"Reddition?" came a defiant shout at the end of that. "Jamais!"
"Zey do not believe us, Capitaine. He say, we are all blancs, French or British, it is no matter. Zey die before zey surrender."
"Do they have powder aboard, like the others, sir…" Langlie cautioned.
"Mister Wyman? You may open upon the lugger," Lewrie ordered. "One broadside only… from the main battery guns. Damn the fools!"
"As you bear… on the up-roll… fire!"
Proteus roared and shook, flinging defiance for defiance, and a new chorus of screams erupted as the lugger was shredded at such short range. As the smoke of the broadside drifted down alee and past that lugger, she was revealed as a total wreck. Her mast was gone, and the jury-rig up forrud was wiped away, along with the men who had tended it. The lugger's starboard side was shot through like a colander and she heeled with her rails awash to the sea. Of her crew…
There might have been fifty or sixty men crammed aboard, before that broadside. Now her decks were piled with offal, with the dying and dead wallowing in their own life's blood, in a coiling mass of entrails and body parts! There were some in the water, splashing about and trying to swim or grab some flotsam on which to gasp and keen.
"Now we'll close-her," Lewrie snapped, "before she goes under. Mister Wyman, a boarding party to search her for papers, anything. Mister Langlie, lower a boat for Mister Wyman's party."
"Aye, sir," Langlie parroted, though not sounding happy.
"Fetch to, sir. Stand down the larboard battery, but keep the swivels and six-pounders manned. About a cable's distance, hmmm?"
Lieutenant Wyman's boat had barely reached the stricken lugger, he'd barely had time for a very quick snatch-and-grab from her decks, before she slipped under in a welter of bubbles and foam, and sank, forcing those few members of the boarding party who'd gained her rivened deck to scramble for their lives. As she rolled over and sank stern-first, Lewrie could see that the lugger had been big enough for a coach-top and some accommodations below her main deck, with a canvas spread over a cargo hatch between the stumps of her masts. Lieutenant Wyman waved, then smiled, showing that everyone in his boat was uninjured and returning safely. Wyman steered well clear of the Blacks swimming near his boat, though, with some of his hands levelling their muskets or pistols at the bobbing heads.
"Ho, here's one, sir!" Able Seaman Inman cried from the entry-port, pointing down over the starboard side, which was now alee of the winds. Lewrie peered over to see the muscular, mahoghany-skinned man in the water below the boarding-battens and man-ropes, treading water and bleeding from the mouth, and a scalp wound upon his shaven pate. In the water, his skin was as shiny as a seal pelt.
"Don't got a fuse and powder keg wif 'im, does 'e?" Yeoman of the Powder Foster cracked.
"Mister Devereux, have your Marines fetch him here. He might talk to us," Lewrie decided. "I'll have more need of your services, Mister Durant. Now we've gotten this'un into a more amenable mood." From Lewrie's vantage point high above, the man did seem shattered, a pathetic, pleading half-grin on his features. He even raised his hands upwards in supplication.
Inman waved him up, leaning out the entry-port. "Come on, you son of a whore. Up ye get. Come on, we won't eat ye! Safe, see?"
The man nodded, querying, as if he could not believe his luck, pointing to his chest as if to say "Who, me?" before thrusting upward from the water and grabbing the lowermost wooden batten in one hand, then a man-rope in the other, slithering and scraping along the barnacles at the waterline, wincing with the pain, but scaling the side as Proteus rolled and wallowed, the boarding-battens first vertical, then easier to climb.
"That's th' way, mate, up ye get. There'll be a cup o' grog in yer gullet in no time, laddy," Inman encouraged, reaching down as the man got near the lip of the entry-port.
' 'Ware! 'Ware!" Lt. Wyman shouted from the boat as it neared, a pistol in his hand, awkwardly dragged from his waist belt. "Knife!"
"Canga! Heu!" the survivor screamed, whipping out a long cane knife secreted in the back of his ragged trousers, and slicing Inman's throat almost to the spine with a single backward slash!
Wyman's pistol barked and the Black stiffened, back arched and blood spouting from his mouth as he was lung-shot, before letting go and falling back into the sea with a large splash… followed not a moment later by Inman's body, that fell into the same target of roiled water! Fresh-killed, their lungs still full of air, after a deep, dead plunge they both wafted to the surface, almost arm-in-arm.
"God Almighty damn!" Lewrie breathed, shuddery and faint from surprise and shock. "Get him aboard, get Inman back aboard, now!"
"No use, Capitaine," Mr. Durant sadly said. "What ze noir did to him…" Durant sucked his teeth and shook his head.
"I don't give a damn, I won't have him in the water with that treacherous, murderin' bastard!" Lewrie raved.
Sheets and halliards and braces were flung overside, safely belayed about the pin-rails, and a dozen hands sprang down to the chain platforms with quickly fashioned loops of line to snag Inman and bring him alongside, then coil them about his body and haul him back up to where others could take hold of his arms and lay him out on the gangway.
Lewrie went forward, his head like to burst with rage, but his feet as benumbed as if he were walking on pillows, until he stood over the body, removing his hat in reverence, as the people parted and made way. My fault, my fault, my bloody goddamned fault! he thought, full of hate for himself. Inman leaked a great puddle of water from soggy slop-clothing, leaked from that huge, ghastly rent in his throat…
"My fault," he croaked, having to swallow hard and cough before he could talk further. "Wanted prisoners… information! Damn 'em! Should've known… my fault."
"Nossir, couldn't a known!" Bosun Pendarves countered, raising an agreeing chorus from the hands nearby.
"Savages!" someone else spat. "Ya can't show mercy, 'coz they don't know what it is!"
"Ain't Christians, like us'uns," another growled.
"They sunk us wif 'at powder, they'da slit our throats, quick enough," Mr. Neale, the Master-At-Arms supposed aloud. "Let's kill 'em all, all that still tread water!"
"No!" Lewrie shouted. "We'll leave 'em. Let 'em sink, swim, or be taken by sharks, as God wills. 'Twas my fault that Inman died, our only casualty. We'll give him a proper shipmate's burial tonight, at sunset. And I'll not have his welcome to Heaven ruined by more murder."
"Amen, sor," Landsman Furfy said, teary-eyed and sniffling, hat in hand and leaning on his mate, the leaner and shorter Liam Desmond.
"We know the rules, now," Lewrie announced, close to tears himself, irritably dashing at his eyes with a coat sleeve. "We know how they mean to fight… and how much they hate us. We… I'll not be mistaken the next time. Next time, we'll stand off and shoot 'em to kindling. Survivors, bedamned!"
That elicited a guttural growl of agreement.
"Mister Durant, sir… would you and Mister Shirley be so good as to prepare Able Seaman Inman for burial?"
"But of course, Capitaine. We will see to him," Durant vowed. "Wiz as much tender care as his own mother. Men? Assist me, please?"
Lewrie turned and stalked aft to the quarterdeck, cramming his hat back on any-old-how, and slamming his fists together, his rage no longer quite so aflame, but still scouring himself for a fool.
"Er, Captain Lewrie, sir?" Lieutenant Wyman called, scampering after him. "Excuse me, sir, but… thought you should see this. Sorry if I shot too late, sir. Never killed a man before, not… up close? Artillery, aye, but never with a pistol. Tried to warn him, I…"