A number of things had occurred in that half hour.
Item: Boltan had died of the gunshot wounds, probably instantaneously.
Item: The gun which the murderer had dropped, a Smith & Wesson M39, had been turned over to the forensic lab men. If they had found any fingerprints on it, we hadn’t heard of it yet.
Item: The police cadets who had covered the Cellar’s two Street exits immediately after the shooting swore that no one had left.
Item: The entire stage area and the remainder of the club had been thoroughly searched without turning up any sign of the bearded killer.
Conclusions: The Amazing Boltan had been shot to death by a man who could not have left the Magic Cellar, was therefore still here, and yet, seemingly, was not here at all.
All of us were baffled, as we had said to each other several times in the past few minutes. Or, rather, Ardis and Cedric and Jan and I had said so; Steele sat in silence, which was unusual for him, and seemed to be brooding. When I asked him how he thought it had been done, since after all he was a master illusionist and a positive fanatic when it came to “impossible challenges,” he gave me a meditative look and declined comment.
We had considered, of course, the trapdoor in the stage, and had instantly ruled it out. For one thing, it was located in the middle of the stage itself — right behind where Boltan had fallen, as a matter of fact — and all of us had seen the killer exit stage right through the side curtain; there was no trap in that dressing room area. The tunnel leading from under the stage trap to the coatroom had been searched anyway, but had been empty.
I dredged my memory for possible illusions which would explain the bearded man’s vanishing act, but they all seemed to demand a piece of apparatus or specific condition which just wasn’t present. Houdini once vanished an elephant off the stage of the Hippodrome, but he had a large, specially made cage to do it. What did seem clear was that the murderer knew, and had applied, the principles of stage magic to come up with a brilliant new effect, and then had used it to commit a cold-blooded homicide on the stage of the Magic Cellar.
Captain Dickensheet approached our table and leaned across it, his palms hard on the edge. “Everybody,” he said pointedly to Cedric, “has to be somewhere. Don’t you have any ideas where the killer got to — and how?”
Cedric shook his head wearily. “There’s just no other way out of that dressing room besides the curtain onto the stage and the curtain next to the Spirit Cabinet,” he said. “The Cabinet is solid down to the floor, and the other walls are brick.”
“No gimmick or gizmo to open that Cabinet’s back wall?”
“No, none.”
“Even if there were,” Steele said, “it would merely propel the killer into the audience. The fact is, Captain, he could not have gotten out of the dressing room unseen. You have my professional word on that.”
Dickensheet straightened up, glaring. “Are you telling me, then, that what we all saw couldn’t have happened?”
“Not at all.” Steele stood abruptly and squeezed past my chair to the aisle. “I can assure you that what you saw is exactly what happened. Exactly.” Then, nodding to the table, he headed back to the stage left dressing room.
Dickensheet lowered his lanky frame into the aisle chair and stared across at the Carter the Great poster on the wall facing him. It depicted Carter astride a camel, surrounded by devils and imps, on his way to “steal” the secrets of the Sphinx and the marvels of the tomb of old King Tut. “Magicians!” the captain said, with feeling.
Cedric asked, “How much longer will you be holding everyone here?”
“I don’t know yet.”
“Well, can’t you just take all their names and addresses, and let them go home?”
“That’s not up to me,” Dickensheet said sourly. “You’ll have to talk to Lupoff, the homicide inspector in charge of the investigation.”
“All right.” Cedric sighed, and got up to do that.
I decided to leave the table too, because I was wondering what Steele was up to backstage. I excused myself and went into the left dressing room where I found Steele sitting in front of the mirror, carefully applying his stage makeup.
“What are you doing?” I demanded.
“It’s twenty till twelve, Matthew,” he said. “I’m on at midnight.”
“You don’t think they’re going to let you do your show now, do you?”
“Why not?”
“Well, they just took Boltan’s body off the stage fifteen minutes ago.”
“Ah yes,” Steele said. “Life and death, the eternal mysteries. My audience is still here, I note, and I’m sure they’d like to be entertained. Not that watching the police poking and prying into all the corners big enough to conceal a man isn’t entertaining.”
“I don’t understand why you’d even want to go on tonight,” I said. “There’s no way you can top the last performance. Besides, a spook show would hardly be in good taste right now.”
“On the contrary, it would be in perfect taste. Because during the course of it, I intend to reveal the identity of the murderer of Philip Boltan.”
“What!” I stared at him. “Do you mean you know how the whole thing was-done?”
“I do.”
“Well — how? How did the killer disappear?”
“The midnight show, Matthew,” he said firmly.
I looked at him with sufferance, and then nodded. Steele never does anything the easy way. As well, here was an opportunity to put on a kind of show of shows, and Steele is first and foremost a showman. Not that I objected to this, you understand. My business is publicity and public relations, and Steele’s flair for drama is the best kind of both. If he named the killer during his midnight show, and brought about the capture of the bearded man, the publicity would be fantastic.
“All right,” I said, “I’ll use my wiles to convince the cops to allow you to go ahead. But I hope you know what you’re doing.”
“I always know what I’m doing.”
“Ninety percent of the time, anyway.”
“Ask Ardis to come in here,” Steele said. “I’ll have to tell her what effects we’re doing now, and in what order.”
“You wouldn’t want to give me some idea of what’s going on, would you?”
Steele smiled a gentle, enigmatic smile. “It is now quarter to twelve, Matthew. I would like the show to begin at exactly midnight.”
Which meant that he had said all he intended to say for the time being, and I was therefore dismissed. So I went back out into the club where Captain Dickensheet was still sitting at our table with Jan and Ardis; Cedric had also returned, and had brought with him the dark, intense-looking inspector-in-charge, Lupoff.
When I got to the table I told Ardis that Steele wanted to see her. Immediately, she hurried to the stage left dressing room. I sat down and put on my best PR smile for Lupoff and Dickensheet.
“I have a request from Christopher Steele,” I said formally. “He wants to be allowed to do his midnight show.”
Both cops frowned, and Lupoff said, “I’m in no mood for levity.”
“Neither is Steele. He wants to do the show, he says, in order to name the murderer and explain how the vanishing act was done.”
Everyone at the table stared at me, Cedric and Jan looking relieved. Lupoff and Dickensheet, on the other hand, looked angrily disbelieving. The inspector said, “If Steele knows how and who, why the hell doesn’t he just come out here and say so?”
“You have to understand him,” I said. “He’s an artist, a showman. He thinks only in theatrical terms.” I went on to tell them about Steele’s idiosyncrasies, making it sound as though he were a genius who had to be treated with kid gloves — which was true enough. “Besides, if he solves the case for you, what can it hurt to let him unmask the killer in his own way?”