I shook my head. "No, I mean, one person surviving this much trauma, or even two, I'll buy. But most people wouldn't survive it, or am I wrong?"
Evans pushed his glasses more securely on his nose, but nodded. "No, you aren't wrong."
"Then how did all six of them survive?" I asked.
He frowned at me. "I'm not sure I understand exactly what you're trying to say here, Ms. Blake."
"I'm asking what are the chances that six people of varying sex, background, physical fitness, age, etc … would all be able to survive the same amount of trauma. My understanding is that all the victims that were just skinned have survived, right?"
"Yes." Doctor Evans was watching me closely, pale eyes searching my face, waiting for me to go on.
"Why did they survive?"
"They're tough sons of bitches," Marks said.
I glanced at the lieutenant, then back to Evans. "Are they?"
"Are they what?" the doctor asked.
"Are they tough sons of bitches?"
He lowered his eyes as if thinking. "Two of the men worked out regularly, one of the women was a marathon runner. The other three were just ordinary. One of the men is close to sixty, and didn't have a regular exercise routine of any kind. The other woman is in her thirties but didn't … " He looked at me. "No, they aren't particularly tough individuals, not physically anyway. But I've found that it's often the people who aren't physically strong or outwardly tough that survive the longest under torture. The he-men are usually the first to cave."
I forced myself not to glance at Edward, but it was an effort. "Let me test my understanding, Doctor. Have any people that have been skinned like the six in that room died?"
He blinked and again looked into the distance as if remembering, then he looked at me. "No, the only deaths have been those people torn apart."
"Then I ask again, why are they all alive? Why didn't at least one of them die from shock, blood loss, or a bad heart, or hell, the pure terror of it."
"People don't die from terror," Marks said.
I glanced at him. "Are you absolutely sure of that, Lieutenant?"
His handsome face looked petulant, stubborn. "Yeah, I'm sure."
I waved the comment away. I'd argue with Marks later. Right now I was chasing a point. "How did all six of them survive, Doctor? Not why this six, but why all of them?"
Evans nodded. "I see what you mean. How could all of them have survived it?"
I nodded. "Exactly. Some of them should have died, but they didn't."
"Whoever skinned them is an expert," Marks said. "He knew how to keep them alive."
"No," Edward said. "No matter how good you are at torture, you can't keep everybody alive. Even if you do exactly the same thing to each of them, some people die and some people live. You're not always sure why some make it, and some don't." His voice was very quiet, but it filled the hush of the room.
Doctor Evans looked at him, nodding. "Yes, yes, even an expert can't make people survive what was done to these six. You should lose some of them. For that matter I don't know why they're all still alive. Why hasn't one of them contracted some secondary infection? They are all remarkably healthy."
Marks stood so abruptly, he spilled coffee over his hand. He cursed, striding to the sink and throwing the cup and all in the sink. "How can you say they're healthy?" He looked over his shoulder at the doctor while he ran his hands under the water.
"They are still alive, Lieutenant, and for their condition that is very healthy indeed."
"Magic would do it," I said.
Everyone looked at me.
"There are spells that can keep a person alive during torture so that the torture can be prolonged."
Marks tore too much paper towel off the roll and turned on me, wiping his hands with small abrupt movements. "How can you say you don't do black magic?"
"I said there are spells that will do it, not that I did the spells," I said.
It took him three tries to get the paper towel in the waste basket. "Just knowing about such things is evil."
"Think what you like, Marks, but maybe one of the reasons you had to call me in is that you've kept yourself so lily white that you don't know enough to help these people. Maybe if you were more interested in solving crime than in saving your own soul you'd have wrapped this up by now."
"Saving a soul is more important than solving crime," he said. He was striding towards me now.
I stood up, coffee cup in my hand. "If you're more interested in souls than crime then become a minister, Marks. What we need right now is a cop."
He stalked towards me, and I think would have come close enough to exchange blows, but I watched him remember what I'd done out in the hall. I watched him remember caution, and he walked far around me to get to the door.
Doctor Evans glanced from one to the other of us, as if wondering what he'd missed.
Marks turned at the door, pointing a finger at me. "If I have my way, you are going to be back on a plane tonight. You can't ask the devil to help you catch the devil." With that he closed the door behind him.
Evans spoke into the silence. "There must be more in you, Ms. Blake, than mere toughness, something I haven't seen yet."
I looked at him and took a drink of the cooling coffee. "What would make you say that, doctor?"
"If I didn't know better, I'd say Lieutenant Marks is afraid of you," he said.
"He's afraid of what he thinks I am, Doctor Evans. He's jumping at shadows."
Evans looked up at me, his tea forgotten in his big hands. The look was a long considering one. I had an urge to squirm under such scrutiny, but fought it down. "Perhaps you are right, Ms. Blake, or perhaps he has seen something in you that I have not."
"When you spend all your time worrying that the devil is right behind you, eventually you start seeing him whether he's there or not," I said.
Evans stood, nodding. He rinsed his coffee mug in the sink, washing it out with a fresh paper towel and soap. He spoke without turning around. "I do not know if I will ever see the devil, but I have seen true evil, and if there is no devil behind it, still it is evil." He turned and looked at me. "And we must put a stop to it."
I nodded. "Yes," I said, "we must."
He smiled then, but his eyes stayed tired. "I will work with my colleagues here that are more accustomed to working with the living instead of the dead. We will try and discover why these six survive."
"And if it's magic?" I asked.
He nodded. "Do not tell Lieutenant Marks, but my wife is a witch. She has traveled the world with me seeing such things. Sometimes what we find is more up her alley than mine, not often, mind you. People are quite able to torment one another without aid of magic. But occasionally it has been more."
"Don't take this wrong," I said, "but why haven't you called her in before this?"
He took in a long breath and let it out. "She was out of the country on another matter. Why, you may ask, didn't I call her home sooner?"
I shook my head. "I wasn't going to ask."
He smiled. "Thank you for that. I reasoned that my wife was needed elsewhere, and the FBI seemed so sure it was a person." He glanced at Edward then back to me. "The truth is, Ms. Blake, something about all this frightens me. I am not a man who is easily frightened."
"You're afraid for your wife," I said.
He stared at me as if he could look into my mind with those pale eyes. "Wouldn't you be?"
I touched his arm, gently. "Trust your instincts, doctor. If it feels wrong, send her away."
He drew away from my touch, smiling, tossing the paper towel into the trash can. "That would be terribly superstitious of me."