I picked up my list and went to work, haunted by the memory of my very first day as a detective constable, when old Alf Stein, who went on to become my mentor, gave me a desk, a phone and a list of bystander witnesses, made by two PCs who attended a near-fatal stabbing, and told me to get on with interviewing them.
I did too; the fifth person I spoke to told a story that was so much at odds with the first four, who had all painted more or less the same picture, that I stopped what I was doing and dug a little deeper into his background. The ‘witness’ had professed no knowledge of the victim, and yet a simple check showed me that when he had served six months in Saughton for assault, the two had been cellmates.
I decided to look more deeply at the victim: I pulled his record and called the detective sergeant who was listed as his last arresting officer. He told me to fuck off if I knew what was good for me. I invited him to say that to my face, then went to Alf and told him what I had discovered.
We pulled in the witness and sat him down in a windowless, airless room in Gayfield Square, my least favourite of all the Edinburgh police stations. His name was Thomas McGraw, and he went down in my personal history as my first ever CID collar. Ten minutes of Alf’s relentless, unblinking interrogation . . . from then on I modelled my own interview style on his . . . and he coughed the lot.
The victim, one Scott Hancock, a recidivist criminal, had been on the payroll of Ernie Lewis, my detective sergeant acquaintance, as an informant, but that relationship had been tarnished when he confessed to McGraw in an unguarded moment in their cell that much of the information he had provided had come from a man called Dougie Terry, also known as the Comedian, and had been designed to incriminate his enemies while protecting his friends.
McGraw had gone straight to Lewis, with a view to securing the DS’s favour, and had been told to prove himself by serving notice on Hancock with the weapon of his choice. It had all gone according to plan, until the two PCs arrived ahead of schedule, having heard the victim’s cries. With his escape route blocked, McGraw had mingled among the growing crowd of passers-by at the scene. When asked for his details he had been foolish enough to give his real name.
Hancock survived, McGraw pleaded guilty to an assault charge rather than attempted murder and both men gave evidence against Ernie Lewis. By the time he came out I was a chief inspector. Alf let me charge McGraw, but he kept Lewis for himself, for he didn’t think it wise for a rookie DC to have another a cop on his arrest docket.
My trawl of the coastal marinas of Britain and Ireland was nowhere near as successful. In fact it was a total bust, as I had feared from the outset. Most of the places told me they couldn’t handle a vessel of that size, and the rest said that if one had turned up, they would have recalled it, but couldn’t. For the sake of thoroughness I checked out the fuelling points at Inverkip and Oban, but had no joy at either.
The only credit I could give myself was for doing something that McGarry hadn’t, but that was offset by the truth that his slackness had actually saved police time.
For the sake of thoroughness, I called the managers of the stolen boats website, but they had no fresh information, and nothing waiting to be added. The Princess Alison was gone, and if Walter Hurrell was right, gone for good.
I was pretty certain that before the week was out I would be reporting back to Eden, recommending that he negotiate the best settlement he could with his insurers, but I still had one place left to go.
Jock Hodgson still hadn’t got back to me. I tried him again, with no more success than before, then I called Luisa McCracken.
‘Jock does other things as well as crewing the Princess, ’ she told me. ‘We have first call on his time, but he does quite a bit of engine maintenance work.’
‘Could he be on holiday?’ I asked.
‘That’s unlikely; being single, he hardly ever takes any. When he does he always gives us plenty of notice. Hold on.’
I did, for a couple of minutes.
‘I have a folder on him,’ Luisa said when she returned. ‘There are no notes about holidays, just timesheets.’
‘When did you hear from him last?’
‘Last October. Walter told him that the boat had been stolen, then I called him to arrange a meeting with the insurance underwriters. There’s an understanding that when the boat’s recovered or replaced, we’ll get in touch with him.’
‘Do you have an address?’ I asked. ‘I won’t be ignored; if he won’t call me back, I’ll go and bang on his door.’
‘I thought you’d want that,’ she said. ‘I have it here; it’s Ailsa View, Dunglas Avenue, Wemyss Bay. It’s a long drive, mind.’
‘Nah, I can do it in a couple of hours.’
It was just after midday; I fixed myself an early lunch, ham slices and coleslaw in a couple of wholemeal pitta breads, then grabbed a Snickers bar and a bottle of water for the journey, and headed off in my still-wounded car, after making a mental note to dump the repair in the hands of my insurers, and let them fight it out with the owner of the BMW, whoever he might be.
Gullane to Wemyss Bay is a coast-to-coast drive, Firth of Forth to the Firth of Clyde, round Edinburgh and through Glasgow, motorway for all but the first ten miles and the last fifteen. I made good time; it was two fifteen and I was on the outskirts of Greenock, when my phone sounded.
‘Mr Skinner?’ It was Clyde Houseman.
‘Yes,’ I replied. ‘I’m on the road and I’m alone. You can speak.’
‘Good. I have feedback for you on the man you asked about. It wasn’t easy to get, and I can understand why. I told you that the name rang a bell with me; it should have been an alarm bell. Yes, Petty Officer Hurrell was operational in the Special Boat Service, but not for long. He served in Iraq, in a different zone from me, up in the north of the country, chasing a cadre of Saddam’s old Revolutionary Guard who were taking revenge on civilians in and around his home town. He was part of a three-man team, who caught up with some of them in a house near Tikrit. By that time they weren’t much of a threat; there were only five of them left and they’d hardly any ammo. Hurrell’s unit was under the command of a Marine sergeant, a lad I knew. He was under orders to take prisoners back for interrogation, so he gave them the chance of surrender.
‘They took it. They threw their weapons out of the window and came out in a line, hands on head. One of them twitched; he scratched his ear, my friend told me. Whatever he did, it spooked Hurrell. He mowed the fucking lot of them down.’
‘Was he court-martialled?’ I asked.
‘In another unit he might have been, but not in Special Forces. He was kicked out, unceremoniously. They sent him back to his minesweeper. Six months later, he left the service and went to work for your man Higgins. His CO knew nothing about the Iraq incident, and wrote him an excellent reference. It’s still on file.’
‘The reference,’ I said. ‘Does it square with the rest of his service record?’
‘It does,’ Houseman replied. ‘His reports show him to have been an exemplary sailor.’
‘Apart from killing five unarmed men in cold blood,’ I chuckled.
‘We all have our off days, sir.’
I thanked Houseman and drove on, letting my navigation system guide me for the rest of the journey. One big difference between the Firths of Forth and Clyde is that ferries still run in the latter. Wemyss Bay is one of the terminals; a rail service from Glasgow delivers Rothesay-bound passengers all year round. My dad took the family there on holiday when I was six. God bless him, it was his idea of a good time.
Satnav took me straight to Dunglas Avenue, but Hodgson’s house wasn’t so easy to find. The street was a short cul-de-sac, and none of the dozen bungalows had numbers, only names. I looked at them all, one by one, but couldn’t see Ailsa View anywhere. Puzzled, I thought about calling Luisa to recheck the address, but before I could do that, I was hailed by a white-haired lady in a tweed skirt and heavy purple jumper, standing in the doorway of a little dwelling called Barrhead.