch him," she said. "You're crazy."
"I thought you wanted your cherry busted," Patti said, giving her frightened friend a quick glance.
"Not with that thing," Betsy moaned, her voice quaking.
"You'll change your mind once you see me fuck him." Patti was totally committed. The hardness of Tiny's prick and the powerful throbbing gave her a craving to be fucked that couldn't be denied.
Betsy's eyes stared first at Tiny's growing cock, then at Patti. "You're teasing me," she said, breaking into a smile.
"I'm not teasing." She stood up, stroked Tiny's rump. "Easy, boy. Easy."
Mesmerized, Betsy sat on the floor of the barn. She watched as Patti made a bed of hay, her gaze constantly drifting back to Tiny's long hard cock. Suddenly, her mouth watered and she tore her eyes away, forcing herself to concentrate on Patti.
Patti built up the pile of hay. The bench her mother had used, she knew, was too high. The hay would be perfect. Finished, she turned her attention back to her stunned friend. "You can go first if you want."
Numbly, Betsy shook her head. "You're not going to do it," she said. "You're teasing me."
"Watch." Patti brought Tiny over to the hay, guiding him into position. "Nice, Tiny," she soothed. She sensed the excitement in her pony and calmed him. "You're cherry too, huh?" She giggled. Tiny was finally in position.
Betsy could only stare. Her young body was on fire. The memory of Tiny's mouth on her tits had been burned into her brain forever. She stared at the fullness of Tiny's cock, stiff between his hind legs. She stared at his large balls and gulped.
"You sure you don't want to go first?" Patti asked. She was trembling, anxious to feel Tiny's cock up inside the soft wetness of her virgin cunthole.
"I don't believe you," Betsy said, unable to comprehend it all.
After stroking Tiny, Patti got on her knees and rolled easily under him. She stared at his prick, shaking now as the moment was drawing closer.
"Don't," Betsy groaned. "He'll kill you." On her back, Patti stared at her frightened friend. "Yesterday, I jerked him off. His cum drenched me. Today, I want all that cum in my pussy."
Betsy ogled the pony's cock. She squiggled closer, not wanting to miss anything if Patti were telling the truth.
"It's better than fucking Jimmy," Patti said, gripping Tiny's prick. "Tiny can't talk." She stroked his prick, angling her body into position.
Betsy watched, her tongue flicking over her lips nervously. "He's going to hurt you."
"He's going to hurt me good," Patti moaned. She spread her legs, gripped his cock and dragged his prick through her virgin gash. "Ooooo, shit, Betsy. Ooooo!"
Betsy trembled, her eyes misting over. Her heart pounded wildly. "Be careful," she rasped. "God, be careful."
Patti was overjoyed. She was at last going to lose her cherry. She wriggled her hips, the hay pricking her ass cheeks. "Oooo, Betsy, I'm nervous." She shuddered, squiggling her pussy against the head of Tiny's cock. She felt the pressure against her cherry and swooned.
The heat from Patti's pussy inflamed Tiny's cockhead. He tossed his head and whinnied, his mane swishing into his face and across his neck. He jerked, banging the head of his cock hard against Patti's cherry skin.
Patti squealed and braced herself for the invasion of Tiny's hard gorgeous cock. "Stick it in, Tiny! Ram it!" She was deliriously happy.
Silently, Betsy watched as a tremor swept through her own virgin cunt. "Is it in? Is it in?"
Patti gulped. "Not yet." She bit her bottom lip and held her trembling body still.
Tiny, his balls rumbling with hot pony-cum, fucked forward. The power of his thrust and the hardness of his cock split Patti's cherry skin like tissue paper. The head of his prick filled her tight virgin pussy.
Patti's face turned beet red. A hot searing pain shot through her pussy. "Aghhhhhh! He's in me! He's in me!" She thrashed in the hay, Tiny's cockhead buried in her virgin cunt.
"Does it hurt?" Betsy cried, seeing Patti's contorting features. "Tell me!"
"It burns! Ahhhhh! It burns." She fought the pain, knowing from watching her mother that pleasure would more than take its place. She wriggled, squeezing Tiny's fat cock deeper into her pussy.
Tiny helped. He jammed hard, fucking half his cock into Patti's tight pulsing cunthole. He neighed, his tail swishing quickly back and forth. He dropped his head, snorting as his ears flickered. Patti's hot wet pussy was making his balls ache and his prick throb.
Patti's face contorted in agony. The pain was getting worse. She was frightened, yet determined to see it through. The pleasure she had seen on her mother's face haunted her, urged her on.
She turned to Betsy, blue eyes filmy, face flushed, mouth open. "He's so deep inside my pussy. I feel like he's going to rip me apart."
Patti rolled her hips, urging the pony to fuck deeper. She humped up, capturing more of his cock. She clawed her flesh, her eyes fixed on Betsy's wide-eyed gaze.
Betsy squiggled down behind Tiny. Her eyes popped. What she saw sent spasms scurrying through her hot virgin body. Patti's pussy looked split open. Hard thick cockmeat spread her hole wide.
"Can you see?" Patti squealed. "Ooooo!" The pain was beginning to subside. More fuck juices flowed from her spongy cunt walls, greasing Tiny's giant cock for easier pumping.
Betsy saw the oozing flow and sucked in her breath. Curious, she reached under, stroked Tiny's heavy balls. Her fingers glided along his prickshaft and touched the lips of Patti's cunt. Juice greeted her. She almost fainted from feeling the throbbing of Tiny's thick cock.