"Of course, sir," Aitken agreed and Ramage watched the polite smile on the Scotsman's face. "But sir," Aitken asked politely, "what part of my answer - or, rather, partial answer - did you find so provoking?"
With Aitken's accent the word "provoking" had a soothing quality, long drawn out, and Goddard's eyes rose to the deckhead as though seeking Divine help.
He was just going to answer when he saw the trap: if he said that he objected to the phrase "another broadside" he would - damnation, he thought: this young puppy Ramage must have spent hours with his officers guessing what Captain Shirley's questions would be and perfecting these double-edged answers. Goddard knew he had been very near the limit of his powers as court president yesterday, and he had arrested that other lieutenant for contempt of court because it seemed the only way of shutting him up. The charge would not hold, of course, and all that he intended was to keep the fellow locked up out of the way until after the verdict on Ramage was given. But two lieutenants cited for contempt in the same trial (in succession, too) would raise eyebrows at the Admiralty and draw attention to what he was trying to do.
All right, what is the answer to this impudent young puppy's apparently innocent question? Damnation, this cabin is so hot. Ah yes: this should hide the fact that he had not thought of an answer to the question.
"Lieutenant Aitken, let me remind you of this. The prisoner is accused of -"
Now this damned fool Swinford is whispering something. He had always considered Swinford as a reliable sort of man but, Goddard thought, he seemed to be adopting a very radical attitude in this trial.
Goddard nodded impatiently at Swinford and modified his second sentence. "Yes, as Captain Swinford points out, the prisoner is accused by Captain Shirley of removing him from his lawful command of the Jason, and he is charged under six of the Articles of War . . . numbers fifteen, seventeen, nineteen, twenty, twenty-two and twenty-three."
He gestured to Jenkins and told him to bring up a copy of the Articles of War.
He opened the black leatherbound volume with the bold gilt lettering on the front cover. "Let me just remind you. Number fifteen, the first in the charge, refers to 'Every person in or belonging to the Fleet' who shall desert (which does not apply here) or, and I emphasize that word, 'or run away with any of His Majesty's ships or vessels of war, in any ordnance, ammunition, stores or provision belonging thereto' ..."
He tapped the small book. "I think you can see why the Board of Admiralty ordered that Captain Ramage should be tried under that Article. Let us consider the next one, seventeen. I will just quote the relevant parts, as it is long: 'The officers and seamen of all ships, appointed for convoy and guard of merchant ships, or any other, shall diligently attend upon that charge . . . and whosoever shall be faulty therein . . . and submitting the ships in their convoy to peril and hazard. . .' and so on and so forth . . ."
"Increasing our escort by one more frigate can hardly be hazarding it, sir," Aitken said sourly but, Ramage guessed, by adopting a guileless manner, deliberately trying to provoke Goddard.
"Damnation, Aitken, don't you understand what a court-martial is all about?"
"I thought I did, sir," Aitken said, his accent becoming heavier. "I thought I did - until now."
He is trying to provoke me, Goddard told himself, and stabbed his finger down on the Articles of War.
"Listen carefully, now: the nineteenth Article . . . 'If any person in or belonging to the Fleet shall make, or endeavour to make, any mutinous assembly ... he shall suffer death . . .' and, in the same Article, '. . . shall utter any words of sedition or mutiny, he shall suffer death . . .'"
Now the pair of you, Goddard thought grimly, can have a taste of your own medicine. "Might I remind you, Mr Aitken, that plotting against a superior officer, removing him from his command, or even talking of doing so, is a breach of that Article, and no one is disputing that Captain Shirley was the superior of all the officers in the King's service in that convoy."
And that, you impudent Scot, Goddard thought, reminds you that you are as guilty as your blasted commanding officer: you helped him and if you were brought to trial and found guilty (as you surely would) the noose would go round your neck too.
"Aye, sir," Aitken said, "but there's a phrase in that Article you didn't read, though - about 'such superior officer being in the execution of his office'. Captain Shirley had no 'office' connected with the convoy."
"Don't be impudent," Goddard snapped. "He was the superior officer by virtue of his seniority in the Navy List, and that's all that matters." And before Aitken had time to argue that point Goddard said triumphantly: "Now we come to Article twenty - if any person in the Fleet shall conceal any traiterous or mutinous practice or design ... he shall suffer death.' Later the same Article refers to concealing 'words, traiterous or mutinous, spoken to the prejudice of His Majesty or tending to the hindrance of the service . . .'"
Goddard noted to himself that the whippersnapper had no answer to that and hurriedly went on to the next Article.
"Article twenty-two says that if any officer, mariner, soldier or other person in the Fleet, shall strike any of his superior officers, or draw, or offer to draw, or lift up any weapon against him . . .' then if found guilty that person shall be sentenced to death, and of course the same article deals with anyone disobeying lawful commands."
Goddard could not resist turning round and wagging an admonitory finger. "Mr Aitken, firing a gun comes in the same category as 'lift up any weapon', of course."
"Of course," agreed Aitken, "but in this case the senior officer, fired a broadside at thejunior one."
Goddard was quick to realize that, having no answer to the slip of his own tongue, it was best to ignore the remark and trust that Jenkins was not putting it in the minutes.
"Now, Mr Aitken, we come to the final Article to the charge, number twenty-three, which says that 'If any person in the Fleet shall quarrel or fight with any other person in the Fleet, or use reproachful or provoking speeches or gestures . . .' and so on."
"Thank you for reading them, sir. Of course I know them by heart but it must be very helpful to yourself as the president to be reminded of the precise wording."
Goddard, brought up in the old school where you were polite and considerate to your superiors, particularly if your promotion depended on them, shut the book with a snap and signalled to Jenkins to carry on with the questioning. In the meantime this wretched fellow Aitken's question about that phrase "another broadside" had been forgotten: he had guessed that nothing would smother it as successfully as reading from the Articles of War.
Then, to Goddard's horror, Jenkins, instead of going on to the next question, repeated the previous one about Aitken's role when the Calypso boarded the Jason, but the deputy judge advocate looked up in time to see Goddard's glare and tried to recover the situation, saying to Aitken: "You have already told the court how Captain Ramage had laid the Calypso alongside the Jason. Go on from that point."
"I led a particular boarding party and climbed over at about the mainchains."
"How were you armed?"
"Cutlass and pistol."
"And Captain Ramage?"
"If you mean 'how was he armed?', I think a cutlass and pistol - little enough when you think we'd just received a broadside."
Ramage almost laughed at the way that Aitken's quiet voice with its Highland lilt had lulled Goddard so that he could make what sounded as though it was going to be an innocent remark in fact be lethal. Lethal, Ramage amended, in a proper trial, but not in this travesty.