Ellie plants herself in front of Hosea, one French-manicured hand holding on to a bottle at her side, the other smoothing down the fabric on her hip.
“Klein’s been looking for you everywhere,” she says in one of those false-bright voices that makes it apparent nothing about the situation in front of her is okay.
“So I’ve heard.” Hosea stands and stubs out the clove on the bottom of his boot. “I needed some air.”
My phone buzzes in my pocket. A text from Sara-Kate: Where are you? I write back that I’m in the gazebo, put out my clove, and stand up, too.
“You guys know each other?” Hosea motions in my direction as if Ellie’s stare was not already boring into me like hot fire.
“Mmm. Thea, right?” She turns away before we can make eye contact and pulls on the bottom of her skirt, trying to tug it down to cover more of her bare legs. The fabric hardly budges and she gives up after a while, takes a long drink of cider as she looks at Hosea. She lowers the bottle and rakes her fingers through her chunky blond highlights. “Babe, we should go see what Klein wants.”
He takes her hand and I stare too long. At their intertwined fingers, how things are so easy between them. I wonder if I could have that, too.
They start to walk away but I don’t want Hosea to leave without a goodbye, so I blurt out, “Thanks for the clove.”
I’m not talking to her but Ellie turns her suspicious eyes on me and I don’t care. Trisha may be a burnout but at least she never pretends she doesn’t know who I am when we’ve been going to school together our entire lives. One day, I’ll leave girls like Ellie and Lark behind, and then they can’t say shit because I’ll be touring the world with a professional company. Lark is smart—National Honor Society, academic scholarships, the whole deal—so maybe she’ll do something worthwhile with her life when she leaves the kegstand phase behind.
But I don’t think Ellie has a whole lot going on behind the makeup. She coasts by on her looks and Trisha’s popularity and one of these days that has to catch up to her, right?
Hosea glances back at me and kind of nods. “Yeah, sure. Later, Theo.”
I sit down again to wait for Sara-Kate, pulling my knees up to my chest and wrapping my arms around myself as I inhale the sweet smoke that clings to my jacket. And for the tiniest moment, I let myself imagine Hosea’s arms are wrapped around me instead of my own.
CHAPTER FIVE
I WALK DOWNSTAIRS IN MY PAJAMAS THE NEXT
morning to find my father sitting at the kitchen table, drinking coffee and reading the newspaper. He used to bring work to the table sometimes until Mom forbid it. He’s good about sticking to her rule. Even if it means that some days he eats breakfast in record time or goes into the office absurdly early so he can work on spreadsheets over a doughnut and coffee.
He looks up as I approach, pushes his wire-rimmed glasses up his nose. He looks cozy in his green-and-navy flannel robe with the cuffs rolled up. “Morning, babygirl. Ready for ballet?”
I nod as I stifle a yawn. Saturday mornings always come too early, whether or not I went out the night before. And I’m never hungry for breakfast. I know it’s important because it sets the tone for the day and blah blah blah. But most days, the thought of food before 11:00 a.m. literally turns my stomach. Especially rich breakfast foods like fatty bacon and runny eggs and the worst of it alclass="underline" syrupy French toast.
But I can’t skip it. That’s a promise I can’t break or even bend, because one slip-up and they’ll be on the phone with Marisa, who could help them decide it’s time for me to go back to Juniper Hill. And I can’t go back there. I won’t.
So I make my way to the refrigerator and push aside the leftover baked spaghetti, reach for a carton of plain yogurt. I dump a few large spoonfuls into a bowl and sprinkle fat-free granola on top. Leaning against the island is my favorite way to eat. Standing up, taking in slow, deliberate spoonfuls so no one can accuse me of cheating.
Dad looks up in my direction, but not really at me. He does this for a while and I’ve opened my mouth to ask him what’s wrong when he says, “There’s news about Donovan.”
I almost drop my spoonful of yogurt on the floor. “More news? Is it bad?”
He looks right at me now. “He’s not talking, Theodora.”
My father is the only one who calls me that. His mother was Theodora, too, but I never met her. Usually my full name is attached to fairly innocuous sentences (How was your day, Theodora? Isn’t your mother’s tomato sauce delicious, Theodora?), so it takes a bit for the weight of this one to sink in.
“Not talking?” I set my bowl down on the counter. “Like, at all?”
“Not at all,” he says to me with sad eyes. Then: “And they’ve released information about the suspect.” He rubs a hand over the thinning hair at the back of his head before he folds the front page of the paper in half, highlighting the mug shot on the front. “The person who took him is . . . a man. Thirty years old. His name is Christopher Fenner.”
I take the paper from my father, scan the story in front of me. Christopher Fenner’s name floats across the page, along with the kidnapping and child endangerment charges. My eyes travel to the picture that accompanies the article.
Fuck.
Christopher Fenner has bright eyes and a defiant mouth and dark hair that curls over his collar. Even with a scruffy beard, he doesn’t look thirty. He seems like the kind of guy whose worst offense would be pounding too many Bud Lights and passing out in his truck, not someone who would kidnap a child and drag him thousands of miles from his home so he could—
No. I can’t think about the images that have been swimming through my mind for so many years. He’s only a suspect. Maybe there was a mistake. Or maybe that’s what I’ll tell myself until we know more, because it’s easier than putting a face to all the abuse I’ve imagined that Donovan endured.
Donovan was—
No match for someone like this.
The suspect’s flat, still eyes stare into mine until I can’t take it.
Fuck.
“They say he worked at the convenience store a few months before the abduction, that Donovan probably knew him.” Dad is talking again but I can’t look at him.
I try to swallow the bile in my throat but seconds later I’m rushing toward the sink, leaning over, vomiting what little breakfast I’ve had into the basin. I stay hunched over for a while, rasping out breaths and wiping my eyes, even after Dad jumps up to stand behind me. He sort of pats my back and says, “Oh, Theodora” over and over in this sad voice.
A couple of moments pass before he adds, “I didn’t mean to upset you. I wouldn’t have shown it to you if—”
If he’d thought I couldn’t handle it.
I turn on the faucet to wash away the mess, then cup my hands under the water, rinse out my mouth.
“No, it’s okay. I wanted to know.” My voice echoes back up from the sink. I straighten up and wipe my lips with the striped dish towel sitting on the counter. “I needed to know.”
“Why don’t you stay home today?” He says it like he’s doing me a favor, like he’s suggesting I skip school on the day we’re scheduled to dissect fetal pigs.
“I can’t.” I haven’t missed a dance class in three years, and the times before that weren’t by choice. He knows this, which is why he doesn’t challenge me.
I dump out the rest of my breakfast because I don’t think I could get down another bite.
“You’re sure you don’t want to take the morning off?” Dad removes his glasses to look at me. He only needs them when he’s working or reading. “I could call Marisa and explain. I’m sure she’d understand if you need to stay home today.”