“There’s a cover letter from someone named Kevin Quinn.”
“That’s Michael’s brother.”
Matt scanned the letter. “Kevin says he hacked into the computers of his old employer and got this evidence of product fraud.”
“Old employer? Michael never mentioned his brother worked at Fairfield!” But then I remembered. He didn’t — not anymore. Kevin lost his job in New York and was forced to relocate to Boston.
I read the rest of Kevin’s long letter side by side with Matt.
“Jesus,” Matt said. “Someone at that company replaced the central titanium core with metal that has all the durability of a cheap furniture rod.”
“It was done for profit.” I pointed to the end of the letter. “The move cut production costs in half but left the roof spike with a fatal flaw. It couldn’t stand up to the high levels of heat the original prototype had been tested under.”
“Why would the FDNY approve it?”
“They wouldn’t,” I said. “I’m sure all the testing and training was done on roof spikes that had been manufactured correctly... Oh, Matt, that’s what James meant when he said Bigsby Brewer was murdered. When Glenn Duffy and Jason Wren set that final coffeehouse fire, Bigsby was forced to use the roof spike to escape the flames. But the tool failed because someone at Fairfield changed the manufacturing specs.”
“Yeah, but who?” Matt asked.
We looked over the papers again. Kevin didn’t give any names.
I thought it over. “Do you remember when I found that House of Fen glove in the puddle outside of Captain Michael’s apartment?”
Matt nodded.
“I think it was Josephine Fairfield’s glove. When her husband died last year, she took over the company. I’ll bet she changed the specs on the roof spike and found out the captain was investigating the fraud. Then she paid him a private little visit.”
“Yeah.” Matt nodded. “Sounds like a strong possibility.”
“There’s only one problem,” I said, pointing to Kevin’s documents. “Would a society wife be smart enough to do all this on her own?”
“None that I’ve ever met,” Matt said. “Someone must have helped her.”
I considered Oat Crowley or some other member of the FDNY. But it seemed to me the man most likely to help Josephine Fairfield execute this awful scheme was —
“Ryan Lane.”
“Who?” Matt asked.
“Ryan works for Mrs. Fairfield,” I explained. “He hustled her out of the pub last night when she got drunk and loud. Ryan also talked to me about retiring soon, about giving Oat Crowley his job. And he said Fairfield Equipment was on the verge of a big corporate buyout.”
Matt rubbed his chin. “Cutting costs on the roof spike would definitely up the company’s profits, make the operation look more valuable to a prospective buyer.”
“I’ll bet Lane’s an officer of the company, in a position to make big money from the sale — except time ran out for him and Josie.”
“What do you mean?”
“That buyout isn’t final yet,” I said. “So I’m guessing he and Josie simply played the odds. The roof spike worked in most situations. They took a chance there wouldn’t be any catastrophic failures before they sold the company. But there was — Bigsby Brewer lost his life.”
“They must know there’s going to be an investigation, right?”
“Yes, but typically something like that will take weeks, maybe even months. James Noonan got suspicious right away and started making waves. He went to the captain, and they bypassed the usual time-consuming bureaucratic process. Michael Quinn used his little brother Kevin to cut to the truth. Ryan and Josie must have found out about it, assaulted Michael, and murdered James — that would buy them enough time to make a clean getaway before the truth comes out.”
“But, Clare, does Josephine Fairfield even know James Noonan?”
“Ryan Lane does. He spoke to James at the bake sale, and I saw Lane talking to Oat Crowley, too. I’ll bet Oat blabbed the whole thing about James’s suspicions and the captain’s investigation. Lane could have approached James after that, told him he wanted to talk. He could have gone to James’s house last night under the pretense of coming clean about the roof spike — but instead Lane killed him.”
“Killed him how? You said the police believe Noonan’s death was a suicide.”
I considered the possibilities, thought again about that glass of untouched beer on James’s kitchen table, the Harp that Ryan had enjoyed at the pub. That’s when I knew: “James didn’t pour that beer for himself! He poured it for his killer!”
“What?”
“James hated beer. I’m sure he poured it for Ryan Lane — and Lane must have found a way to slip a drug into James’s wineglass, which he would have taken with him to eliminate any evidence. That would explain the single beer on the table. If Lane was careful not to touch the glass, it would only have James’s fingerprints on it. Then James passes out, Ryan hauls him to the garage and stages his suicide. Afterward, he meets up with Josie on her post-bake sale rounds and makes an appearance at Saints and Sinners to establish an alibi.”
Matt frowned. “I don’t know, Clare, that scenario’s a little out there, don’t you think? And it’s not very smart. Wouldn’t a drug be detected in Noonan’s autopsy?”
“So what if it was? As long as the cause of death matches the manner of suicide, what difference does it make if James had a drug in his system? The case for murder is pretty thin with Val confirming her husband’s depression — not to mention that suicide note.” I shook my head. “The scenario I described isn’t out there. It’s ingenious.”
“But what if Ryan Lane isn’t the one who helped this Fairfield woman?”
“Well, if he didn’t, then I’m sure he won’t have any trouble telling a grand jury who did.”
Matt thought it over. “Okay, let’s do something about this. Get on the phone. Call — ”
I heard a meaty smack. Matt’s body went limp and fell against me. I stumbled, caught myself, but couldn’t stop my ex’s heavy form from sagging to the floor.
“Matt!”
“Shut up or I’ll hit you, too.”
One end of a Halligan tool now loomed in front of my face. I saw dried blood on it, pieces of hair. The other end of that gruesome object was in Ryan Lane’s right hand. His left was pointing a gun at me.
I lifted my gaze, met his stare.
Ryan tossed the fireman’s tool on the table and threw a bundle of rope at me. “Tie him up.”
Thirty-Eight
“He’s bleeding,” I said. “He needs a doctor!”
Ryan aimed the gun at Matt’s head. “He’ll be dead if you don’t tie him up. Anyway, I didn’t whack him nearly as hard as I hit the captain.”
I bit back a curse and began to tie the rope — loosely. Ryan caught me. “Tighter, honey. If he gets free before I leave, he’s dead. And so are you.”
“You’re going to kill us anyway.”
“Not at all!” Ryan’s deceptively boyish face lit up with a grin. “I just want you indisposed while Josie and I get out of the country. After we’re gone, I don’t care what happens to you.”
Ryan sniffed the air. “Mmm... coffee. The aroma is magnificent down here” — he took a deep breath — “gives me a jones, you know?”
“Let’s go upstairs. I’ll pull you a fresh espresso.”
Ryan wiggled his gun like a naughty finger. “Nice try, Ms. Cosi, but I’m going to have to wait until I get to Williamsburg. There’s a great little all night spot off the bridge. Then I’ll pick up Josephine, who thinks we’re going on a short business trip, and we’re off on a private jet to... well, as long as Josie’s with me, it’ll be paradise...”
That’s when I knew. “Josephine Fairfield isn’t involved in any of this, is she?”
“No. She isn’t.”
“Then why did I find her glove outside of Michael Quinn’s apartment? Did she go there last night to throw herself at him?”
“No. After we left the pub and Josie passed out in her limo, I grabbed her glove and planted it there.”
“Why?”