She nodded, wondering whether the mayor’s wife was busy with Chase. If he followed the same pattern she did, he probably was in there questioning her right now. If only she could skip one step and go straight to the next suspect, she could get ahead of him, and solve this murder before he did. Wouldn’t it be fun if he read in his morning paper who Paulo Frey’s murderer was? That would make him feel pretty stupid, wouldn’t it?
So she decided not to wait for the mayor’s wife, and to simply assume Aissa hadn’t lied about her alibi. She checked her notes, and saw that the next person to talk to was Gabby Cleret, the well-known Hollywood actress.
She’d left her pickup parked in front of her father’s office, and now quickly returned there to fetch it. And as she did, she saw that her father had just stepped out of his office and was on his way back from the hardware store next door, carrying what looked like a big roll of screen.
“Hey, honey,” he said when he saw her. “We keep running into each other today, don’t we?”
“It’s a small town, Dad,” she said, then gestured at the roll of screen. “What are you up to?”
“Oh, I promised your mother I’d finally fix that screen door. It’s been broken ever since your cat destroyed it last summer.”
“My cat? Wasn’t it your cat who jumped on the screen and ripped it to shreds?”
He grinned.“I think they all played an equal part in its destruction. Oh, before I forget,” he said as she made to go to her pickup. “There’s something I need you to do for me.”
“What’s that?”
“I don’t know if you met him, but your uncle Alec hired a new cop. His name is Chase Kingsley and he just arrived in town a couple of days ago.”
Her lips tightened and she crossed her arms as she leaned back against her car.“We’ve met.”
He flashed her a grin.“Oh, that’s right. Chase told me you did.”
“Did he now?”
“Uh-huh. He was in here just now for a, um, consultation. The thing is, Chase used to work as a cop in New York, and got in trouble over some business out there. It’s no great secret, as it’s been all over the New York papers a couple of months ago. He was dishonorably discharged from the NYPD,” he said, also leaning against the car.
“Yes, I know,” she said tersely. She could hardly tell her dad that she also knew all about the conversation he’d had with Chase in his office. It had certainly made her think. If it was true that he’d been framed, it changed everything. But she hadn’t made up her mind that he’d been telling the truth.
A few passersby nodded friendly greetings at father and daughter Poole, and Tex greeted them back jovially while Odelia merely glared at them. She knew exactly what her dad was going to ask her to do, and she’d been dreading the moment ever since Max and Dooley had told her about it.
“Look, I’d like to correct the impression that Chase is some kind of bad apple,” said Tex. “I can’t go into too much detail without divulging certain confidential information that’s strictly between my patient and me, but…”
“Just spit it out, Dad. What is it you want to tell me?”
“Chase has been wronged, honey. That story about him assaulting a suspect’s wife? That’s just a load of poppycock. So I told him I’d talk to you, Hampton Cove’s premier reporter, and convince you to help spread the word that Chase Kingsley is a fine, upstanding citizen and a great cop, and that whole nonsense about his dismissal is simply one big misunderstanding.”
“I don’t know, Dad,” she said, shaking her head. “Are you saying he didn’t assault that woman?”
“That’s exactly what I’m saying. And what Chase is saying.”
“And you believe him?”
“I most certainly do.”
She shook her head again. Dad was always a sucker for a sob story. Whereas she was a hard-nosed reporter, he believed anything. As she saw it, it was Chase’s word against the woman he’d allegedly molested, so who was she to believe? This far-fetched tale about him catching the commissioner and the mayor’s wife in the act? Or the official story as it had appeared in an NYPD statement and accurately had been reported in the news? Tough choice. But judging from what she’d seen of Chase Kingsley so far, she was inclined to go with the molestation story. The guy was simply bad news.
“So what I want you to do is write a nice little piece, extolling Chase’s virtues, so to speak, and spread the rumor that his dismissal was a mistake.”
“What mistake? Why would the NYPD fire a cop for no reason?”
“I, um…” Her dad quickly glanced around, then said in hushed tones, “Let’s just say he saw certain things he wasn’t supposed to see.”
“What things?” she insisted. She wanted this on the record, so she could use it in a story if she had to.
He stared at her for a moment.“I keep forgetting what a tough reporter you are, honey. Is this the way you conduct all your interviews?”
“Of course. I’m a professional, Dad.”
“Right. Um…” He scratched his scalp, obviously torn.
“I’ll tell you what I heard,” she said, feeling sorry for him. “I heard Chase caught the commissioner and the mayor’s wife making whoopee in his office. So to make sure nobody would believe him if he talked, they bribed this suspect’s wife to fabricate a story about him that got him fired. Am I close?”
He stared at her.“My God, honey. You are good. Who told you?”
She shrugged.“I’ve got my sources. The big question is: do you believe him?”
“Of course I do.”
“What if he’s lying? What if the story is true and he really assaulted that woman? And this whole story about the mayor’s wife is something he made up to protect his reputation and make sure he can work as a cop again?”
Tex shook his white-haired head.“People don’t fool me that easily, honey. I’ve been treating patients for three decades. Trust me, by now I know if they’re lying or not. It’s called intuition, and after so many years I’ve got it in spades.” He stared at her. “You seem adamant to believe the worst about Chase, though. How come?”
“We met this morning in Uncle Alec’s office and he took an instant dislike to me and I to him.”
“You got off on the wrong foot, that’s all. Once you get to know him, you’ll see he’s a great guy. And, I’m sure, a very talented police officer.”
“I just wish he would let me in on the murder investigation.”
“What murder investigation is that?”
“Haven’t you heard? Paulo Frey was murdered. They found his body yesterday out at the Writer’s Lodge.”
“The writer that disappeared?”
She nodded.“Dan asked me to write the story.”
“And Chase doesn’t want you interfering with the investigation.”
“Nope. He feels reporters have no place in a murder investigation.”
“Well, I can certainly understand his aversion to reporters,” said Tex.
“You mean because of that hatchet piece that appeared in thePost?”
Her father nodded sagely, and gave her a grim smile.“He probably feels that that article sealed the deal on his career. Made him persona non grata.”
Her dad had a point. Chase would have an ax to grind with reporters. Unless the assault charges were true. In that case he simply didn’t want reporters snooping around and discovering other dark secrets from his past.
“I don’t know, Dad,” she said, shaking her head.
“You won’t spread the story that Chase was framed?”
“I don’t see how I can. Not unless I know for sure.”
He sighed.“Fair enough. Always check your sources, huh?”
“Exactly. Imagine I spread the story that Chase is innocent, and it turns out he’s been playing us for a fool. That would ruinmy reputation.”
“Like I said, honey,” said her father, straightening. He fixed her with a kindly look. “After all these years, nobody takes me for a fool. Trust me. But if you feel you can’t do this in good conscience, then simply don’t.”