James Lasdun
Seven Lies
© 2005
Every lie must beget seven more lies if
it is to resemble the truth and adopt truth’s aura.
– MARTIN LUTHER
September 14
A woman threw her glass of wine at me. It happened at Gloria Danilov’s party at the Temple of Dendur. I didn’t know the woman – hadn’t spoken to her or even noticed her. Gloria had just introduced me to Harold Gedney, who detached himself from me almost as soon as Gloria left us. A moment later this woman steps up: ‘Excuse me, are you Stefan Vogel?’ ‘Yes,’ I say, and without hesitation she flings her wine in my face. Red wine: a great spatter of it all over my chin and neck and white shirt. She walks away swiftly but calmly, no one stopping her, and from the stunned way people look at me I can tell the assumption is that I must have said or done something disgraceful.
I got out of the place as quickly as I could, not looking for my attacker, just wanting to remove myself from the situation, and walked all the way to the Port Authority.
‘Excuse me, are you Stefan Vogel?’ ‘Yes.’ Splash!
The sheer reflexive speed of it. The strange naturalness this gave the gesture, as if it were simply an inevitability, a law of physics, that the acknowledging of my name should trigger a little violent deluge of red wine.
I sat at the back of the bus, a pariah; marinading in the clammy wetness. I was shaken, but almost more than that I was furious with myself for having come down to the party in the first place, against my own better judgement. And then, beyond both the shakenness and the anger, this déjà vu feeling I get in any crisis: that the attack only happened now in the most illusory sense; that in reality it happened a thousand years ago, and was therefore nothing new.
The lights were on when I got home. I took my stained shirt off in the car – didn’t want Inge to see it – and put my jacket on over my bare chest, buttoning my coat up over that. Bundled the shirt behind a cupboard in the garage. Inge was downstairs with Lena, reading by the woodstove. She gave me her glazed smile.
‘How was it?’
‘Fine,’ I tell her, ‘lots of caviar.’
She keeps her eyes on me, trying – I sense – to resist the pull of her book. But if she has noticed I am home early, she doesn’t mention it, and if she finds it odd that I am standing in the over-heated living room with my coat buttoned up to my Adam’s apple, she doesn’t, as I had predicted, want to get into a conversation about it.
After a moment she stretches and yawns:
‘I think I’ll go to bed.’
‘OK.’
Another helpless smile, then off she goes up the little wooden staircase, Lena shuffling loyally along behind her, tail up like a bedraggled ostrich plume.
I came here into the spare room. Saw this jotting pad on the shelf – a spiral-bound notebook. The sight stalled me. I had a sudden, overwhelming desire to break my own rule of committing nothing to paper.
Some divination, maybe, that I no longer have anything to lose? Some notion of what cataclysmic event must have occurred elsewhere in the cosmos in order for a woman to have thrown her wine in my face at a party in New York?
September 15
Walked up to the quarry. Purple starry flowers blooming over the ditches all the way up Vanderbeck Hollow. Maples and oaks still in their summer foliage, moving through the day like galleons in full sail. Though if you look closely the sails are getting tattered now, pocked and torn in places; nibbled by insects, the holes browning at their edges. Fall on its way.
Are you Stefan Vogel? Yes. Splash!
This desire to exorcise the past. Not only the remote or middle past (though that too), but last week, yesterday, just now…
RUSTLE OF newspaper from the study above me, the snip-snip of scissor blades: Inge working on her clippings. I picture her up there, pasting the heavy tidings of another week into one of the tombstone-sized albums she has been steadily collating over the years. As always, the image comes at me with the force of reproach; all the more painful for being unintended, or not consciously intended.
Snip-snip, snip-snip…
My undiminished love for her. Something in it verging on the idolatrous, as though for some higher creature that has come unaccountably into my possession. (Exactly how I feel about life itself, I realise: that it has come unaccountably into my possession, somewhat to its own dismay.)
September 17
A phrase of my parents’ comes to mind, one that was forever on their lips or Uncle Heinrich’s back in Berlin: Nachteil kriegen: to receive disadvantage.
Was that why I went down to Gloria’s party, so as not to ‘receive disadvantage’?
How in Berlin one was always in dread of not sufficiently abasing oneself towards some superior, and thereby ‘receiving disadvantage’. Not that Gloria would have cared less or even noticed if I hadn’t shown up. So perhaps more a sense of missing out on possible advantage? A reflex of my inveterate opportunism? Though what ‘advantage’ could have come my way at this late date, I cannot imagine.
Or perhaps I was looking for precisely what I found?
Are you Stefan Vogel? Yes. Splash!
Certainly I was apprehensive. Even debated whether to retreat as I came to the entrance of the party. I scanned the crowd milling among the Egyptian ruins. There were some familiar faces from our old New York days: the Chinese historian; that Czech couple we had dinner with fifteen years ago at their NYU apartment; the macho Cuban playwright who told Inge he’d written a part for her in his new play; one or two others – the remnant of Gloria’s old retinue of dissident émigrés and exiles, sprinkled, as always, among her bankers and politicians. To the extent that any of them recognised me, they seemed friendly enough. Taking this to be an encouraging sign, I stepped into the fray, seizing a glass of champagne from one passing waiter and a black alp of caviar from another.
‘Stefan!’
Gloria sees me from behind a pillar and sails over. Both arms extended, her large old head tipped back in mock reproach, she takes my hands in hers, grasping them warmly.
‘How kind of you to come! And where is your beautiful wife?’
‘I’m afraid she couldn’t make it.’
‘Ah. What a shame. Give her my fondest regards. How lovely to see you! How long has it been? Must be five years at least!’
I nod vaguely, not wanting to discompose her with the fact that it has actually been more than ten since we fled New York and closer to fifteen since I picked up my last honorarium from the offices of the little Cold War quarterly she financed back in those days.
‘Now you’re living where, exactly?’ Gloria asks.
‘Aurelia. Up in the mountains.’
‘I suppose you must love it.’
She looks at me with her kindly, guileless eyes. Her way of seeming only to acknowledge what is loftiest in one’s nature, disregarding the rest, so that one feels gathered up for a moment, handed back to oneself in the form of a bouquet made exclusively of one’s virtues and dreams and potentialities.
‘Dear Stefan.’ She gives my hand a little pat. ‘Now, to whom shall I introduce you?’
The hostess must move on. But I don’t think it’s insincere, this warmth of hers. She must have kept literally dozens of us on the payroll of The Open Mind. Pure charity. A fervent anti-communist, but utterly democratic in her social instincts, as demonstrated by her choice of who – whom – to hand me off to:
‘Hig!’
With a decisive movement she leads me towards a man standing at the side of a cluster of elderly matrons. I recognise him immediately as Harold Gedney.