Rush hour had already started by the time Lee hailed a cab. It crawled up Third Avenue as far as the forties, where the driver made a few slick moves crossing Forty-second Street. Lee tipped generously when they pulled up in front of the building on West Fifty-fourth Street.
There was no sign of Sergeant McKinney when Lee pushed open the door to the theatre. A few actors were there already-the Wilson twins and Carl Hawkins were sitting on the edge of the stage running their lines. Davillia brushed in a few minutes later, and while she seemed surprised to see Lee, she gave him a friendly smile as she bustled down the aisle with her coffee thermos and white bakery bag.
“I brought muffins for everyone today,” she sang out cheerfully. “I thought you all could use a boost.”
“Why, thank you, Madame Director,” Fred Wilson replied, taking a blueberry muffin from the bag. Lee couldn’t help noticing that he was dressed in a dark blue wool coat, whereas his brother Keith wore a down jacket. He was pondering this when the door swung open and the Atkins twins entered. They looked as though they had been arguing-Danny’s face was dark and moody, and Ryan looked preoccupied and upset. Ryan declined Davillia’s offer of muffins and went straight backstage. Danny sat in the audience, pulled out his iPhone, and began typing.
“As soon as Sara gets here we’ll start,” Davillia said chewing on a bran muffin. Danny interrupted his typing to give her a quick look, then, seeing Lee sitting behind him, went back to his iPhone.
“She’s late,” Carl said. “That’s not like her.”
“Should we be worried?” Davillia asked.
“She’s got a cop tailing her around the clock,” said Fred Wilson, finishing his blueberry muffin. “If she’s not safe with a police escort, who is?”
Danny looked up from his phone. “What?”
“Fred’s right,” said Carl. “NYPD gave her ’round-the-clock protection. She’s probably just running late from work. ”
There was the sound of quick, light footsteps on the stairs, and everyone turned to see Sara enter the theatre.
“Sorry I’m late,” she panted. “Got stuck at work.”
Lee studied Danny Atkins’s face, though it was hard to read his expression behind the black glasses. But just then his brother stepped out onto the stage, and the astonishment on his face told the entire story. When he saw Sara, he took a step backward, and his jaw dropped open.
Fred Wilson noticed him and laughed. “What’s up, Ryan? You look like you saw a ghost, man.”
Atkins didn’t answer, but his eyes and Lee’s met. Lee stood up, but before he could move, Danny Atkins shot out of his seat, his iPhone clattering to the floor.
“My god, Ryan,” he said. “My god. You-?”
The others looked confused-Davillia stopped chewing mid-bite, and Carl put down his coffee.
“What’s going on?” asked Sara, still at the back of the theatre.
Danny took a couple of steps toward the stage, but before he could get there, his brother reached into the prop bin and pulled out a rapier, the largest and most dangerous of the swords. With one violent motion, he whipped it across one of the brick columns on either side of the stage. The blunted cap fell to the floor, leaving a lethal, jagged piece of steel on the end of the sword.
Davillia gave a yelp and dropped her coffee, which splashed onto the ground, creating a thin brown river at the foot of the stage. Carl and Fred backed away from the proscenium, keeping their eyes on Ryan. Sara screamed and put her hands to her face.
“Why, Ryan?” Danny said, his voice more full of sorrow than anger. “Why did you do it?”
“You’ve never had a clue, have you?” said Ryan. “Little Lord Fauntleroy, always in everyone’s good graces. You have no idea what it was like being me! You stupid little prick.”
Danny took a step toward him.
“Don’t come any closer!” Ryan said, waving the weapon in front of him. “Drop that!” he yelled when Danny reached for his iPhone. “Blood isn’t thicker than water, brother-at least, not your blood.”
While this was going on, Lee managed to duck behind the black curtain that ran along the side of the south wall. Flattening his body against the bricks, he shimmied to the steps leading up to the stage. He darted out of the protection of the felt scrim and dove toward the basket of swords. Seeing him, Ryan lunged at him, but Lee grabbed an epee and rolled to the other side of the stage. Regaining his feet, he held the sword in front of him.
With a roar, Ryan charged him, but Lee parried his thrust, throwing Ryan off guard. Ryan stumbled and fell to his knees, but leapt to his feet quickly and came at Lee again, slashing wildly. Lee realized that all his high school fencing, with its decorum and good form, was of little use in this situation-but once again, he was able to parry Ryan’s wild thrust. When he reached the back of the stage, Atkins spun around and came at him a third time.
Lee stepped aside and tried a counterthrust, but the edge of Atkins’s blade caught him in the face. He felt a burning sensation on his cheek, and lost his footing, stumbling on the edge of the side curtain. Hearing the gasps from the others, he looked up to see Atkins’s sword flashing over his head. He rolled onto his back and evaded the descending blade by scrambling to the other side of the stage.
Ryan Atkins’s blue eyes burned with fury. “You call yourself a profiler? You idiot-and your sword is no mightier than your pen.”
“We’ll see about that,” Lee muttered as he got to his feet.
As Lee prepared himself for another charge, the theatre door banged open and three voices shouted in unison, “NYPD-drop your weapon!”
He looked up to see Detective Butts and Sergeant McKinney along with a uniformed officer, all three with their guns drawn.
“Drop it- now!” Butts repeated, clicking off the safety on his revolver.
Ryan Atkins looked at the three policemen confronting him and let his sword fall to the floor.
Sergeant McKinney produced a pair of handcuffs, which he gave to Butts.
The detective approached the stage. “Ryan Atkins, you’re under arrest for the murders of Mindy Lewis and Caroline Porchowsky.”
CHAPTER FOURTEEN
“So his expression gave him away, huh?” Butts said, popping a powdered cinnamon Munchkin in his mouth.
They were sitting in the Dunkin’ Donuts near the precinct. Ryan Atkins had been booked and was on his way to Rikers, so the detective was indulging in his favorite vice, fried dough coated in sugar.
“Yeah,” said Lee. “He obviously didn’t know he’d killed the wrong girl.”
“So why didn’t he leave the mask?”
“He must have heard someone coming. It’s a pretty risky thing to do in the middle of the afternoon, in broad daylight.”
“And he almost got away with it,” said Butts, taking a big gulp of coffee. “So his brother had no idea, huh?”
“I don’t think so.”
“I always thought twins were really close, and shared everything. Guess I’ve never really known any. How ’bout you, Doc? Ever know any twins?”
“Not identical ones. There was a pair of fraternal twins a year ahead of me at school, but I didn’t really know them well.”
Butts swallowed another Munchkin and wiped his mouth. “So I guess not all twins have this-‘mystical’ connection.”
“Apparently not. Ryan Atkins is obviously a disturbed young man. And it was probably his mother’s death that sent him over the edge. The timing is right-he took his first victim shortly afterwards.”
“He asked Mindy out too, then?”
“Nobody else in the company saw him do it, but my guess is that he did and she rejected him.”
“What about Danny? Pretty normal, would you say?”
“As far as I can tell. He seemed appalled by his brother’s crimes.”
“Hey, how did he know about Caroline’s death?”
“Saw it on the news feed on his iPhone. That’s why when his brother was surprised to see Sara alive, Danny knew Ryan was the killer.”