Eleven
****
Firsts
Jai
The garage door rolls to a close behind us. I twist the key in the ignition, shutting down the car, and drop my head against the steering wheel with a heavy sigh. I feel like shit—I feel worse than shit. I’ve gone to extreme lengths to save Joel. I’ve built my adult life around him…only to abandon him. Was it foolish of me to believe he’d be the same person I grew up with? Surely I had to know things would be different…
Emily and Huss simultaneously unclip their seat belts, but Emily stays put as Huss opens his door and slams it shut behind him, leaving Emily and I alone.
Good.
I want to be with her. Alone.
I lift my head and watch as Huss accesses the house through the white door in the far left corner of the garage and disappears. I watched him on and off on the car ride home. He’ll never admit it, but he’s shaken up. The way he'd grind his teeth and swallow harshly...nervousness is hitting him hard. I'm nervous too. We're doing this thing tomorrow and we still don't know the fucking plan.
“It was never supposed to be this complicated.” I sigh, falling back against my seat.
I look at Emily and I can’t stand it. I can’t stand the glow of sympathy in her eyes, mixed with harsh judgement and something else—something intense.
“Do you think I’ve made a mistake?”
“Making them walk?”
I nod.
“No.” She utters, avoiding my eyes.
She’s lying, but I’m thankful for it. I don’t think I can stomach her disappointment on top of my own.
“I think your decision was justified.”
Justified? Hardly. I shift my hands to the base of the steering wheel and pick at a swallow crack in the leather.
“If you were me...would you have left them?”
Emily lifts her eyes to mine. “No.”
“Why?”
“Because I wouldn’t be able to handle the guilt if something happened to them.”
I close my eyes. If something happens to them...what have I done? No. I will not guilt myself into going back for them. Yes, the possibility of something happening to them is higher than I’d like...but they left me with no choice.
“I can’t go back for them.” I slam my palms against the steering wheel. “They need to know who’s in charge here. I run the goddamn show—not Ted, not Joel—me.”
She reaches out with her slender hand and glides her palm up my bicep. “I know.”
The look of terror on her face when Joker had his gun in Joel's face plays in my head over and over. I couldn’t defend her or protect her. I was fucking useless and I never want to be in that position again. I need her too much.
“All of those bikers...all of those guns...I couldn’t do anything. If only I had known, I would have left you here.”
“But you didn’t know and we’re home safe and sound so don’t dwell on it, Jai. You’ll only make yourself sick.”
Our eyes lock and a million and one emotions vibrate through me. Tomorrow is the end in one way or another. Either I make it back alive, freeing me to spend the rest of my life trying to woo Kitten into loving me, or I won’t make it back at all. The thought of her on her own, scraping by to make ends meet, or snatched from her bed my Skull...I can't. Panic swirls, growing in mass by the second. What about the shit the old man said about her? What if he can “feel” her future like he claims? If she’s in unbearable pain and Joel is somehow involved...maybe Monique and I die, leaving Joel and Kitten to keep each other company.
Sharp points of jealousy stab my stomach and fuel my panic.
I shut my eyes and focus on the touch of her palm on my bicep. For now, it’s enough to hold off the impending panic attack.
“I had that dream again last night.” I mutter, changing the subject, doing anything I can to stop torturing myself with possibilities of our stark future.
“The one where I wear the red dress?”
“Mm.” I nod, smiling slightly. “You look amazing in that red dress. It’s a wonder we even make it to dinner.”
She laughs as I open my eyes and it’s a beautiful sound—girly and sweet. “I’ve been meaning to ask you about that. In your dream you said I fall madly in love with you after dinner.”
I nod.
“When do you fall madly in love with me? During dessert?”
“That’s funny.”
I chuckle, then pause. How doesn’t she know? After everything we’ve been through, after everything we’ve done, and everything I’ve said, how she hasn’t put two and two together. I open my mouth, then shut it. Rejection isn’t something I think I can handle with her. For the briefest moment, disappointment flashes in her eyes and shatters my fear of being rejected. What have I got to lose? If I’m going to die tomorrow, then I want to die knowing that Emily is aware she’s loved by another human being.
“I’ve already fallen in love with you, Kitten.”
A bright pink blush flares up her throat and pools in her cheeks. Her hand shakes as she reaches up to push a thin lock of hair off her forehead, but even with her visible nervousness, her shoulders lift in relief as she straightens her spine. It all makes sense. The distance she’s kept—her strange attitude. I conjured up a million reasons to explain her behavior, how’d I forgo the simplest one? I tortured myself with incredulous scenarios and theories, working myself up for no reason when the answer was so obvious.
She loves me too.
“O-Oh..." She stutters. "I...I...wasn’t expecting—”
“And forget what I said about you falling in love with me after dinner. You’ve already fallen in love with me too.” I state.
Just like earlier, the churn of her stomach is visible as a bout of nausea crosses her countenance.
“How do you know you love me?” She asks, sheepishly.
Her large, doe eyes flick to mine. There’s a sad droop to her eyebrows at the end of a concerned curve. What is she so afraid of?
“How do I know?”
“Yeah.” She glances at her hands and threads her fingers together. “How do you know for sure?”
I exhale and flick off the headlights, drowning us in darkness—not complete darkness. I can still see the outline of her face, the slope of her neck and the curve of her breasts. I notice the change in her breathing in the darkness. It’s calm and relaxed—like there’s no more pressure to look me in the eyes when she speaks.
“I haven’t really thought about it.” I say, scratching my head—which reminds me I need a damn haircut. “I guess, in summary, the thought of not being with you for even a second makes me feel tight in the chest.”
Emily whips her head in my direction. “Does it?”
“Oh, yeah.”
Through the darkness, she reaches out and slips her warm hand into mine. It’s damp, but it no longer trembles and it feels so tiny enclosed in my giant paw.
I like this. Being able to tell her everything I’ve been thinking—everything I’ve been feeling. Why stop there?
“I find myself stealing glimpses at you all day. You’re so fucking cute.”
With her free hand, Emily covers her mouth and I can only imagine the fierce blush in her cheeks at this very second.
“Oh my God. Stop. You do not!”
If only she knew just how many times I catch myself watching her—admiring her. Perhaps then she wouldn’t ask me if I’m sure about loving her.
“I do.”
“What if I’m picking my nose?” She asks, shock and disgust dominating her tone as he cringes.
“I’m sure you’d find a cute way to do it.”
Emily’s beautiful, uncontrolled laughter fills the car and I add it to my list of things that make me certain that I love her.