And finally I let her go.
Her ankles were hooked around my calves since she’d been using her legs to try and raise herself off the mattress and get that contact pressure against my pelvic bone. It was a simple matter to slam myself down, grind down HARD on her clit, and carve my cock around the inner walls of her cunt. I sucked on her neck hard enough to leave a hickey - good thing she didn’t have any Zoom classes for a few days lest she need to wear a turtleneck. And at the same time, I reached a hand beneath her ass, grabbed the end of her butt plug, and wriggled it at the same time.
Michelle exploded.
She clamped down on me so hard that I nearly came.
And then she passed out.
Perfect.
Michelle’s body had gone as limp as it would ever go. I paused on top of her body, propped up on my elbows so that my chest wouldn’t crush her while I tried to catch my breath. She looked so peaceful, eyes closed in sleep with her head lolled to the side. I chuckled at the sight of her developing hickey now prominently displayed in the crook of her neck.
“Pull out, quick,” Alex said, suddenly beside me.
“Huh?”
She held up the bottle of lube.
“Oh, right.”
I backed out, exiting my little sister’s sodden snatch with an audible squish. She was soaked in girlcum, and trickles of it started running out of her twat and down her taint.
Alex quickly filled her hand with lube and slathered it onto my throbbing erection. A second later, she pulled out the butt plug, stuck in the nozzle, and squirted her sister’s rectum with a ton of the slippery stuff as well. Michelle moaned and started to awake.
“Hurry up!” Alex hissed. She grabbed my beautiful dick in her hand and aimed me while I took hold of Michelle’s legs and lifted them over my shoulders for leverage.
With my cockhead notched, Alex actually spanked my ass, and I reflexively rammed the first four inches in.
“AAAAAAHHHHHH!!!” Michelle’s eyes flew WIDE open as she suddenly felt a human dick invade her ass for the very first time.
I stopped, halfway in. She’d clamped up TIGHT and I wasn’t going to make it any deeper without her express permission.
“Fucking FUCK!” my little sister barked, her eyes staying open wide as she searched the ceiling for answers as to how her previously virgin asshole had been suddenly violated. “Holy SHIT you guys...”
Alex was suddenly over Michelle’s face, blocking her view of the ceiling as she chirped, “Merry Christmas!”
“Fuck you for talking me into doing this.”
“Aww, but you wanted to give him the perfect present.” Alex giggled again.
“I take it back.”
“Little late for that, sister.”
“It’s too big.” Michelle shook her head in a vehement negative.
“It’s already in you.”
“It’s not gonna all fit.”
“It’s gonna all fit.”
“No way. It’s too fucking big.”
“Just relax.”
“You forget. I was there when he first did this to YOU. It’s too fucking BIG.”
“You can take it.”
“You were screaming about how much it hurt!”
“But it hurt so GOOOOOD.”
“How the fuck can hurt be good?”
“You’re about to find out.”
“I don’t— Ah, fuck.”
Alex had spanked my ass again, and I suddenly lurched forward another inch. Holding Michelle’s legs over my shoulders, I looked down at her with concern, wondering if I should pull out.
“There you go.” Alex said with a smile.
“I never shoulda let you talk me into this.”
“You’re doing great.” Alex spanked my ass again, and I pushed forward another inch. Keeping up the pressure and switching my grip to her buttcheeks, I pulled her body toward mine, burrowing deeper and deeper and deeper.
“Fuck!” Michelle exclaimed, once again searching the ceiling as her head lolled left and right. Her eyes were actually unseeing, all her attention focused inward on the baseball bat crawling up her ass. “Holy FUCK! Fuckity FUCK!”
“Atta girl!” Alex cheered enthusiastically.
“Fuck-fuck-fuck-fuck-FUCK!”
“That’s everything,” I grunted, feeling my pelvis press all the way up against my baby sister’s buttcheeks.
“Fuckity FUCK!” Michelle exclaimed once more. “Holy SHIT you’re big!”
“How does it feel?”
“I don’t fucking know! It’s just so ... so...”
“Full?”
“YES!”
“Like losing your virginity again?”
“YES!”
“Feeling the man you love more than anyone in the whole world buried deep inside a part of your body you’ve never felt touched before?”
“YES!”
“Yeah...” Alex sighed dreamily. “That’s exactly what it feels like when he does it to me, too.”
“Get in fucking line, sister.”
Alex laughed and leaned over to peck Michelle on the lips. “What, you don’t want him to pull out immediately, leave you the fuck alone, and swear on Grandma’s life that he will never put that baseball bat anywhere near your asshole again? Because if you want him to do that right now, I’ve got a teeny-tight asshole that would really love to feel all that right now.”
“Wait your fucking turn!” Michelle wheezed. “Holy SHIT this hurts.”
“But doesn’t it hurt so good?”
“Fucking A it does...” Michelle closed her eyes, took a deep breath (or three), and concentrated on the feelings. When she opened them again, she was able to focus on me, and she reached up to caress my cheek once more, mumbling softly, “Hey there...”
I smiled and held her hand to my cheek. “Hey, Chelle ... You alright?”
She closed her eyes and nodded slowly. After taking another deep breath, she murmured, “You can start moving now.”
Relocating both hands to Michelle’s hips, I slowly withdrew a few inches and then just as slowly pushed back inside. She gasped and tensed up, but managed to relax herself a moment later, keeping her eyes closed as she concentrated on the feelings. She started to smile.
“It’s good, isn’t it?” Alex asked, observing Michelle’s expression as well.
“Mmm-hmm ... It’s so weird. It still hurts, but it’s...”
“It hurts so good.”
“Nnghh ... Yeah...”
Michelle’s anal chute clamped down on me less and less, so I started to pick up speed. I was also now moving about six inches in and out, bottoming out with each thrust but not pulling all the way back.
“Fuck ... fuck ... fuck...” Michelle groaned with furrowed eyebrows and clenched eyes. She tossed her head back and started lolling it from side to side. “Fuuuuuck meeee. Ohmigawd. Fuck my ass, big brother. Fuck my ass...”
“Ungh, ungh, ungh,” I grunted with every thrust. “You’re so tight.”
“You like that, huh?” Michelle moaned. “You like fucking your baby sister’s teenaged asshole? You like violating my virgin body?”
“Fucking A, Chelle...” I groaned, slamming myself all the way in and holding it there for a minute.
She laughed, which carried vibrations throughout her whole body, including her anal muscles. “You’re so fucking deep inside of me. It feels like you’re touching my very core.”
Leaning forward, I bent her long, lithe body beneath mine. I didn’t quite fold her in half, but we were getting there. And digging my toes into the mattress, I started to really pump her harder.
I’m fucking my little sister’s ass.
I’m fucking my little sister’s ass.