El Rojo looked up toward the Saint.
“And the señor,” he said, “is he the fortunate man with whom you fell in love?”
“No. He is in Mexico City. He is in the government service, and he could not leave to come with me.”
“He is rich, this man?”
“Yes,” she said, and her voice was no longer cold.
There was silence for a long time — for so long that the dancing firelight died down to a steady red glow.
Teresa Alvarez gazed into the dull embers, with her arms clasped around her knees, absorbed in her own thoughts, and at last she said, “But I have only been dreaming. Even in such a small territory as this, why should anyone remember one man who was here two years ago?”
El Rojo stirred himself a little.
“Was your husband,” he said, “a man of middle height, with smooth black hair and greenish eyes and a thin black mustache?”
Suddenly she was still, with a stillness that seemed more violent than movement.
“Yes,” she said. “He was like that.”
“And his name was Alvarez?”
“Yes. Gaspar Alvarez de Quevedo.”
Her voice was no more than a whisper.
The bandit drew a gust of evil-smelling smoke from his cheap cigarette.
“Such a man was a guest of mine about two years ago,” he said slowly. “I remember him best because of the ring, which I gave to a girl in Matamoros, and because he was the only guest I have had here who left without my consent.”
“He escaped?”
The words came from the girl’s lips with a weariness that was too deep for feeling.
“He tried to,” said El Rojo. “But it was very dark, and these mountains are not friendly to those who do not know them well.”
He stretched out his arm, toward the black emptiness beyond the rock wall that guarded the niche where they sat.
“I buried him where he fell. It was difficult to reach him, but I could not risk his body being seen by any goatherds going up the valley. In the morning, if you like, I will point you out his grave. It is below the path we followed to come here — more than a hundred meters down... The señora may go on without fear to the happiness that life has kept waiting for her.”
It was very dark, but Simon could see the tears rise in the girl’s eyes before she hid her face in her hands.
The morning sun was cutting hot swaths through the fading mist when El Rojo followed the Saint and Teresa along the winding ledge between cliff and cliff that led out of his eyrie high above the river. Where the slope of the mountain opened clear before them he called to them to stop, and held the bridle of the horse which the girl was to ride while she climbed into the saddle.
“I give you — buen viaje,” he said. “You can make no mistake. Follow the side of the hill until you come to a belt of trees, and then go downwards. To find your way back here — that is another matter. But if you keep going downwards you must come to the river, and on the other side of the river is the road to La Quinta. I will meet you somewhere on that road in three days from now, at about four o’clock in the afternoon.”
“I can never thank you,” she said.
“You have no need to,” he answered roughly. “You are going to bring me — how much did we agree? — one hundred thousand pesos, and the señor remains as my guest as a surety for our meeting. I regret that I have to be commercial, but one must live, and if your lover is rich he will not mind.” She held out her hand to the Saint.
“I shall be there to meet him in three days,” she said. “And then I shall be able to thank you again.”
“This was nothing,” he answered with his lazy smile. “But if you ever meet any dragons I wish you’d send for me.”
He kissed her fingers, and watched her ride away until the curve of the hill hid her from sight. It was true that he had done very little, but he had seen the light in her eyes before she went, and to him that was reward enough for any adventure.
He was thoughtful as he walked back along the cliff edge track towards the bandit’s cave with El Rojo just behind his elbow, and when they were halfway along it he said casually, “By the way, I ought to warn you that the parole I renewed last night is just running out.”
The muzzle of the bandit’s rifle pressed into his chest as he turned.
“In that case señor, you will please put up your hands. Unless, of course, you prefer to renew your parole again.” Simon raised his hands to the level of his shoulders. “My friend,” he said, “have you forgotten the Arroyo Verde?”
“Perdone?”
“The Arroyo Verde,” said the Saint steadily. “Between San Miguel and Gajo. Where there was a man with a sprained ankle who had been there for three days without food, and who might have stayed there until he starved if a brigand with a price on his head had not stayed to help him.”
“I have not the least idea what you are talking about.”
“I thought not,” said the Saint softly. “Because you weren’t there.”
He saw the bandit’s hands go rigid around the gun, and the blue steel was as sharp as knife points in his eyes.
“I didn’t think this brigand would have forgotten me so completely that we could spend an evening together without him recognizing me. You see, we got quite friendly down in that forsaken canyon, and when my ankle was better I paid him a visit here. That’s why I was able to find my way so easily yesterday. I came to Durango because I hoped to meet him again. And yet this brigand’s name was El Rojo, too. How do you explain that — Señor Alvarez?”
For a moment the bandit was silent, standing tense and still, and Simon could feel the shattering chaos whirling through the man’s mind, the wild spin of instinctive stratagems and lies sinking down to the grim realization of their ultimate futility.
“And suppose I am Alvarez?” said the man at last, and his natural voice was quite different from the way he had been speaking before.
“Then you should tell me more about what you said last night — and about El Rojo. Where is he?”
“I found him here by accident, but he thought I was looking for him. We fought, and he fell over the precipice. He lies in the grave which I said was mine.”
“And because you wanted to disappear, and because you loved the mountains, you thought that the best way for you to hide would be to take his place. No one had ever seen the face of El Rojo, no one ever knew who he was. You took his mask and became El Rojo.”
“Eso es.”
Alvarez had not moved. Simon could sense the taut nerves of a man who held death in his hands and was only waiting for one word to turn the scale of his decision.
Simon Templar was also waiting for the answer to one question. He said, “And last night?”
“A usted que más le da?”
“The answer is in your hands,” said the Saint.
His eyes were as clear and unclouded as the sky over their heads, and there was something as ageless and unchangeable as justice in the even tones of his voice.
“Perhaps in these two years you might have changed,” he said. “Perhaps you were glad that you could never go back to the old life. And perhaps you told that lie to cut the last link with it, and you were glad to set your wife free for the happiness which you never gave her. If that was so, your secret will always be safe with me. But I’ve never seen a man like you change very much, and I wondered why all you asked about your wife’s lover was whether he was rich. I wondered if it had occurred to you that if you let her believe you were dead, so that she would marry this man, you could go back to Mexico City and charge a price for your silence. And if that was so—”