"Santa's fake," she said.
"He's real!"
"No, he's not."
"How do you know?"
"I just do."
"But how do you know?"
"I just do."
"Prove it!"
Karen finally tore her gaze away from the screen.
"You want me to? Really?"
Her brother blinked at her. It was up to him now.
If he insisted on this, she'd have to go through with it, right? That's what big sisters are for-helping little kids learn. And if a lesson stung a little, well, that wouldn't be her fault, would it?
Ronnie nodded reluctantly.
"Alright," Karen said.
She walked over to the TV and switched it off. The reruns would come around again one day. That's why they call them "reruns." But this moment with her brother-it would come only once.
"Follow me."
She headed for the bedroom Mom had been sharing with Cousin Rick the past few months. The door was closed. The door was always closed now.
"Where are you going?"
Karen looked back at her brother. "Where does it look like I'm going?"
"But… we can't go in there."
"Why not? Mom's at the Tiger tonight. She won't be home for hours. And you know how it is when he's supposed to be watching us. He'll probably show up five minutes before Mom and pretend he was here all day."
"But if he catches us… you remember what he said."
Karen did remember. The tone of Rick's voice, anyway. If he ever found them messing with his things, he'd have to do something… ugly. Karen had understood that much even if some of the words were new to her.
"He won't catch us," she said. "We'll only be in there a minute."
She turned and opened the bedroom door. The room beyond was messy, dark. Adult.
She stepped inside.
The bed-that was the place to start. Karen got down on her hands and knees and pushed away the crumpled clothes and cigarette packs so she could take a look underneath. The shades were drawn down over the windows, yet just enough silver-gray light glowed around the edges to see by.
There wasn't much to see, though. Just more clutter.
A single shoe. Dad's aluminum softball bat, the one Mom kept around "for protection." An old People magazine. A torn wrapper with the word "Trojan" printed on it.
It suddenly occurred to Karen that she might not find what she was looking for. The thought scared her.
"What's down there?"
Karen looked over her shoulder. Her brother stood in the doorway, half-in half-out of the room.
"Nothing."
She stood and started toward the closet. To reach it, she had to step around a pile of dirty clothes as high as her waist.
The apartment had never been like this when Dad was alive. But after Mom had to start working two jobs-days at the Lawn Devil plant, evenings tending bar at the Toy Tiger Lounge-things changed.
And then Uncle/Cousin Rick showed up, and things didn't just change some more. They fell apart.
He appeared overnight, like Christmas presents or Easter eggs. One morning, Karen and Ronnie stumbled bleary-eyed from the tiny bedroom they shared and there he was. A complete stranger eating their Boo Berry at the kitchen table.
"Hey," he'd said through a mouthful of cereal. "Your mom's still asleep."
After another half-hearted bite-and a full minute of awkward silence-Rick dropped his spoon and stood up.
"I don't see how you can eat this crap," he mumbled, and he stomped past the still-gaping kids and disappeared into their mother's bedroom, closing the door behind him.
He'd left the bowl, still filled with milk and soggy blue blobs, sitting on the table. That was The Rick System for dining and dishwashing: Dirty bowls, plates, cups and silverware were left out, encrusted with food, until there was nothing left to eat with. And when you reached that point, you got all your food from KFC and White Castle and ate it straight out of the box.
Cleaning (never), sleeping (late), bathing (when people noticed the smell)-soon it was all on The Rick System. Mom was on The Rick System. And it was making her seem less like Mom every day.
Dad used to warn Karen about "bad influences" at school, but she never really knew what he meant until she saw the effect Cousin Rick had on her mother. If there really were a Santa Claus, she knew what she'd ask him for. Not that the fat man would do it.
Santa gave bad people a lump of coal. He didn't drop them down abandoned mine shafts.
"What are you looking for?" Ronnie asked as Karen stepped up to the closet Mom and Rick now shared.
"You'll see."
But Karen wasn't sure he would. What if there was nothing to see? Could Cousin Rick have changed Mom that much?
She pushed aside one of the closet's sliding doors and got her answer.
"Come here," she said.
She turned to her brother and grinned.
Ronnie moved into the room slowly, cautiously, as if the floor was littered with land mines instead of dirty laundry. But then he saw what had put the smile on his sister's face, and he ran the rest of the way to the closet, plowing through heaps of wrinkled clothes as he went.
"The Death Star! The Death Star! The Death Star!"
Ronnie reached out for the box, ready to tear the heavy cardboard apart with his bare hands to get at the treasure pictured in color on the side: a Star Wars Death Star playset, the very thing he'd asked Santa for in the letter Mom helped him write two weeks before.
Ronnie stopped.
The very thing…and here it was in Mom's closet next to a Nerf football and a Shaun Cassidy album and a Nancy Drew book and a bunch of plastic-wrapped socks and underwear.
Two tubes of brightly colored wrapping paper were propped up in the corner.
Karen watched her brother's face as he put it all together. Wonderment gave way to puzzlement gave way to disappointment.
And then finally: contentment.
No, there was no Santa Claus. But yes, there would be a Christmas… because their mother still loved them.
Ronnie dropped to his knees before the Death Star looking as reverent and awestruck as a shepherd in the manger.
"Last year, it was all under the bed." Karen knelt next to her brother and picked up the Shaun Cassidy LP-obviously a gift for her even though it was Leif Garrett she truly loved. "I found it by accident. Mom was getting rid of Dad's clothes and junk, and I… I guess I was looking for something I could keep."
"Why didn't you tell me?"
Karen shrugged. "You were too little. And you were still all sad about Dad."
"I'm still all sad about Dad."
Ronnie leaned in closer to the Death Star and started picking at the packing tape that sealed it in its box.
"Hey!" his sister barked, making him flinch. "You can't open it, dummy! We're not even supposed to be in here."
"But I wanna play with it," Ronnie whined.
"You can play with it after Christmas," Karen said, unconsciously imitating the flat tone and clipped diction of an exasperated adult. "And don't forget to look surprised when you unwrap it."
"But-"
"Do you want Rick to know we've been in here?"
"But-"
"Cuz he'll figure it out."
"But-"
"And then he'll be do it, I swear. What he said he would."
Ronnie nodded glumly… then reached out for the box again.
"But I wanna play with it."
Karen sighed. Fear didn't always work with Ronnie, and logic was no help whatsoever. What she needed now was a distraction.
"Hey, you know what?" she said. "I bet there's more presents in here. Maybe even something cooler than your Star Wars thing."
Ronnie looked at her skeptically, for what could be cooler than a Death Star playset? But he said, "Really?"
"Sure." Karen pointed into the darkness that swallowed the rest of the closet. "Back in there. Get out of the way and we can look."