The snow was thick in the woods and Phoebe plowed ahead, plunging her stick into the snow before each step. Olivia followed, carefully stepping into Phoebe’s footprints, until they emerged in the small clearing.
“Meg’s at home.” Phoebe pointed to the smoke curling from the cottage chimney.
“She hasn’t been out at all.” Olivia gestured to the virgin expanse of snow leading from the gate to the front door. Cat prints zigzagged among the bushes, but there was no other indication that anyone had been around. “Although of c-course a broomstick wouldn’t leave tracks,” she added mischievously.
It was not a successful joke. Phoebe glared at her and stalked off up the path.
Olivia stumbled after her. “Oh, c-come on, Phoebe. It was in jest.”
“I didn’t think it was funny.” Phoebe raised her stick to bang on the door.
“I’m sorry,” Olivia said. “Forgive me?”
Phoebe glanced at her and then smiled. “Of course. Come on, let’s go in before we turn into icicles.” She banged on the door with her stick.
It was a minute or two before they heard the bar being lifted and the door creaked open. Meg, wrapped in a thick blanket, her head swathed in flannel, tried to smile and grimaced instead. She stood back, gesturing that they should come in.
“What is it? Are you ill?” Phoebe asked in concern.
“Toothache,” Meg mumbled. “You have to help me draw it.” She laid a hand to her flannel-wrapped cheek. “I’ve tried everything. Oil of cloves, witch hazel. It has to come out.”
“My father pulled one of my teeth when I was little,” Olivia remarked. “He tied string around the door latch and slammed the door. It hurt,” she added rather doubtfully.
“It won’t hurt as much as it does now,” Meg declared. “Come now, Phoebe, put me out of my misery.” She sat on a small stool beside the fire, and the one-eared cat jumped onto her lap.
Meg’s teeth were a constant source of trouble for her. Phoebe had performed this service for her friend before and knew how to be both swift and gentle. She found the string, located the rotten tooth, and the task was over in a second. Meg rushed to the basin in the corner of the cottage, while Phoebe stared at the tooth dangling from the string. The cat jumped onto the windowsill and began to wash himself.
“What a lot of blood,” Olivia observed with habitual curiosity. “You wouldn’t think such a small thing could c-cause so much.”
“You wouldn’t think it could cause so much pain,” Meg said thickly, raising her head from the basin and reaching up for a vial on the shelf above. She rinsed out her mouth with the contents and then sighed with relief. “Such agony… you can’t believe.”
“Do you want the tooth?” Phoebe handed it to her.
Meg took it and tied a knot in the string, slipping it over her head. “Maybe it’ll act as a talisman against future toothache.” She grimaced and touched her still-swollen face. “Thank heavens you came.”
“There’s something I came to tell you.” Phoebe’s face was suddenly very grave. “There’s talk of a witch in the village. The vicar was raving this morning.”
Meg nodded slowly. “That’s no surprise. You remember when you were here last I was called to a sick child?”
“Yes.” Phoebe perched on the edge of the table.
“Well, the child died soon after I physicked him.”
Olivia ceased her examination of Meg’s alabaster jars and glass vials of potions. “What of?”
Meg shrugged and drew her blanket closer around her. “I can’t say. He was fine when I left, but according to his mother fell into convulsions an hour later. He was dead when I reached him.”
“Sometimes there’s nothing you can do,” Phoebe said hesitantly.
“You and I know that,” Meg said dourly. “The child’s mother cursed me. The father spat at me. There was a crowd there, murmuring and whispering.”
Phoebe crossed her arms over her breast with an involuntary shudder. There was a jolt of fear deep in her belly. “What were they saying?”
“That I had laid a curse on the child.”
“So it was you the vicar was bellowing about,” Olivia said, coming over to Phoebe. She laid a hand on her shoulder.
“Like as not,” Meg said. “Superstition is an unpredictable evil.” She reached up to the drying rack for a handful of thyme and another of verbena. “Set the kettle on the trivet, Olivia. I need some tea for the swelling.”
“It seems to have come out of nowhere,” Phoebe said. “It was but last week that you cured the Bailey girl’s fever… And look at the Harvey children. Last month they could barely walk with the rickets, and now they’re running all over the village.”
“That was then. This is now.”
“Maybe on the way home I’ll pay a visit to the Bear in the village, hear what people are saying. If they are talking such foolishness, I’ll have a few things to say of my own.” Phoebe’s eyes snapped.
Meg shook her head. “Have a care, Phoebe. Tar sticks.” She dropped herbs into an earthenware teapot as the kettle began to steam.
“Tar doesn’t stick to Lady Granville,” Phoebe said stoutly.
“This tar is no respecter of rank,” Meg replied. “You remember Lady Constance… she was not spared the witch finder.”
Phoebe frowned. “But she was accused by her husband’s mistress. And when that was known, she was released.”
Meg inclined her head in faint acknowledgment, but Phoebe could tell that she was unconvinced. “She was still not spared the witch finder,” Meg repeated. “In open court.”
“That would be terrible,” Olivia said, turning pale. To be exposed naked in open court for the minute examination of the witch finder with his long pins was a horror not to be contemplated.
“An understatement,” Meg said dryly. “But we must hope it won’t come to that.” She poured water on the herbs in the teapot, and the fragrant steam filled the small space.
“Well, I shall see what I can discover.” Phoebe bent to kiss Meg. “Are you sure there’s nothing else you need this afternoon?”
“No, my dear.” Meg patted her cheek. “Sleep is my greatest need and that I can get alone.”
“Well, send word to the house if you’re uneasy. Unless…” Phoebe paused. “Unless you’d consider coming back with us now. No one will harass you under Lord Granville’s roof. And when it blows over, you can return.”
Meg shook her head decisively. “No, indeed not. I thank you, but I’m not about to leave my home because of some ignorant mischief makers.”
Phoebe had expected nothing else and didn’t press the matter.
“I wonder what my father would say if we brought Meg home with us,” Olivia said thoughtfully as they made their way back down the path.
“What could he possibly say?” Phoebe asked in genuine puzzlement.
Olivia cast her a quick look. “He might not see things the way you do.”
Phoebe frowned. She had noticed that Cato did not see the issues of the village and his tenants the way she did.
“My father is a very just magistrate and very generous to his tenants,” Olivia said. “But he doesn’t like to g-get personally involved. He’s the lord of the manor; it’s not his business.”
“Well, it’s my business,” Phoebe said after a minute’s thought. “I do like to get personally involved.”
“Perhaps you c-can change his view,” Olivia offered but without much conviction.
“Perhaps,” Phoebe said. They had reached the lane leading back to the manor. “You go on home. I’m going to make a detour in the village, ask some questions about Meg, and I’ll follow you.”
“Should you go alone?” Olivia sounded doubtful.
“They might not talk so freely if you’re there,” Phoebe said. “And no one’s going to molest me. These are my friends.”
“Yes, you see, that’s the difference between you and my father,” Olivia pointed out. “He would never c-consider that his tenants were his friends.”
Phoebe contemplated this insight as she hurried through the village. She had no doubt that Olivia was right, but how to reconcile that attitude of Cato’s with her own? Therein lay the puzzle. She was firmly convinced her own view was the only correct one, so if someone had to change, it would have to be Cato.